Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!


Apparently the US has suspended sonar operations around Hawai due to the damaging effect to the whale and dolphin population.

I just love whales and dolphins!!!
I'm surprised (but glad), that the navy is finally admitting the potential damage sonar can cause to the marine life. We had a similar incident along the northwest coast some years back when a pod of pilot whales stranded themselves on a beach, and the cause was thought to have been a destroyer banging away with its active sonar in the bay.

The Oregon coast is along the humback whale migration route, and I hope to go see them this year. Absolutely stunning animals.


War Hero
As a former UCSM I have always regarded the allegations of active sonar freaking out the marine life as so much Greenpeace bullshit. If anything I reckon active TXs attract the sealife. Pilot whales have often been found stranded on the west coast of Tasmania, an awfully long way from any fleet excersise areas, yet Greenpeace still try to blame the Navy.

Once I was fishing in a mates boat off Botany Bay. All was quiet and a cold beer was going down well when I heard the unmistakeable 'tambourine rattle' of an SQS23 sonar. Over on the horizon was a DDG and the transmissions were reverberating through the aluminium hull of the boat. We caught quite a few fish that day, seems the sonar didn't bother them at all. I wish Greenpeace could have seen it. :p
Whales and the like have stranded themselves since time immemorial, and so far Greenpeace has failed to come up as gfar as I have seen with a good explanation how modern sonar does cause more standings than normal. This of course does not mean they are wrong, but they do have a reputation for using bad science and campaigning on objectives which turn out to be scientifically wrong.

At present I for one have great difficulty in believing them on any subject, unless others independantly support their assertions with good scientific explanations.

Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
soleil Forces Network: "Killer Whales Could Make Things Orca-ward For Military Exercise" Bases / Shore Est 0
P It's a good thing that submarines are smaller than whales Submariners 11
soleil Times: "Royal Navy Ship Torpedoed Whales In Falklands" History 39
soleil Rossshire Journal: "Ross 'War Games' No Fun For Whales, Says MSP" The Fleet 0
The_Caretaker 2 Whales Nautical Jokes 0
P If swimming is so good for you, why are whales so fat ? Diamond Lil's 17
I Dolphins in the surface fleet Joining the Royal Navy 39
R What do you go through in order to earn your Dolphins? Submariners 24
MoD_RSS New tech teams to protect dolphins and create next generation of super strong aluminium MoD News 0
BreathingOutOnTheWayUp Earned Your Dolphins? If "Yes" then Read On. Submariners 8
G Dolphins Submariners 2
gerrysurfs Wearing of dolphins and being PMU submarines Submariners 16
Ballistic Question Time Dolphins? Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 18
D Can you wear dolphins upon return to general service? Submariners 37
soleil Dolphins For The Duchess Submariners 10
S How long does it take a submariner to get his Dolphins? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 8
1 Embroidered Combat Dolphins? Submariners 21
W dolphins Petitions 28
I Can I wear my Dolphins? Submariners 13
K submariner pay and getting your dolphins Submariners 25
K submariner pay and getting your dolphins Submariners 2
etsandy Image of Dolphins? Submariners 2
H receiving your dolphins Submariners 30
I Cry Baby Dolphins Submariners 51
soleil RN Exercise/Stranded Dolphins/ZSL Report Current Affairs 4
B Boat and dolphins Submariners 6
WreckerL Dolphins award accident Submariners 4
soleil Newly qualified submariner swallows his Dolphins Submariners 28
5dits Dolphins poss killed by Warship Sonar Current Affairs 55
S Dolphins Submariners 3
shellbackmac Introduction of Dolphins in the early '70s Submariners 32
whitemouse Miami Dolphins Diamond Lil's 7
Permissionopenmuzzledoor How old are meeeee dolphins. Submariners 24
H Submarine dolphins Submariners 13
GSSR_Vvd Earning your dolphins Submariners 12
slim Bay dolphins have Welsh dialect The Gash Barge 0
creeper Wearing Dolphins on mess undress Submariners 12
future_ET(MES) your dolphins Submariners 34
Similar threads

Latest Threads

New Posts