Very sad ...........

i can honestly say these are quite possibly the saddest two articles I have ever read/seen in my life ;
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
She must have been in there a while from the look of her hands.
Omayra Sanchez (the girl pictured) was 12 years old at the time and lived with her parents, her brother and an uncle. However, prior to the tragedy, her mother had traveled to Bogotá on business. Omayra could not escape and was trapped under her own home's concrete plaque and debris.
When rescue teams tried to help her, they realized that her legs were trapped. The only feasible option was to pull her out by breaking and ripping her legs off. Omayra remained strong until the last moment of her life. According to people who were by her side during those moments, the little girl wanted to live, saying her only worry was to go back to school.
The people who were trying to save her life begged the pilots of overflying helicopters to get a pump so the water could have been drained out. After two days a pump was delivered, but unfortunately it did not work properly and finally got stuck because of the mud and debris.


http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/4231020.stm


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

RoofRat

War Hero
How could any feeling human being photograph something like that, and then drive away?
Fcukin right he should commit sidaways, he was absolute cnut!
RoofRat
 
I don't believe that picture, because as RoofRat says, no way you could walk away and leave the kid there, unless you are mentaly deficient.
 
Lingyai said:
I don't believe that picture, because as RoofRat says, no way you could walk away and leave the kid there, unless you are mentaly deficient.
Remember we're talking about journos here who are morally deficient! :evil:
 
Always_a_Civvy said:
Lingyai said:
I don't believe that picture, because as RoofRat says, no way you could walk away and leave the kid there, unless you are mentaly deficient.
Remember we're talking about journos here who are morally deficient! :evil:
That's the most complimentary thing you can say about them..
 

Seadog

War Hero
Moderator
As tragic as this story is and as scummy as photo journalists can be, this story is 22 years old.
trapped in debris caused by a mudslide following the eruption of a volcano in Colombia in 1985.
Hardly current.

The article on photojournalists ethics or lack of is 17 months old though it can be argued that it is eternal and therfore 'current' but looking at some of the responses, it is better off in the Quarterdeck.
 
Lingyai said:
I don't believe that picture, because as RoofRat says, no way you could walk away and leave the kid there, unless you are mentaly deficient.
Sorry but you are so wrong!!!!!!

I would say the photographer would be hanging about to wait for the vulture to start picking to get that classic pic that will pay thousands.

Scum of the earth!!!!
 

josiecats

War Hero
Backpacker1uk said:
Lingyai said:
I don't believe that picture, because as RoofRat says, no way you could walk away and leave the kid there, unless you are mentaly deficient.
Sorry but you are so wrong!!!!!!

I would say the photographer would be hanging about to wait for the vulture to start picking to get that classic pic that will pay thousands.

Scum of the earth!!!!
i totaly agree with you..... they would wait til the last dying breath..
we have seen this type of [email protected] before...... rember the young naked girl runing down the road..... what type of person can walk away..???
 

Shakey

War Hero
The one with the vulture is a real phot, I saw it some years ago in the Sunday Times or summat.

And yes the photographer did walk away.

Question is, if the child was infected with summat would you risk picking up the infection and becoming a casualty yourself? :???:
 
Shakey said:
The one with the vulture is a real phot, I saw it some years ago in the Sunday Times or summat.

And yes the photographer did walk away.

Question is, if the child was infected with summat would you risk picking up the infection and becoming a casualty yourself? :???:
seriously??
 

josiecats

War Hero
wet_blobby said:
Shakey said:
The one with the vulture is a real phot, I saw it some years ago in the Sunday Times or summat.

And yes the photographer did walk away.

Question is, if the child was infected with summat would you risk picking up the infection and becoming a casualty yourself? :???:
seriously??
yes i would to save a child i would ....
 

Shakey

War Hero
Yes, seriously.

If the photographer has had the fear of God put into them by being told the refugees might have Ebola or summat mental like that then would you seriously expect anyone to approach them without wearing a full-on noddy suit?

And if the child did have some life threatening disease in some shit hole refugee camp in Africa then you're not going to save them, they are already the walking dead. This is what we call triage.

That photograph is probably the most powerful image taken in recent times and raises very interesting questions concerning morality.

What would I do? Dunno, 'cos I don't know the full story behind the image. If the photographer had been told 'Don't go near dying refugees 'cos they have very bad lurgy and you'll catch it and die' then that's one story. If he had been told 'Don't go near refugees 'cos they've got athlete's foot' then that's another.
 

sgtpepperband

War Hero
Book Reviewer
Photojournalists are taught to maintain a kind of hypocratic oath, similar to that of a doctor, in maintaining impartiality - they are not to become involved with the story, save anyone accuse them of influencing the story they are reporting on. They are the reflector, not the director. Remember the stories of journos strategically placing teddy bears in the rubble and wreckage after Lockerbie and the Clapham rail crash?

What of the photographs of Iraqis being tortured; should the person taking the photos also have intervened? Aren't they responsible for what happened, by recording the incidents rather than stopping them?

Bringing these images to the public domain is to raise awareness of the bigger picture. The images of the burning Vietnamese girl; the Auschwitz survivors being liberated; and the vulture watching the Sudanese baby; all horrific events, but the images brought awareness to what caused these atrocities. The loss of her life may have saved the lives of millions through famine relief brought on by Carter's photo and subsequent report.

Kevin Carter's story is a unique but sad one nonetheless, and I bet most people here would have a similar moral dilemma if in a similar situation. All those who are medically trained will know that you must look after yourself first, regardless of the consequences, as you might become injured too. A simplistic POV I agree, but he maintained the ethos of photojournalism - and he paid the ultimate price for his actions, despite the plaudits he received as a result.
 
"paid the ultimate price for his actions"

Having a blonde moment here, did his catch something and die or was he outcast for not helping the child?
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
D How could they mess my sons Navy Career up !!! SO VERY SAD Joining the Royal Navy 21
stan_the_man A very sad reminder of inept foreign policy. Current Affairs 0
scouse A very sad Story Indeed The Fleet Air Arm 30
trelawney126 A Very Sad Milestone Current Affairs 3
W Some very sad news Diamond Lil's 19
The_Caretaker It's very sad! Diamond Lil's 26
MoD_RSS Study finds very low numbers of COVID-19 outbreaks in schools MoD News 0
MoD_RSS HPV vaccine drives cancer causing infections down to very low levels MoD News 0
MoD_RSS No-deal is a very real prospect. We must ensure we are ready: article by Michael Gove MoD News 0
J Very torn between engineering and intelligence Joining the Royal Navy 13
vauxhall The Armed Forces Pension is Very Good Indeed! Finance & Pensions 0
MoD_RSS Speech: International law is the very foundation of peace and security: Harriet Baldwin's UN Security Council statement MoD News 0
Sugar_Rush Interview- Advice and Tips very welcome Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 5
J Very worried for hms Raleigh Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 21
D Approaching 25 and very concerned... Joining the Royal Navy 2
LateToTheParty Super fast application process... it's now very real Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
MoD_RSS Press release: If the Somme was fought today, it would be a very different battle. MoD News 0
Chicogiz Chicojizz’s Very Own Bucket of Shit. The Gash Barge 95
M I'm very worried about the royal marine psychometric test although I can get through the booklet goo RMR 14
Seaweed A Very Interesting Rolex History 6
S Thank you very much! Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 36
C I'm very, very silly Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 2
O Very Confused,need a lot of help!! AIR ENGINEERING TECHNICIAN Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 32
finknottle When We Were Very Young Diamond Lil's 83
trelawney126 Queen gets new Handbag, it's very effective The Gash Barge 0
BillyNoMates Merchant ship. Be afraid - be very afraid. Diamond Lil's 18
Rumrat Your Very FIRST OFFENCE in the Andrew. Diamond Lil's 100
R i have my rt tuesday.. any tips are very welcome!! Diamond Lil's 10
Rumrat Very near escapes, and I do mean near. The Gash Barge 0
finknottle Be afraid, be very afraid and get your tin foil out. Current Affairs 2
Good CO VERY limited search / Last 50 following upgrade Site Issues 17
S Very Smart The Internet - Best and Worst 10
Topstop Some RAF being very naughty boys? Current Affairs 1
finknottle A very moving Story The Corps 2
S Mean?or just very careful? The Gash Barge 4
soleil Wishing a very Happy Birthday to SJRM_RN! The Quarterdeck 9
soleil "Shaking Queen's Hand Was Very Special - Ark Royal's Chef" The Fleet 1
C Applying from overseas. Please help - very confused. Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 21
scouse Not very bright, by The Secretary of State Current Affairs 15
shag_shacker very interesting chat from the FAA requirements manager The Fleet Air Arm 37
F A Very Belated Pickle Night Social & Reunions 4
scouse Son of a very very famous FAA VC Recipient The Fleet Air Arm 0
BillyNoMates This bloke is a very clever one... Diamond Lil's 6
S The Very Last One !! Diamond Lil's 27
BillyNoMates Fizzy Pop - a very sexy advertisement. Diamond Lil's 1
soleil Guardian: "Trident: Deadly - And Very, Very Expensive" Submariners 2
R Poetry Worth a Read- very apt. The Quarterdeck 4
soleil Independent: "A Very Modern Military Partnership" Current Affairs 9
P the gash barge and VERY sensitive ppl.. lol The Gash Barge 5
P Epilepsy when i was VERY YOUNG!!! Health & Fitness 16
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

Top