Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

US Brown Job Mouths off about the Iran Incident

Oil_Slick

War Hero
During the engagement several thoughts crossed my mind:

How will this incident be perceived, given that Syria is an enemy of the United States?

Will my decisions escalate poor relations between two sworn enemies?

Will attacking and taking the offense, given my enemies' numerical and fire superiority, get my men killed or kill the enemy?


Well what the gobshiite seems to have missed is that crucial term 'enemy'…

Last time I checked we were not at war with Iran and retain Diplomatic Relations.
 

chieftiff

War Hero
Moderator
WJ_Poo_Pong_McPlop said:
I choked on my frosties yesterday when reading this and thought you all might like to see how the good name of the Navy and Marines is being trashed in Texas.

http://www.star-telegram.com/242/story/64570.html

I think the link expires after a week and I don't know the forum rules about cutting and pasting copyrighted material.

Is that a news article or the first page of his "best selling action hero" book. He even think Felix Carmen is a Royal Marine, good research!
 
"I ordered my machine gunners to return fire"...or some such twaddle...lucky man he had some machine guns, something that the boarding party didn't.
 

F169

War Hero
Nor was the USA at war with Syria but then the Iranians didnt fire at all so his comparison is hardly fair.
 
A well thought out and thoroughly researched article. The man is a credit to the Yanks. If only we had that quality of journalism in this country!
 

ukdaytona

War Hero
The RN/RM were on water NOT in the middle of a sand pit
The RN/RM were grabbed in day light not middle of the night (04:00??)

And as previous posts, the RIBS didnt have radar and according to reports the Iranians came up on the blind side or do the RM guys now have x-ray vision ?

I also wonder if those brave yanks had air support on call, overheard AWACS cover, artillery support, Buger King and or Big Macs on rapid response, bowling alley and cinema

I would truly love to see the yanks in a similar situation and to see the response. What would be the US response at home if they didnt fight back and were grabbed ??? All out assault on Iran maybe??

What if they did fight back and were all killed - all out assault on Iran as realiation perhaps???
 
WJ_Poo_Pong_McPlop said:
It's a pile of pants, full of errors, written by a trigger happy septic. Do RIB's even have radar?

Not a serving member of the forces ?

"popped up on ... radar" is an eupemism for suddenly seeing/noticing something - doesn't mean that the things actually had radar fitted - but you never know with these modern RIB thingys
:)
 

Oil_Slick

War Hero
ukdaytona said:
I would truly love to see the yanks in a similar situation and to see the response. What would be the US response at home if they didnt fight back and were grabbed ??? All out assault on Iran maybe??


Well if we were being bitchy we could remind our trans-atlantic cousins of these incidents…

USS Peublo

US Embassy siezed in Tehran

3 US Army bods 'detained' by Yugoslavs

US Navy EP-3 forced down by China


Nope, thought so, they didn't fight in those incidents either… :?
 
whitemouse said:
WJ_Poo_Pong_McPlop said:
It's a pile of pants, full of errors, written by a trigger happy septic. Do RIB's even have radar?

Not a serving member of the forces ?

"popped up on ... radar" is an eupemism for suddenly seeing/noticing something - doesn't mean that the things actually had radar fitted - but you never know with these modern RIB thingys
:)

The radar statement in the article is in quotation marks. I took that to mean that the author is saying that these are Lt Carman's words.
 
Quote 'we came under intense fire from the Syrian side of the border'

The difference is that our guys didn't come under fire and we don't usually shoot first. Not cricket old boy.

Quote 'Syria is an enemy of the United States'

Really? well we are not at war with Iran and therefore don't start shooting at them without first being shot at.

Quote 'My soldiers and I were awarded medals for valor because, while executing our mission, we stood our ground on our side of the border and returned fire against an overwhelming enemy force.

Bravo, and so you should have been, because YOU WERE FIRED UPON.

Added to the ones you got for passing out of basic training and for crossing the atlantic and for standing the longest in the BX queue.

P2 standing by for incoming (which I will of course return)
 

steveeas

Newbie
It's painful for any service when this happens. If you're in another service, critique comes easily. As disappointed as I was about this whole affair, it reminded me of my service's own painful incidents; the P-3 that landed on a Chinese airfield instead of ditching, the USS Pueblo, and USS Liberty. No service has a monopoly on mishandled incidents. Hopefully this sad affair will be a wakeup call for all of us.
 
Quite clearly Luis Carlos Montalván has failed to find out the true facts of the incident before shooting his mouth off. Perhaps if he had led his own patrol some what more effectively he would not have been caught in an ambush that put the lives of his men at risk. As a mere captain I would suggest that he should pay more attention to his military studies than trying to earn a few dollars writing articles for the hick press or perhaps he will find he has reached the summitt of his military carreer
 

nelsons_blood

Badgeman
This all boils down to Luis Carlos Montalvan being a twat.
Whether it was right or wrong to be there, they were and when confronted by a numerically superior and more heavily armed force, the actions of the 15 (or most of them) ws entirely correct. It is not until after that when it all went horribly wrong.
Just can't understand why the whole world hate the Elmers (including their greatest allies!!!)
 

sweeney

Lantern Swinger
You see comrades, this is where its all gone wrong for the andrew. Cap'n Ricardo Montalban is better trained than Lt Carman RM (ahem)... How else can you you observe a maelstrom of bullets coming from a truck?

Now I'm no expert, but thats not right is it>? If only there was some way of getting hold of cap'n Montalban and asking him...

oooh look, here is the fort benning (which is where our good cap'n is serving) website... and blow me there is a phonebook option... :wink:

https://www.infantry.army.mil/fbhome/sites/local/
 

finknottle

Banned
Prick, who are they to bad-mouth our Armed Services? They cannot even protect the Iraqi Parliament which is supposedly in a secure area.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
B Advice and Help from a Brown Job Nearest & Dearest 41
trelawney126 Gordon Brown takes on Moonlighting Job Current Affairs 16
Blackrat Brown Job Diamond Lil's 19
soleil BBC4 - Wednesday, September 16th 2020 - 9 pm - Britain's Greatest Pilot: The Extraordinary Story of Captain Winkle Brown The Fleet Air Arm 2
MoD_RSS Press release: Brown trout and endangered crayfish rescued from river pollution MoD News 0
iipodgeii HAIX Brown Boots, A Problem? Joining the Royal Navy 11
Bad CO Auction of Estate of Captain Eric M 'Winkle' Brown The Fleet Air Arm 10
Ageing_Gracefully Captain Eric 'Winkle' Brown Current Affairs 25
Ageing_Gracefully Captain Eric “Winkle” Brown CBE, DSC, AFC Royal Navy History 1
Seaweed Heads up, Captain Eric 'Winkle' Brown doco History 13
soleil Forces Sauces - Corporal Ketchup and Brigadier Brown - at Tesco Charity 0
soleil Radio 4 - iPM - Interview With Captain Eric Winkle Brown The Fleet Air Arm 2
scouse Captain Eric Winkle Brown The Fleet Air Arm 0
F Has Gordon Brown finally got the message ? Diamond Lil's 6
stan_the_man Me and Brown Hatters Diamond Lil's 3
SONAR-BENDER I will NOT be opening any brown enveopes from the UK..... Submariners 16
trelawney126 Former PM Brown to Rescue the Euro The Gash Barge 4
trelawney126 Gordon Brown not Popular Candidate IMF Current Affairs 18
stan_the_man San Fransisco brown hatters Diamond Lil's 32
soleil STV: Rosyth Jobs Threat If Carriers Axed, Says Gordon Brown Current Affairs 3
scouse Captain Eric Winkle Brown Interview The Fleet Air Arm 3
BreathingOutOnTheWayUp A question of honour for Gordon Brown Current Affairs 45
alfred_the_great Brown's gone Current Affairs 28
finknottle War Artist Stuart Brown The Corps 3
lonestar Gordon Brown dies (jk) Diamond Lil's 10
Naval_Gazer Brown admits cash for military WAS cut back Current Affairs 17
S Former Defence Chiefs Challenge Gordon Brown Over Iraq Current Affairs 4
Passed-over_Loggie Gordon Brown denies claims he mistreated staff Current Affairs 23
NotmeChief Brown trying for the sympathy vote? Current Affairs 10
soleil Grdn: "Brown rejects claim UK troops lacked proper kit" Current Affairs 5
soleil Herald (Scot): "Brown will commit to fleet of warships" Current Affairs 4
jesse Brown Hatters Brothel in Bermuda? The Quarterdeck 11
finknottle Is Brown attempting to suffocate the Chilcot Inquiry? Current Affairs 15
labrum Is Brown having a laugh? Current Affairs 3
X.R.D Harry brown Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 15
NotmeChief Even MORE Brown gaffs Current Affairs 56
trelawney126 Brown Proposal = Worldwide Snub Current Affairs 7
trelawney126 Brown and Mandelson in New Push for Blair Diamond Lil's 10
Ja5on Brown U-turn on territorial cuts Current Affairs 0
Guzzler "The man in the brown shirt at the back..." Current Affairs 36
trelawney126 Brown Avoids the Question. This takes the biscuit! Diamond Lil's 1
slim Reasons why David Cameron WILL is better than Blair or Brown The Gash Barge 11
rod-gearing Pink or Brown Diamond Lil's 20
C Listening to Brown's conference speech Current Affairs 15
Ja5on Brown targets crime in key speech Current Affairs 15
S Derren Brown - Control The Nation, who is going to do it? Diamond Lil's 68
H Brown envelopes Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 6
sgtpepperband Derren Brown: How he REALLY predicted the Lottery... Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 1
F Brown sauce or Ketchup ! the OGGY VAN at Jupiter Point ? Diamond Lil's 47
finknottle Gordon Brown to announce Iraq war enquiry (Your Views) Current Affairs 67
Similar threads


















































Top