Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Trident Strategy viz Independance

broadside

War Hero
Probably factually correct as a bit of top-line assessment goes but highly unlikely in the context of the significant damage to employment/Scottish economy if
a) the Jocks did vote for independence
b) they then decided to close Faslane down

There must be other options south of the border aside from the obvious ones that the MoD have chosen to share with the meeja and, even if there aren't, surely our US allies would never permit the UK to lose the deterrent - options to lease space/capability in US facilities perhaps?
 

Sumo

War Hero
The option for the UK to maintain the nuclear deterrent allows them to have a say at the big boys table, the committees’ that are attended by only nuclear deterrent owning counties.
To lose it would be political slamming our top Brass and politician’s would not want to have to take , so whether in the public domain or not I am sure they will be a policy/stratergy somewhere of what to do if we cast Scotland adrift.
 

trelawney126

War Hero
Given the political drive to save money and the sheer deceiptfulness of Cameron, ably tutored by Bliar, he'd turn up to the Top Table with a picture of Trident stating that with defence cuts, he could blow up the picture if they liked. Anything to keep our seat.
 

Rumrat

War Hero
I have been into the heartland of Scotland quite recently in as much visiting family.
Despite the insistence of Comrade Salmon to include the 16-17 year olds in his bid to become "king "of Scotland, it is predicted amongst the masses I met he will fail.
He sees his plan to allow the lower life forms to vote as cunning but it may well bite him yet.
As in any place within the UK the minority have a good voice and the majority as usual remain silent. The young educated Scot of which there are many in rural quarters are far from the calibre of those Salmon depends on and more profuse. They know that Independence will in its first rush give Scotland a push up the ladder of recognition.
They also see the snake waiting at the top as first rushes usually give way to reality, like buying a house and three months later there is more to pay than the mortgage.
Turn outs for the elections that have given rise to the SNP have not been anywhere near dense, but on an issue of the magnitude of Independence this is sure to be the case. Brave heart may be a film that pushes propaganda at the susceptible, but most Scots are well aware of the reality of a divided Kingdom and the pitfalls that come with the package.
So although contingency plans may be prudent, the reality is it is doubtfull they will ever be more than that,.....plans.
 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator
If (when) he gets the No vote, has he said what his future plans for Scotland are. I've heard shedloads of spin and rhetoric if they get Independance but nothing about the SNP plans if it goes pete tong. I assume another re-worded referendum and so on until he hears what he wants?
 

Sumo

War Hero
Rummers
I had some comment to make about you north of the boards and family but after BOB slating yesterday we had better stay on track.
Good balanced view with emphasise in any real direction
 

Sumo

War Hero
If (when) he gets the No vote, has he said what his future plans for Scotland are. I've heard shedloads of spin and rhetoric if they get Independance but nothing about the SNP plans if it goes pete tong. I assume another re-worded referendum and so on until he hears what he wants?[/QUOTE]

The scream of Freedom as he imitates Brave Heart! Perhaps?
 

Rumrat

War Hero
Another brick not yet in the wall is that of finance.
Two companies that relatives of mine work for have more than suggested to its employees that upon Independence all UK instigated tax concessions would cease. ( Government incentives to move north to ease low employment areas)
In these conditions if the newly formed republic would not/ could not maintain the concessions they would cut and run.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
A HM S/M Trident Submariners 12
MoD_RSS News story: UK troops combat ready for NATO Exercise Trident Juncture MoD News 0
L Question about Trident D5 Submariners 6
MoD_RSS Statement to Parliament: PM Commons statement on future of Trident: 18 July 2016 MoD News 0
Stirlin Trident...a debate. Current Affairs 0
N Corbyn: UK could keep Trident submarines but without warheads Current Affairs 50
Stirlin Faslane/Trident Current Affairs 15
J When does trident expire? MoD News 28
Andy B Latest Trident Debate Current Affairs 0
Tomahawk Where might Trident go? Current Affairs 34
soleil Telegraph: "Trident Cuts 'Need Not Hit Deterrent'" Submariners 1
Strangelove Three reasons the LibDems deserve to get shot down over Trident Current Affairs 2
trelawney126 Nuclear Fuel for boats and Trident production suspended Submariners 0
trelawney126 Trident replacement and the Treasury Submariners 7
soleil "Guardian: "MoD: Trident Submarines Cannot Be Moved From Scotland To Plymouth" Submariners 30
SONAR-BENDER Salmond and Trident Submariners 1
MoD_RSS MOD signs Trident support contract Current Affairs 2
trelawney126 350m MOD Contract Trident Current Affairs 7
trelawney126 Trident Class stopped my Car Submariners 3
soleil "Trident Protesters Renew Call For Nuclear Disarmament During Blockade At Faslane" Submariners 9
soleil Herald (Scotland): "Trident Sub Crippled In Accident" Submariners 4
soleil BBC Scotland: 10:45 PM - Wednesday 23rd February 2011 - "Who Needs Trident?" Submariners 2
trelawney126 Cameron Speaks on Trident Policy Current Affairs 10
soleil STV: "Church Calls For Trident Clarification" Submariners 10
soleil Guardian: "Defence Cuts Threaten Trident Nuclear Safety, Warns MoD" Submariners 0
alfred_the_great Trident Delays Current Affairs 13
WarfareSpecialistToBe Trident replacement?? Current Affairs 9
dublinclontarf Trident safe? Current Affairs 17
soleil The Register: "Trident Delay: Cunning Plan Or Bad Idea?" Submariners 1
soleil D. Mail: "Decision on £20bn Trident renewal to be delayed" Submariners 9
P DT article on Russians (trying) to track Trident boats Submariners 13
soleil Reuters: UK May Axe Carriers, Trident Safe - Defence Source The Fleet 26
soleil BBC: "Trident Costs Must Come From MoD Budget, Osborne Says" Submariners 17
soleil Guardian: "Trident: Deadly - And Very, Very Expensive" Submariners 2
soleil Guardian: "Life On Trident: 3 Months Under The Waves" Submariners 0
S Devon Candidates Clash Over Trident Boats Current Affairs 9
soleil Telegraph: "Labour ditches Trident Pledge" Submariners 4
soleil H. Advertiser: Helensburgh & Trident: Election Epicentre Submariners 0
soleil "Innovative Project Underway to Refurbish Trident Jetty" Submariners 0
soleil Teleg: Conservatives to delay Trident replacement by 5 years Submariners 4
L Trident cuts Submariners 15
soleil Times: "Labour backing away from plans to replace Trident" Submariners 5
soleil Greenpeace: "Trident: costs are running out of control" Submariners 4
soleil The Times: "Trident Replacement Plan on Scrapheap?" Submariners 18
S Trident and other defence issues. Current Affairs 2
N MAD to Go: Will Trident be Replaced Current Affairs 110
C Scrap Trident Submariners 79
S The Trident debate? Submariners 24
G 'Son' of Trident. Submariners 2
S Bishop and Trident... ;) Submariners 21
Similar threads


















































Top