Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Telegraph: "Falkland Islands to be left without Warship"

PINCH

War Hero
Re: The Telegraph: "Falkland Islands to be left without Wars

Now this is a cut tooooooo far.

However the new Bay ships are very capable, and versatile
 

Oil_Slick

War Hero
Re: The Telegraph: "Falkland Islands to be left without Wars

"In any shooting war with a serious enemy the Royal Navy would cease to exist within a few weeks."


Very true, painfully so.
 

wave_dodger

MIA
Book Reviewer
Re: The Telegraph: "Falkland Islands to be left without Wars

Old news and badly presented. Because some platforms have failed (and are failing OST), because we're committing to the EU Anti Piracy initiative we've had to juggle programmes which means a few small gaps appear in the programme of the usual commitments. Chopping the ATP(N) LSDA to go South is just an interim measure.

Lets not forget BFSAI has the oncall Tornado's, the C-130 which runs surveillance flights, its helo's and the Clyde OPV. Its not like we've closed shop and gone home!
 

damo567

Midshipman
Re: The Telegraph: "Falkland Islands to be left without Wars

wave_dodger said:
Old news and badly presented. Because some platforms have failed (and are failing OST), because we're committing to the EU Anti Piracy initiative we've had to juggle programmes which means a few small gaps appear in the programme of the usual commitments. Chopping the ATP(N) LSDA to go South is just an interim measure.

You say this like a "few small gaps" isn't a problem, surely this is just the start of our problems, all due to the fact we haven't got enough ships!
 

Purple_twiglet

War Hero
Moderator
So the sum of this story is we don't have a DD/FF in APT(S) doing stirring destroyer like things? Shame the article neglected to point out that we have got the following down there at the moment:

1 x Bay Class LPD
1 x Rover Class Tanker
1 x Clyde Class OPV
1 x Endurance Class Antarctic Patrol Ship
Assorted Tugs etc

Just what does a DD/FF bring to the party that these ships can't do exactly? Argentina is in no position to invade the islands - we have all the capabilities we need for current ops. As usual this is a total non story.
 

Purple_twiglet

War Hero
Moderator
Sorry - it was a slightly faceitious comment. What I meant to say is that we have 4 pussers canoes in the area, all of which have clearly defined roles. Given we don't face a threat from the Argies at the moment, I'm not quite sure why some people think its the end of the world if we don't have a DD/FFG on station?
 
If you lived on the Falklands I'm sure you'd feel a bit differently.
Frigate/Destroyer is there for protection. The rest are there in support of the protection.

There is now no protection.
 

Purple_twiglet

War Hero
Moderator
Lamri

I'm sorry but that is just emotional BS. If you consider what is there - the company group, the airfield, the interceptors, the airlift, the air defences, the patrol vessels, the support etc. If you think that a single frigate will make the slightest difference, then you are deluded.

The escort fleet provides capabilities, but, at a time when there is no threat, and there is no credible chance of Argentina providing a threat, we have to grow up and move on. The line that the Falklands are somehow vulnerable because a single Frigate isn't on station, when its often not on station for months at a time anyway is just bilge.
 
Purple_twiglet said:
Lamri

I'm sorry but that is just emotional BS. If you consider what is there - the company group, the airfield, the interceptors, the airlift, the air defences, the patrol vessels, the support etc. If you think that a single frigate will make the slightest difference, then you are deluded.

The escort fleet provides capabilities, but, at a time when there is no threat, and there is no credible chance of Argentina providing a threat, we have to grow up and move on. The line that the Falklands are somehow vulnerable because a single Frigate isn't on station, when its often not on station for months at a time anyway is just bilge.

Yes, to us it may be emotional BS, but, like I said in the first part of my post, imagine how different you would feel if you lived there.
Face it, it really doesn't matter what WE put down there - 23s are total dogshit, 42's are too old and out of date, 22's probably wouldn't make it.
However, what we DO have is the "The Navy's Here!" factor, letting them know that we haven't forgotten them, nor will we. Well, sorry but this sends the message that we have.
If, as a reservist, you are privvy to so much Argentinian military knowledge, I would suggest that you need to contact to powers-that-be with enough time for us to be able to do something about it, the next time the Argies ARE in a position to take them. I would say that we, as in the RN, need roughly fifteen years to be in a position of strength, so make sure you let us know that far in advance.
;)
 

Purple_twiglet

War Hero
Moderator
Lamri

If you doubt Argie capabilities and are still serving, then PM me and I'll give you the idiots guide to how to do an RFI so you can see for yourself.
The joy of working somewhere far more interesting in my day job - but nice attempt to get a bite though!

If we had 'forgotten them', then we would not have any ships at all out there - the fact is that we are stretching other vessles programmes to keep something down there is a sign of the commitment we place to the FI - 4 warships forward deployed is not a small commitment by any nation.
 
Not an attempt to get a bite. Only the truth. As a part-timer I wouldn't expect you to understand.
You need to stop looking at this from a reservist point of view and attempt to look at this from an Islanders point of view, if at all possible (have you even been there?).
Yet another cut in operations due to lack of assets, leaving those that ARE there in a support role with nothing to support. They will be gone soon too as there is no need for them to be there supporting nothing, and before you know it we have no Naval presence in the area and no way of getting any there soon enough.
 

wave_dodger

MIA
Book Reviewer
Lamri said:
Purple_twiglet said:
Just what does a DD/FF bring to the party that these ships can't do exactly?

I bet you wrote that with a straight face, didn't you!

Lamri, the post deployment report from the last T42 was interesting (sic), their highlight was a CASEVAC of a pongo!

The T42 isn't an INT gatherer, has a crap boarding capability, suffers more OFDEFS than god knows what and has how many working warshots to shoot at air tracks?

In the end all the platforms of any shape or form are there to do is provide a presence.

I imagine the powers have looked at the threat from Argentina and made a reasonable decision!
 

Purple_twiglet

War Hero
Moderator
Your argument doesnt make sense - you complain that there is no DD/FF in theatre, then you say it doesnt matter as they are out of date? If they are out of date, then why spend any time with them in theatre?
 
If you read my posts then perhaps you would understand my position as a regular. You have made your position perfectly clear in the pm you sent.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
soleil Telegraph: "Britain Can Do 'Nothing' To Prevent Argentina Retaking Falkland Islands" Current Affairs 16
MoD_RSS Prime Minister's article in the Telegraph: 12 September 2020 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Prime Minister's article in the Telegraph: 15 June 2020 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Public Health England response to Sunday Telegraph coverage MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Chief Scientific Adviser's Sunday Telegraph article: 31 May 2020 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Health Secretary Matt Hancock's Sunday Telegraph Op-Ed MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Letter to The Telegraph from Emma Howard Boyd, Chair of the Environment Agency MoD News 0
soleil Telegraph: "Royal Navy To Halve Number Of Staff At Headquarters, As Sailors Are Redeployed To Front Line Roles" Bases / Shore Est 1
soleil D. Telegraph: "Royal Navy Adjusts Rules To Allow Rastafarians To Keep Long Hair And Beards" Bases / Shore Est 0
MoD_RSS Minister for Women and Equalities Liz Truss speech at The Telegraph's Women Mean Business event MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Culture Secretary addresses Telegraph's Tech for Good conference MoD News 0
vauxhall Telegraph Reports on Pension Tax Trap Finance & Pensions 0
vauxhall 'Scrap These Ludicrous Tax [email protected] - Telegraph Article Finance & Pensions 0
soleil Telegraph: "Commander Ken Frewer, Submariner – Obituary" Submariners 1
soleil Telegraph: "Captain Peter Grindal – Obituary" Current Affairs 1
BreathingOutOnTheWayUp DAILY TELEGRAPH FIREWALL Current Affairs 8
J Telegraph: F35 won't be shooting until 2019 Current Affairs 39
W Belfast Telegraph - promoting their lovelies Diamond Lil's 1
soleil Telegraph: "Armed Forces Drink 'To Point Of Oblivion', Minister Warns" The Quarterdeck 20
soleil Telegraph: "Ironing Becomes Casualty Of Afghanistan Withdrawal" Bases / Shore Est 30
soleil Telegraph: "MoD Looks At Giant Patrol Drone To Replace Axed Nimrod" MoD News 5
soleil Telegraph: "Why It Is More Important Than Ever To Invest In Defence Of Democracy" MoD News 0
exJenny Telegraph: Inside HMS Plymouth Current Affairs 15
scouse Good article by Christina Schmid in today's Telegraph History 5
soleil Telegraph: "British Armed Forces Complete Handover Of Helmand Province After 8 Years" Bases / Shore Est 12
soleil Telegraph: "Britain's Largest Warship Nears Completion" The Fleet 12
soleil Telegraph: "10 Things No One Tells You Before You Join The Royal Marines" The Corps 27
B Telegraph: "The Patrol: A British Look At Modern Warfare" Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 0
soleil Telegraph: "Wave Of Suspected Bombs Sent To Armed Forces Recruiting Offices" Current Affairs 30
soleil Telegraph: "Former Navy Chief Accused Argentina Of 'Unacceptable Harassment'" Current Affairs 2
soleil Telegraph: "Britain's Biggest Defence Projects Are 25 Years Late" Current Affairs 6
soleil Telegraph: "The Patrol: A British Look At Modern Warfare" Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 2
soleil Telegraph: "Britain's Military Standing Slides, Warns Think Tank" Current Affairs 4
soleil Telegraph: "Defence Cuts Threat To Britain's Biggest Ceremonial Events" Current Affairs 6
soleil Telegraph: "Trident Cuts 'Need Not Hit Deterrent'" Submariners 1
soleil Telegraph: "Tackling The Challenges Of Moving To Civvy Street" The Afterlife - Resettlement and Jobs 4
soleil Telegraph: "MoD Contracts Safeguard 1,000 AgustaWestland Jobs" The Fleet Air Arm 1
soleil Telegraph: "F-35 Fighter 'Hit By Software And Reliability Problems'" The Fleet Air Arm 9
soleil Grimsby Telegraph: "HMS Grimsby Arrives In Town's Royal Dock" The Fleet 1
soleil Telegraph: "Viagra And Bayonets Stolen From MoD" Current Affairs 40
soleil Telegraph: "UK Orders Near For F-35 'Stealth’ Jet" The Fleet Air Arm 46
soleil Telegraph: "'Too Many Quitting Forces' MPs Warn" Current Affairs 40
soleil Telegraph: "Honours Bias 'Favours Officers Over Soldiers'" Current Affairs 20
soleil Telegraph: "MOD Spends £66 Million On Consultants As Armed Forces Cut" Current Affairs 5
soleil Telegraph: "'Britain Must Scale Back Ambitions Without More Defence Money'" Current Affairs 19
soleil Telegraph: "Endurance Race Organiser Admits He Lied About Being An Ex-Royal Marine" The Corps 0
soleil Telegraph: "Head Of Armed Forces: Military Risks Becoming 'Hollow Force'" Current Affairs 21
soleil Telegraph: "Amazing 360 Degree Look Inside Britain's Newest Typhoon Fighter" The Fleet Air Arm 3
soleil Telegraph: "Coalition 'Abandons' Plan To Privatise Defence Procurement" Current Affairs 4
soleil Telegraph: "'Lawrence Of Helmand' Marine Awarded Afghan Gallantry Medal" The Corps 3
Similar threads


















































Top