Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

T'graph: RAF Can Be Trimmed, But Cuts To Navy & Army Insane

Re: T'graph: RAF Can Be Trimmed, But Cuts To Navy & Army Ins

Given we remain an island nation, the Navy is of enormous importance. The sea lanes that matter to us are not, however, just those familiar from the shipping forecast. The Navy gives us reach in the world.

Well said, just hope the Mandarins in the corridors of power take heed. We only know what we don't know !
 
Re: T'graph: RAF Can Be Trimmed, But Cuts To Navy & Army Ins

And as for the Army: how can it be cut while we are in Afghanistan? The consensus among the top brass is that we shall be there for at least five more years. That should mean the Army is not considered for economies until then.

Really? I don't see much urgency for heavy armour or artillery at the moment. Further weakening of either the Navy or the Air Force would be lunacy.

The Ministry of Defence has, to an extent, asked for this. It has about 85,000 civil servants, roughly the same as the total complements of the Royal Navy and Royal Air Force put together. One of the first places to start a clear-out is there.

That must look very attractive and "popular"; to those that don't understand it. If our fighting Services consisted of nothing but infantry and coastal patrol boats, it might be an option. It's an unfortunate fact of life, though, that highly technical Services need a very large number of non combatants shoreside to provide the equipment and support they need. We could save some by being freed from Government accounting rules and abandoning the great edifice of "performance management". That wouldn't save that much, though.
 

Seaweed

War Hero
Book Reviewer
I am reminded of a rhyme from a book of Kings and Queens I had as a child. Charles II:

"... He did not worry overmuch
When up the Medway sailed the Dutch .."

Nevertheless Heffer is wrong to categorise the MoD CS as 'an army of penpushers'. He would do well to find out what the MoD CS actually does before making glib assumptions like that (does this number include the RFA?). There should be more to this debate than cheap soundbites, and, sadly, a cheap shot like that undermines confidence in everything else he writes, some of which is to the point.
 

timex

Lantern Swinger
Re: T'graph: RAF Can Be Trimmed, But Cuts To Navy & Army Ins

Passed-over_Loggie said:
And as for the Army: how can it be cut while we are in Afghanistan? The consensus among the top brass is that we shall be there for at least five more years. That should mean the Army is not considered for economies until then.

Really? I don't see much urgency for heavy armour or artillery at the moment. Further weakening of either the Navy or the Air Force would be lunacy.

Those bits of Artillery and Armour may not all be deployed to Afghanistan but the people who man them are over there patrolling and supporting, much like the guys did in NI.

Their kit is old and will soon need replacing much like a lot of the Fleet. You'd be surprised at just how little we have in the way of Operational Arty and Armour.
 
Re: T'graph: RAF Can Be Trimmed, But Cuts To Navy & Army Ins

The tankies and dropshorts do, indeed have boots in the 'Stan and a fine contribution they make. If when that aberation is ENDEX, though, a wind back on numbers would keep the infanteers within the manpower limits.

I do realise that their noise generators are getting old and I have a good idea of how much it costs to maintain them. It's also not difficult to work out how much it will cost to replace them. I also realise that it would put UK PLC out of the armour and heavy arty design and manufacture game.
 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator
Re: T'graph: RAF Can Be Trimmed, But Cuts To Navy & Army Ins

Passed-over_Loggie said:
The tankies and dropshorts do, indeed have boots in the 'Stan and a fine contribution they make. If when that aberation is ENDEX, though, a wind back on numbers would keep the infanteers within the manpower limits.

I do realise that their noise generators are getting old and I have a good idea of how much it costs to maintain them. It's also not difficult to work out how much it will cost to replace them. I also realise that it would put UK PLC out of the armour and heavy arty design and manufacture game.

Not while there's a thriving export market
 

mophead

Lantern Swinger
Re: T'graph: RAF Can Be Trimmed, But Cuts To Navy & Army Ins

Not while there's a thriving export market[/quote]

Where?
No one wants to buy our good but expensive,kit when they can get something nearly as good cheaper from the US,Frace,Germany without all the hassle....and with the required"agents payment"
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
soleil T'graph: "British Armed Forces: Army, Navy And RAF In Stats" Current Affairs 31
soleil T'graph: "China & Russia Help Global Defence Spending Rise For First Time In 5 Years" Current Affairs 14
soleil Grimsby T'graph: "Soldier Who Dodged Death Twice Passes On Words Of Wisdom" The Corps 0
soleil Grimsby T'graph: "Bravery Of Grimsby Marine In 'Immensely Dangerous' Situation" The Corps 0
soleil T'Graph: "The Importance Of Maintaining A Strong Royal Navy Presence In The Gulf" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil T'graph: Relations Between Britain & China Strained Over Naval Ship's Visit To Japan The Fleet 6
soleil T'Graph: "RN Launches Its First Women's Network To Boost Number Of Female Commanders" The Fleet 3
soleil T'graph: "Human Trafficking In East Africa: Why The RN Is Forced To Turn A Blind Eye" The Fleet 0
soleil T'graph: "Admiral Lord West: 'The Big Lie Of The Defence Funding 'Black Hole'" Current Affairs 5
soleil T'graph: "Navy Plane Which Sunk The Nazis To Perform Flypast At Jubilee Pageant" The Fleet Air Arm 18
soleil T'graph: Royal British Legion Severs Links With News Of The World Over Phone Hacking Current Affairs 31
soleil Coventry T'graph: "Captain Jack Sparrow Is Britain's Most Famous Seaman" Current Affairs 5
soleil T'graph: "Gov't 'Rows Back On Defence Cuts To Fund Conflicts In Libya & Afghanistan" Current Affairs 0
soleil T'graph: "WikiLeaks: Ex-SAS Officers Hired As 'Human Bait' By Foreign Shipping Firms" Current Affairs 1
soleil T'graph: SDSR: Military Chiefs Fight Private Education Cuts Current Affairs 5
soleil T'graph: "French Carrier Set To Defend Britain Breaks Down" Current Affairs 8
soleil T'graph: "SoS: Closer Alliance With France Good For Britain" Current Affairs 17
soleil T'graph: "SDSR: Royal Navy Has Greatest Job Losses And Cuts" Current Affairs 0
soleil T'graph/Letters: Don't Sacrifice RN For Army's Horses/Bands Current Affairs 14
soleil T'graph: £16bn Future Rapid Effects System Faces Axe In Cuts Current Affairs 6
soleil T'graph: "Carriers Give Politicians Options - Not Dead Ends" Current Affairs 3
soleil T'graph Gen. Sir Richard Dannatt: SDSR: Britain Is At Stake Current Affairs 0
soleil T'graph: SDSR: 4 Future Scenarios & How They Might Play Out Current Affairs 3
soleil T'graph: Continuous Nuclear Submarine Patrols Not Guaranteed Submariners 4
soleil T'graph: "Fighter Plane Crash: You Just Have To Get Out" The Fleet Air Arm 5
soleil T'graph: Sangin Ambush Alleys Provide Ground For RM Heroics The Corps 2
soleil T'graph: "MoD Drops British Socks For Cheaper Chinese Ones" Current Affairs 22
soleil T'graph: "Harrier Jump Jet Is Hung From Tate Britain's Roof" The Fleet Air Arm 10
soleil T'graph: "Martello Towers: An Artistic Entente On The Coast" History 0
soleil T'graph: "Injured Servicemen Hope For Olympic Ski Success" Sports and Adventure Training 2
soleil T'graph: "Royal Tournament To Be Revived After 11 Year Gap" Current Affairs 33
soleil Belfast T'graph: "HMS Monmouth In City For Maritime Event" The Fleet 0
soleil T'graph: "Family Rescued By Warship After Iceberg Collision" The Fleet 6
soleil Coventry T'graph: "Leamington Submariner gives final salute" Submariners 6
soleil T'graph: Royal Navy consigns tiffs to history after 141 yrs Current Affairs 19
soleil T'graph: Liam Fox: "No room for sentimality in Review" Current Affairs 1
soleil T'graph: Generals and Admirals to be culled in Defence cuts Current Affairs 15
soleil T'graph: "Heirs of Harry Patch fighting in Helmand's fields" Current Affairs 0
R HMS/M Graph (ex U-Boat 570 Submariners 14
MoD_RSS Milestone for runway works at RAF Lossiemouth as aircraft return MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Completion of training facility at RAF Waddington MoD News 0
MoD_RSS RAF looks to the future on Battle of Britain Day MoD News 0
J Navy or RAF Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 8
MoD_RSS Counter-drone tech and state-of-the-art radar for the RAF MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK Government announces multi million pound funding for Moray College Hub at RAF Lossiemouth MoD News 0
MoD_RSS First Operation for RAF Poseidon tracking Russian Warship MoD News 0
J Navy to raf apprenticeship Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 8
MoD_RSS RAF flights to take UK aid-funded supplies to Africa to tackle coronavirus MoD News 0
MoD_RSS £20-million contract awarded for Typhoon infrastructure at RAF Lossiemouth MoD News 0
MoD_RSS RAF Fighter Jets, Surveillance and Refuelling aircraft have been in action across Europe this week in support of NATO allies MoD News 0
Similar threads


















































Top