Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Strange death of the RN

Originally posted on GunPlot by Road runner aka Les Figg LEM WR

This is an interesting, but sad article. Even with British interests around the world being vastly reduced since the mighty days of the Commonwealth, this some how leaves one scratching one's head...

THE STRANGE DEATH OF THE ROYAL NAVY

By ARTHUR HERMAN

January 14, 2007 -- A 400-YEAR epoch of world history is about to draw to a close. If Britain's current Labor government has its way, Britain's Royal Navy will mothball at least 13, and perhaps as many as 19, of its remaining 44 ships, or nearly half its effective fleet.

With one bureaucratic stroke, the Ministry of Defense will end a naval tradition reaching back to Sir Francis Drake - reducing the Royal Navy, which 40 years ago was still the second-largest fleet in the world, to the size of navies of countries like Indonesia and Turkey.

This decision, of course, has to be set against the background of Britain's decades-long decline as a world power. But it also reflects a struggle for the soul of Great Britain that has been going since World War II: Is Britain part of an English-speaking, Atlantic-based strategic alliance that includes the United States and Canada? Or is it part of Europe as envisioned by technocrats in Paris, Brussels and Berlin?

NEXT month's final decision on whether to scrap the Royal Navy may supply us with the answer. Because the Blair government's drastic plans include more than taking existing ships out of commission. The service's entire future as a blue-water navy (that is, a navy capable of operations outside Britain's own waters) may be forfeit.

According to The Daily Telegraph, plans for two new fleet carriers of the kind vital for fighting today's War on Terror and projecting power overseas - and for which $6.9 billion had already been set aside - will also be scrapped. Two new destroyers, which were supposed to replace at least some of the retired ships, are also out of the picture. The Telegraph even reports (Jan. FPRIVATE "TYPE=PICT;ALT=Cool" that all officer promotions in the navy are to be suspended for the next five years.

Many in the government and in the media blame these cuts on Tony Blair's support for the U.S. war in Iraq. They claim the British troop presence there is eating up the British defense budget, leaving the other services like the navy to fight over table scraps.

But this is far from the whole story. Since the mid '80s, British defense spending has shrunk by more than 30 percent, to less than 2.5 percent of GDP. Today it is at its lowest level since 1930. Even welfare states such as France and Germany spend more on their military. (Meanwhile, Blair is busy hacking back the British commitment in Iraq from 7,000 to 4,500 troops - less than 4 percent of the coalition total.

The truth is that for two centuries Britain and the Royal Navy played the role of global cop, policing the world's sea trade lanes which keep the global economy going. (Even today, 95 percent of the weight of all intercontinental trade travels by sea.)

AFTER World War II, the U.S. Navy gradually took over that thankless but essential task; the British felt free to relax. From a postwar peak of 388 ships and submarines in 1950, the Royal Navy had dwindled to 112 vessels in 1980. By 2004. it was down to just 46.

Yet the British navy still takes pride in sharing the global cop burden with the United States in vital strategic areas like the Persian Gulf, and even being able to project power trans-oceanically alone when it has to, as during the Falklands War.

Analysts agree that once these forecast cuts go through, this will be impossible. Indeed, a Royal Navy of only 25 vessels would require at least some cooperation from its European neighbors even to defend Britain.

This is a ominous trend for many reasons. It not only increases the burden on the U.S. Navy around the globe. It also reflects a decision to move Britain away from its traditional maritime culture, which is the basis of its strategic relationship with the United States, and toward a decaying Europe.

SINCE 1945, Britain has been torn between the two, like a would-be bride torn between two suitors. Winston Churchill (who was half-American) and Margaret Thatcher knew which to choose. "There is no hope for civilization," Churchill used to say, "if we drift apart," meaning the United States and England.

Blair, it is true, has been supportive on Iraq. But (like many recent British politicians) he has been eager to ingratiate himself with his continental neighbors, including by compromising Britain's defense capability. For example, his government stuck with the ill-fated EFA-2000 Euro-fighter project, even though it cost Britain 21/2 times the original estimated cost ($37 billion versus $13.7 billion) and the RAF only got its planes after a 41/2-year delay.

Then in 1998 he endorsed Germany and France's idea of a European Defense Force separate from NATO and the United States. Again, the cost of cooperation will be to reduce the British army to just one more unit in a European military coalition led from Brussels, not London.

Now come the naval cuts. Pure coincidence? It is not difficult to see the distant hand of the Paris-Brussels-Berlin axis at work.

And disasters like this will continue as long as British politicians fool themselves into thinking their future lies with the shrinking economies and aging populations of the continent of Europe.

IRONICALLY, Britain just celebrated the 200th anniversary of its naval victory over France at Trafalgar, which allowed Britain to build an empire and dominate the world's oceans. If these navy cuts go into effect, France will have a larger fleet than Britain for the first time since the mid-1600's.

The victory the French couldn't win at sea, they will win effortlessly and painlessly at the bureaucrat's desk.

Arthur Herman is the author of "To Rule the Waves: How the British Navy Shaped the Modern World," which was nominated for the Mountbatten Prize for best book in naval history in 2005. His latest book, a study of Gandhi and Churchill, will be published next year.
_________________
Les Figg
ex LEM WR, R62259, 1963-69
Served in Ships Sydney, Hawk, Perth
Served at Bases Cerberus (x3), Kuttabul (FMP), Encounter, Waratah (San Diego and Mare Island)
 

dondon

MIA
A sad state of affairs indeed , have seen it all coming for a long time , so glad I did my time when I did (1971 /1995) , never believed for a minute that we'de get the Carriers , still don't believe it , every day I go down over Victoria Road in St Budeaux & you can look out over the Dockyard , there is nothing there I'm affraid , It all looks very deserted & empty , all so sad , !!!!!!!!!!
 

Dabs

Lantern Swinger
dondon said:
A sad state of affairs indeed , have seen it all coming for a long time , so glad I did my time when I did (1971 /1995) , never believed for a minute that we'de get the Carriers , still don't believe it , every day I go down over Victoria Road in St Budeaux & you can look out over the Dockyard , there is nothing there I'm affraid , It all looks very deserted & empty , all so sad , !!!!!!!!!!
Typical GUZZ skeptic, what can I say?
 

Dabs

Lantern Swinger
Dabs said:
dondon said:
A sad state of affairs indeed , have seen it all coming for a long time , so glad I did my time when I did (1971 /1995) , never believed for a minute that we'de get the Carriers , still don't believe it , every day I go down over Victoria Road in St Budeaux & you can look out over the Dockyard , there is nothing there I'm affraid , It all looks very deserted & empty , all so sad , !!!!!!!!!!
Typical GUZZ skeptic, what can I say?
By the way, I actually read a dit on this site from a GUZZ rate that called GUZZ, GUZ. Now that's sad. :roll:
 

Dabs

Lantern Swinger
Dabs said:
Dabs said:
dondon said:
A sad state of affairs indeed , have seen it all coming for a long time , so glad I did my time when I did (1971 /1995) , never believed for a minute that we'de get the Carriers , still don't believe it , every day I go down over Victoria Road in St Budeaux & you can look out over the Dockyard , there is nothing there I'm affraid , It all looks very deserted & empty , all so sad , !!!!!!!!!!
Typical GUZZ skeptic, what can I say?
By the way, I actually read a dit on this site from a GUZZ rate that called GUZZ, GUZ. Now that's sad. :roll:
Way back in WWII when the callsign for the GUZZ area was Golf Uniform Zulu Zulu ................ need I say more?
 
Dabs said:
dondon said:
A sad state of affairs indeed , have seen it all coming for a long time , so glad I did my time when I did (1971 /1995) , never believed for a minute that we'de get the Carriers , still don't believe it , every day I go down over Victoria Road in St Budeaux & you can look out over the Dockyard , there is nothing there I'm affraid , It all looks very deserted & empty , all so sad , !!!!!!!!!!
Typical GUZZ skeptic, what can I say?
Nothing, shit in it... :evil:
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Sumo Strange ? Clever inventions Diamond Lil's 3
BillyNoMates Strange people creating accounts (amended thread title) Miscellaneous 18
Harry_Von_Scrinse Strange Diver Patch History 4
Sumo Best place, Best thing seen, Strange Journey Diamond Lil's 11
BSBRN82 Strange RT Exam....Help!! Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 27
Si_Novice Any other strange ones? Diamond Lil's 60
jesse Rum Ration is having a strange effect on me! Diamond Lil's 1
N Odd or Strange Postings/Jobs you got in Pusser. Diamond Lil's 15
Jack77 Strange Geordie Toilet Habits Diamond Lil's 18
J Royals...Strange People.... The Corps 30
B Strange rig of the Day History 14
Chicogiz Strange Hotels The Quarterdeck 7
frayedknotarts Strange ever for THIS place.... Diamond Lil's 1
chieftiff Thought it was strange but! Site Issues 14
sgtpepperband Strange but true... Current Affairs 2
sgtpepperband Strange foreign TV adverts by stars The Gash Barge 0
brazenhussy Strange Things Under Beds Diamond Lil's 7
G Strange Drinks Diamond Lil's 0
Praetorian Strange Shagging Music Diamond Lil's 14
W A strange sight in the South Pacific The Gash Barge 6
general_jumbo. strange Social & Reunions 0
N Strange Air Routes Diamond Lil's 8
GCYZ Royal Navy Quiz-Something a bit Strange? The Fleet 5
Reservist-Monkey Another strange uniform question History 35
N Strange Circumstances for a Valour Award History 10
MoD_RSS People with learning disabilities had higher death rate from COVID-19 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Foreign Secretary statement on the death of the Amir of Kuwait MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Charity regulator disqualifies individual as trustee over death threats and incitements to murder MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Death of Azimzhan Askarov, human rights defender in Kyrgyzstan: UK statement MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Excess weight can increase risk of serious illness and death from COVID-19 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Ministry of Defence confirms the death of Fusilier Sam Brownridge MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK statement on the death of President Nkurunziza of Burundi MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Daily death reporting now includes all positive COVID-19 deaths MoD News 0
MoD_RSS New guarantee on death in service benefits for frontline health and care staff during pandemic MoD News 1
MoD_RSS Ministry of Defence confirms the death of Lance Corporal Brodie Gillon MoD News 0
MoD_RSS CMO for England announces first death of patient with COVID-19 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Ministry of Defence confirms the death of Private Joseph Berry MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Inquiry launched into the death of Jermaine Baker MoD News 0
MoD_RSS PM travels to Oman following the death of Sultan Qaboos bin Said al Said MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK flags to fly at half mast for the death of Sultan Qaboos of Oman MoD News 0
MoD_RSS PM statement on the death of His Majesty Sultan Qaboos bin Said al Said, Sultan of Oman MoD News 0
E Death of a Merchant Seaman: Leonard Gould Shannon History 3
MoD_RSS UK Government statement on death of Daesh’s leader MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UN Human Rights Council 42 - General Comment on the Question of the Death Penalty MoD News 0
MoD_RSS FCO statement following the death of Robert Mugabe MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Minister for Europe & Americas statement on the death of the Ambassador of the Republic of Armenia to the United Kingdom MoD News 0
vauxhall Death in Service Benefits Finance & Pensions 0
MoD_RSS News story: Ministry of Defence confirms the death of Guardsman Mathew Talbot MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Oral statement on the death of Lyra McKee MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Man who stabbed acquaintance to death has sentence reviewed MoD News 0
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

New Posts

Top