Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Secret Britain – The Hidden Bits of our History by Justin Pollard

Status
Not open for further replies.

Boldnotold

Midshipman
Book Reviewer
This is a paperback book which, according to the blurb on its cover, uncovers the cover-ups and conspiracies, the secret passages and hidden identities, the forgotten stories and dark secrets of the grave. It consists of a series of short essays, each describing an event, location, or life of a person which, however tenuously, fits that description.
I read a review of it in a magazine, and asked A-Y to procure it for me as I thought it would appeal to this audience. The publisher was very helpful, sending a second copy when the first went missing in the post.

The book starts well, with a description of the Berners Street Hoax, and a story about Captain Warner’s Invisible Shell, which shows that the gullible people given responsibility for military procurement have always been exploited by the unscrupulous. It reveals some genuine secrets, for example the involvement of a postman called Flowers in the invention of the first electronic computer at Bletchley Park and inspired Alan Turing, the underground city at Burlington near Corsham (for use by our political masters whilst the rest of us dealt with the nuclear winter) and the uses of Orford Ness and Shoreham by our military authorities. Readers of this site may enjoy the story of the ‘Naughty Nuns of Higham’, or learning that Arthur Ransome spied in Russia as well as writing children’s books.

However by the time I’d read the ‘secrets’ of the village of Eyam, which cut itself off so as not to spread plague in 1665/6, and the rotten borough of Dunwich, and other stories, I started to be frustrated and annoyed that many of the so-called secrets were in fact well-publicised stories.

The author describes the book as a collection of historical curiosities, but I found it to be a collection of a few interesting stories padded with a lot of rather dull ones. This was very disappointing, given the effort the publisher had made to get the book to me for review. Perhaps it would be better used as a book for dipping into, rather than one to read end-to-end. In any case it’s not one I’d recommend wholeheartedly or indeed read a second time.

Classification – one anchor.
 

Purple_twiglet

War Hero
Moderator
"the underground city at Burlington near Corsham (for use by our political masters whilst the rest of us dealt with the nuclear winter"

Site 3 (AKA Burlington / Turnstile / Stockwell) etc has not been a secret for nearly a decade. The more interesting question is what its role really was, as it seems that after 1963 it was primarily intended as a decoy site. (I'm a deep geek on Site 3, having been there several times and done a lot of research into it...)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Naval_Gazer BBC2 - 'Britain's Secret Seas' showing RN divers in action Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 0
Ballistic Britain's new secret weapon Diamond Lil's 1
Sumo IRA still being track by secret squirrels Current Affairs 2
MoD_RSS Appointment of the new Chief of the Secret Intelligence Service (MI6) MoD News 0
Stirlin The Troubles....a secret history. Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 1
Stirlin Secret Agent Selection WW2 Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 4
soleil 1911 - 1915: "The Royal Navy's Secret Campaign Against 'Unnatural Crimes'" History 11
soleil Secret and Silent: Conference (15/16th June 2018) and Exhibition Submariners 0
SARKING Secret History HMS Glorious History 1
P Apprentice Charleine on 'ejaculation pillow' - I saw worse at Secret Santa! The Gash Barge 11
wafuloyal wafu secret santa HELP! The Fleet Air Arm 17
Stirlin Patagonia.....Earths Secret Paradise. Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 6
Ageing_Gracefully Book Comp: CHURCHILL'S SECRET WARRIORS Competitions 9
soleil BBC: "Mail Rail - What Is It Like On The 'Secret' Tube?" History 0
soleil Daily Record: "Gary Barlow Makes Secret Visit To See Our Troops In Afghanistan" Bases / Shore Est 21
soleil Mail: "Secret Command Centre Used By Winston Churchill Goes Up For Sale" History 1
soleil Telegraph: "'Top Secret' D-Day Orders To Naval Captains Emerge" History 3
I Secret/Specialist branches or roles in the navy ? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 21
F Listen.........do you want to know a secret Current Affairs 13
BreathingOutOnTheWayUp Cuban missile crisis: The other, secret one History 1
soleil Pompey News: "Secret Repairs For HMS Daring After She Suffers Breakdown" The Fleet 5
soleil Telegraph: "Belgrano Was Heading To The Falklands, Secret Papers Reveal" History 43
finknottle Secret Pakistan Current Affairs 12
T SAS war diary: The SAS secret hidden since World War II Current Affairs 2
WreckerL Pusser's secret battlecruiser History 4
finknottle A Royal Marine died after a secret mission off the coast of Portsmouth Current Affairs 0
BARNEYRNSM The secret life of buildings CH4 on at the minute. Submariners 6
soleil BBC: "Inside The Royal Navy's Secret Submarine Factory" Submariners 5
trelawney126 MP's Reclaim, repaid Expenses in Secret Deal Current Affairs 1
soleil Guardian: "Flaws In Nuclear Submarine Reactors Could Be Fatal, Secret Report Warns" Submariners 29
NotmeChief Russian 'secret agents' arrested in US Current Affairs 0
Seaweed Secret Pirate Interceptor Boat Trials The Quarterdeck 3
T Top secret submariners to be recognised Submariners 9
Guns Secret Handshakes and rolled up trs legs Diamond Lil's 14
stan_the_man Secret Santa Diamond Lil's 5
D Government attempts to keep torture case secret Current Affairs 0
soleil What is the secret of successful tenpin bowling? Sports and Adventure Training 11
soleil Sinking of HMS Poseidon 1931 - secret salvage op? History 0
JamesH Secret film from Labour HQ Diamond Lil's 4
A SECRET SECURITY CLEARANCE? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 14
T Inquests to be held in secret, at Minister's whim... Current Affairs 11
sgtpepperband More secret files found on train Current Affairs 13
Scran_Bag A Wardroom secret discovered after 66 years ? Diamond Lil's 10
witsend secret life of our moderator Diamond Lil's 5
sgtpepperband The Secret Language of the Child Diamond Lil's 2
Vesper Polishing Shoes, any secret formulas? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 74
Random Smut-swapping sailors leak secret missile specs Diamond Lil's 2
slim Former British diplomat makes public secret evidence on Iraq Current Affairs 28
S How long do you keep a secret? Submariners 20
MoD_RSS New 'Diversity Built Britain' coin unveiled MoD News 0
Similar threads


















































Top