Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

RFA career in the event of Scottish independence?!

BaldRik

Midshipman
Good morning all, long time lurker, first time poster and all that..

A couple of things you'll need to know about me first of all are that I've recently received a provisional offer from the RFA to start an ME cadetship with the October '16 intake and I'm from Edinburgh.

With the political goings-on of the past couple of days (Brexit obviously), it's looking like our dear leader up here will be pushing for a second referendum on Scottish independence, given that 62% of Scotland voted to Remain.
Now, I'm not looking for any opinions on #indyref2 (as the kids would put it) I'm just curious/mildly concerned about the possible implications for my future career, given that the MoD being a governmental organisation might not be able, or want to employ non-nationals.

So, what are your thoughts?
 

janner

MIA
Book Reviewer
In the event of Scotex all Scots and their families will be interned until the wall is rebuilt and then, following having S branded on their foreheads, will be deported never to return.

Faslane, one of Scotlands biggest employers will be closed down and the whole nuclear setup will be moved to Gibraltar, thus pleasing most matelots and upsetting Spain big time. This is known as a win / win situation.

All of the extra benefits that Scottish people have received from the UK will cease. North Sea revenues are plummeting so financially things will be hard.

One last thing, it will take years for Scotland to get into the EU because they don't conform to many of the criteria required for entry, and having lost a net contributor the last the the EU needs is another state looking for hand outs.

I hope this has been of some assistance. ;)
 
Last edited:

BaldRik

Midshipman
Didn't quite answer my question...or at all... but fascinating nonetheless! Fingers crossed for the jaunt to Gib then, eh?!
 

Sumo

War Hero
What do you think?
The lower number not even 50% of the voting population, it will be a different turn out for Scotland to leave U.K. what will happen if the SNP lose again? You for one will be able to answer your own question?
 

BaldRik

Midshipman
I'm entirely sure what you're talking about. The voter turnout on Scotland was over 74% for the EU Ref and as I tried to make clear, although obviously unsuccessfully, I'm not interested in talking about the hypothetical pros and cons of Scottish independence, all I'm trying to get some views on is whether or not I would still have a job with the MoD if it did happen..
 

WelshJaffaCake

Lantern Swinger
Don't know if someone tell you either way unless it's directly from the MoD their talking bullshit. Best bet if you want to sound of mind move to England or better yet move to your Celtic cousin's homeland of Wales.
 

BaldRik

Midshipman
Relocating is definitely an option I would consider, but it would depend entirely on how high the import taxes on Irn Bru and haggis were...

And no, nobody has told me anything about my original question. I'm sure it will become clear in due course, just thought I might get some reasoned speculation from folk in the know on here. Apparently not!
 

exJenny

War Hero
Moderator
Book Reviewer
Whilst we are leaving the EU, it won't happen before you join the company and a Scottish referendum is going to take a few months to sort I imagine. It wasn't an issue last year for the large number of jocks in the outfit. Most of them wanted out back then.
 

WelshJaffaCake

Lantern Swinger
And no, nobody has told me anything about my original question. I'm sure it will become clear in due course, just thought I might get some reasoned speculation from folk in the know on here. Apparently not!

No one can really answer a question on hypothetical situation that may or may not happened.
 

BaldRik

Midshipman
That's why I was looking for "reasoned speculation".. Unless you mean the first bit, I was referring to you asking if anyone had told me directly? Which they hadn't...

ExJenny, do you mean the jocks were wanting out of the RFA, or the UK? From the chat given by the SNP last year, I think any break from the UK would take a fair bit of time, especially including prep time for another referendum, so I know I'll have already have made a good start with the RFA at least, no matter what happens.

Personally, I would imagine they'd try to hang on to the staff they'd spent money training, no matter where they were from, especially engineers/technicians etc seeing as everyone seems to be having a bit of bother recruiting them at the moment.
 

Ninja_Stoker

War Hero
Moderator
If Scotland splits from UK, (assuming the EU doesn't fall apart in the interim also), then there's the interesting issue of eligibility with regards Nationality in the RFA.

Irish nationals cannot join the RFA in Comms, Logs or Systems Engineering branches, so one would assume the same could potentially apply toward those with independent Scottish nationality.

Dual Nationals, holding a British passport however, would probably be OK.
 

BaldRik

Midshipman
So assuming it resulted in a similar situation to that currently of Irish nationals, I would be ok in marine engineering?!
Also if those parameters didn't apply, if the rules had only changed after I had been qualified for a while, do you think exceptions might be made given that I/anyone else in the same boat (no pun intended) WAS a UK national when contracts were signed?
 

Ninja_Stoker

War Hero
Moderator
So assuming it resulted in a similar situation to that currently of Irish nationals, I would be ok in marine engineering?!
Also if those parameters didn't apply, if the rules had only changed after I had been qualified for a while, do you think exceptions might be made given that I/anyone else in the same boat (no pun intended) WAS a UK national when contracts were signed?
Difficult to say with any certainty to be completely honest. One would imagine current established contracts would be honoured for at least the duration of the trip.
 

exJenny

War Hero
Moderator
Book Reviewer
Considering the number of Scots in the company there's a lot of contracts that would need looking at.
 

BaldRik

Midshipman
Yes ExJ, I thought there might be and that's what made me think they might have to try and find a way to keep them on. Or try to find a way to replace them at relatively short notice?

What is the current amount of notice they have to give their employees at the moment? (as I said, I've only been given a provisional offer, don't know any details as such..)
 

Seadog

War Hero
Moderator
The voter turnout on Scotland was over 74% for the EU Ref
No it wasn't.

Stick with the nationality that suits you best. I'm not expecting a queue for passports with the declaration, "Wee Nippy demands that the bearer of this passport be given his bus fare, or you're pure getting it"
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
B Advice on career in RFA please RFA 0
BreathingOutOnTheWayUp Good News - For RFA, Brit Shipbuiders, RN Support & Brit Taxpayer RFA 0
M Qualified Deck Officer, Thinking of moving from Cruise Ships to RFA RFA 3
C RFA Seamanship Apprenticeship - Application to AB. RFA 12
O RFA System Engineer (qualified) interview RFA 7
J Couple Of Questions About Life in RFA RFA 2
soleil RN: "Cardigan Bay Chef Nears 50 Years' Service In The RFA" RFA 2
J RFA Limitations With Colour Blindness RFA 7
S RFA Training Pipeline RFA 11
Multiirishman Joining the Rfa RFA 20
7 Joining the RFA as a chef apprentice RFA 8
T preparation for RFA engineering apprenticeship RFA 26
S RFA engineering interview RFA 4
D Looking for Challenge/Spoof Coins From RFA Ships RFA 2
C RFA or Royal Navy? Older applicant Joining the Royal Navy 36
soleil FB: Aggie Weston's - Pastoral Support To RFA HQ Following Grant From Trinity House RFA 2
I RFA RFA 3
A RFA RFA 6
A Rfa RFA 6
F Switching RNR application to RFA RFA 11
northern-matelot RFA Argus RFA 4
K What to expect from the RFA? RFA 8
D Information on RFA Cadet Officer (Deck) course RFA 6
P Internal only RFA job (helicopter controller/supply chain etc). Which branch? RFA 0
D RFA BRNC June 2020 intake Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 0
Skylarker RFA Biographies? The Book Club 1
C-Roi RFA Comms Apprentice Interview RFA 9
C Life at worthy down as a RFA chef apprentice RFA 12
SeaBiscuit RFA Officer Cadet Interview and AIB RFA 1
soleil RN Website: "Why Join The RFA?" RFA 0
R RFA - watchkeeping and retirement RFA 2
R RFA reserve specialist RFA 2
Stirlin RFA Able Seaman's will to live. RFA 0
J Joining as a chef, should I join the RFA or the RN? RFA 11
J Should I join the RN or RFA as a chef. Joining the Royal Navy 6
S RFA seamanship apprentice RFA 4
C-Roi RFA Communications Apprentice RFA 34
V Smoking in the RFA RFA 8
Seadog RFA Commodore ( Engineer ). RFA 4
09traej RFA Engineering Cadetship - Graduate RFA 13
D RFA interview RFA 1
B RFA Recruitment Questions Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 5
C RFA and Forces Right To Buy RFA 7
S RFA Training at BRNC RFA 13
R Joining the RFA whilst being Reserve RFA 6
Skylarker RFA or RN Careers Joining the Royal Navy 1
Skylarker RFA or RN RFA 7
D RFA training RFA 1
S Minimum time in the rfa RFA 3
T Where in the UK are RFA ships based? RFA 2
Similar threads
















RFA

RFA

Rfa
































Latest Threads

New Posts

Top