Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Refusing blood transfusion

Karma

War Hero
BBC report

A young Jehovah's Witness has died just hours after giving birth to twins. She had signed a form refusing blood transfusions, and her family would not overrule her. Couldn't doctors have intervened?

So should the doctors have considered the risks to the children of a single parent up-bringing and given the transfusion anyway?
 

wave_dodger

MIA
Book Reviewer
I'm willing to be corrected but I believe they can't. Once she says no thats that. Quite extraordinary that she could believe so strongly and was willing to gamble against her life and her children.
 

Topstop

War Hero
Not the doctors call/part of ship. If the dozy mare wants to go to Heaven that badly its up to her.(sic) Are the social workers involved yet. :dwarf:
 

Karma

War Hero
wave_dodger said:
I'm willing to be corrected but I believe they can't.

I'm thinking more about the philosophical question, rather than the current interpretation of the legislation. Thought it might make a change form the usual debateusing the term very loosely
 
Karma said:
So should the doctors have considered the risks to the children of a single parent up-bringing and given the transfusion anyway?

Certainly not!
None of their business in my opinion.
 

RabC

MIA
Had the doctors got involved then they would have been open to assault charges. Weigh it up, charges of assault V death of a parent????? but then I'm an engineer and fix things that can't complain, makes life easy.
 

OSLO

War Hero
Another example of the lunacy of the misguided religious interpretation of a book written by a committee of dead mean thousands of years ago. Despite that, the doctors had no other recourse (in this country, at least). On a brighter note, I believe the the Jehavah's Witness community is much more cohesive than the average society, and the children will be brought up in a loving and supporting family environment, even without their mother. Pity it is a misguided, religion based community.
 
Lamri said:
It is only misguided to you, just as you are misguided to them!

On the other hand can logig be nisguided, I know faith can be, one hoes always hope that proper logic is no capable of being misguided.
 
Maxi_77 said:
Lamri said:
It is only misguided to you, just as you are misguided to them!

On the other hand can logig be nisguided, I know faith can be, one hoes always hope that proper logic is no capable of being misguided.

Who sets the standard though Maxi?
Who are WE to say who is misguided, we don't have all the answers mate, do we?
 

slim

War Hero
In the case of juveniles the government has intervened in the past and overruled parents demands that their child not be given blood transfusions.
In the case of an adult of sound mind I think it would take a rather stupid person to overrule the adult. Claims in court by today's lawyers would probably net millions.
 

OSLO

War Hero
Sorry, but where exactly does the Bible say that blood transfusions are not permitted by God? The books were written before blood circulation was known about, much less transfusions. AND the books were written by men. Where is the sense, the logic, in refusing a straightforward medical procedure to ensure your survival and the provision of a mother to your newborns (not withstanding my earlier comments about the community)? If someone said that they refused a transfusion because the great flying spaghetti bowl told them in a dream that only tomato sauce must flow in your veins, they'd be certified mad and carted off. They'd still get the blood, though. How many believers in the great flying spaghetti bowl does it take for the law to protect their tomatoy rights? Madness, I tell you.
 

sgtpepperband

War Hero
Book Reviewer
Actually as Health Care Workers, Doctors have a social and moral obligation for the care of the child and, in certain exceptional circumstances, can apply to a Judge for an Order to make the unborn child a 'ward of the Court' for the duration of the delivery and subsequent treatment, thus assuming temporary guardianship. What the Social Services do after that is another matter...

I know from personal experience (i.e my Mother spent most of her working life as a maternity nurse) that his occurred on more than one occasion, although only in rare circumstances.
 

NotmeChief

Banned
This is part of their religious doctrination and has happened many times in the past.

However, maybe - just maybe in todays sue anything and everything climate, that was the idea.
Perhaps they decided to refuse thinking the docs would intervene.
 
Personally I believe in individual autonomy except where that autonomy harms others in the Millian topos of 'harm'. Just as an adult of sound mind (whatever that actually is) should be entitled to abort a fetus which is incapable of surviving naturally ex utero, so an adult should be able to kill themselves or cause others to passivly assist their suicide through abstinence. It should be remembered that passive euthanasia is not illegal in the UK, only in the active form.

See the Suicide Act 1961.
 
Hmm, so God would rather a woman die, and her children grow up without a mother than have a blood transfusion?

If this is the God, imagine the devil.

May I also remind you that the Jehovah's Witness movement forbids followers from marrying non-Jehovah's Witnesses, and as I was reading in a copy of the Watchtower magazine, takes "Secret Dating" (i.e. youths dating without their parent's knowledge) to be a deeply shameful act. And also if they are frequently wrong about the date of Armageddon, surely there is the possibility they are wrong about blood transfusions?
 

NotmeChief

Banned
Potential_Officer said:
Hmm, so God would rather a woman die, and her children grow up without a mother than have a blood transfusion?

If this is the God, imagine the devil.

May I also remind you that the Jehovah's Witness movement forbids followers from marrying non-Jehovah's Witnesses, and as I was reading in a copy of the Watchtower magazine, takes "Secret Dating" (i.e. youths dating without their parent's knowledge) to be a deeply shameful act. And also if they are frequently wrong about the date of Armageddon, surely there is the possibility they are wrong about blood transfusions?

You and I might think that, but they have every right to worship who and how they want and if that includes 'no blood transfusions' then so be it. It harms neither me nor you.
 
Surely we should collectively get off of our high horses and let people live (and indeed die) in the manner that they wish to ?
Or are we so used to Labour's nanny state that we can't stand the idea of someone having the freedom to do just that?
 
I think we should respect her for believing so devoutly that she was ready to do this--------- I am a strong believer in having the right to die, and to have the right to do so with dignity, in the way we so choose-- and bottom line this is what she chose.

It is her faith, her belief, and her choice- who are we to criticise?
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
R Consequences of refusing to go to sea. Submariners 13
SkullFuct Soldier refusing to return to Afghanistan Current Affairs 70
F P.C refusing posting to Israel embassy Current Affairs 2
MoD_RSS Landmark change to blood donation criteria MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Warfarin and other blood thinners – reminder on safe use during COVID-19 pandemic MoD News 0
MoD_RSS First far north “blood bike” named MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Coronavirus (COVID-19) and high blood pressure medication MoD News 0
MoD_RSS DVLA unveils Blood Bikes Wales as their Charity of Choice for 2020 MoD News 0
H Vaccinations/blood grouping Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 7
MoD_RSS Reducing saturated fat lowers blood cholesterol and risk of CVD MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Infected blood scandal: increased financial support for victims confirmed MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Three further batches of blood pressure and heart medication recalled from pharmacies MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Additional blood pressure and heart medication recalled from pharmacies MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: MHRA recalls more blood pressure and heart medication from pharmacies as a precaution MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Irbesartan blood pressure and heart medication recalled from pharmacies by MHRA MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: MHRA recalls Valsartan blood pressure and heart medication from pharmacies MoD News 0
C Aircrew Medical Blood Pressure Joining the Royal Navy 15
Goatherder What is the origin of the nickname 'Blood' Reed/Reid? The Quarterdeck 14
WelshJaffaCake Blood type RFA 36
MoD_RSS Press release: New research shows need for emergency responders to carry blood MoD News 0
G Where to find out blood type? RFA 17
H failed medical due to high blood pressure Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 46
Ageing_Gracefully First Book Comp of 2014 - Fields of Blood Competitions 13
Ageing_Gracefully 2nd July Competition - INVESTMENT IN BLOOD Competitions 12
T Blood/Bone/Organ Donor's Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 10
D Blood pressure Health & Fitness 4
alfred_the_great One for AngryDoc - relationship between Stroke Volume and Blood Pressure Health & Fitness 6
mcreature Blood Bro. Nautical Jokes 2
A Blood type Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 35
Polycell New blood needed Submariners 0
I Blood Pressure Health & Fitness 4
Bergen Dean Richards and Harlequin RFC Blood Injuries Diamond Lil's 6
Ollie-O Blood and Adrenaline The Gash Barge 5
werqpr Blood Pressure Health & Fitness 8
werqpr blood pressure Health & Fitness 16
P URGENT: High Blood Pressure, Medically Discarged Health & Fitness 43
werqpr blood test Health & Fitness 3
R Blood Pressure Health & Fitness 7
Chicogiz Blood risk for UK soldiers and civilians The Quarterdeck 4
wet_blobby spitting blood. Diamond Lil's 11
The_Wonderer Blood Pressure Health & Fitness 21
slim A jab that will cure high blood pressure Diamond Lil's 2
brazenhussy blood transfusion.................... Current Affairs 9
S Blood Pressure The Quarterdeck 42
D Males after young blood! Diamond Lil's 24
Similar threads













































Latest Threads

Top