Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Pirates block Britain's bid to rule waves (Daily Mail 16 Aug 11)

broadside

War Hero
Sorry WLS I still think this is sloppy reporting and hiding it in the business pages hasn't helped.

IMO it isn't balanced, it is just a 2nd rate piece of regurgitation of published (elsewhere) facts and a few added comments from assorted officials and pundits. The editorial "balance" you suggest would come in the analysis and there isn't a lot of that in this article. In fact I would go so far as to say it is more than a bit thin, it is glaringly threadbare in places - starting with the not-so-Gucci graphics.

How can you have 362 reported hostages under the left hand Somalia column (implying total hostages taken during the entire reporting period) yet there are 377 hostages currently being held (right hand column) - if they haven't been reported how do you know they are there?

Whether the mistake is by the ICC/IMB or by the Mail Graphics department or by the writer himself (Hugo Duncan) is irrelevant - it SHOULD have been picked up before publication.

In summary - definitely up to the usual standards of the Daily Mail which is either long on vitriol and short on substance or, as in this case, just sheer lazy.
 
According to the IMB website, the figure for hostages currently held should be 355 instead of 377 so it looks like a careless typo:

Please see below figures for piracy and armed robbery incidents as reported to the IMB Piracy Reporting Centre in 2011.

Worldwide Incidents: updated on 18 Aug 2011
Total Attacks Worldwide: 314
Total Hijackings Worldwide: 31

Incidents Reported for Somalia:
Total Incidents: 178
Total Hijackings:22
Total Hostages: 362
Total Killed: 7

Current vessels held by Somali pirates:
Vessels: 18
Hostages: 355
This minor error doesn't affect the gist of the the article which appears balanced, informative and timely. I hope the message is starting to get through.
 

broadside

War Hero
I'm not saying the article isn't "balanced" - I am saying that the balance has stuff all to do with the Daily Mail editorial contribution. All the journo has done is collate a series of numbers (not very effectively) and a number of quotes and comments from external sources. There is no "publisher's slant" so the balance is simply the facts speaking for themselves.

I suppose there should be SOME credit to the Daily Mail in that they haven't tried to score any cheap points out of it.
 
This was why I linked it. The business pages are the most balanced part of the entire newspaper and don't usually go for the hysterical approach like the front bit does. It's pretty much left alone to get on with the job.

It serves as a nice reminder why the RN is so important to the UK and was why I was surprised it didn't get a mention on the Defence Media analysis.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
soleil Star: "Britney Spears Is Being Used To Scare Off Somali Pirates." Current Affairs 6
S Piracy Task Forces Meet to Combat Somalia Pirates Current Affairs 10
sgtpepperband News Story: "British ship heading to ward off Somali pirates held at port in Spain" The Quarterdeck 9
soleil Mail: "Ahoy Heir: Prince Charles Tours Royal Navy Warship That Targets Pirates" The Fleet 0
MoD_RSS News story: Royal Navy Lynx hunts pirates from French frigate MoD News 0
soleil The Sun: "Pirates On The Rocks - Navy Sinks 17 Boats In Sea Bandit War" The Fleet 2
soleil The National: "Pirates On The Back Foot, Says UK Royal Navy Commander" Current Affairs 0
MoD_RSS Marines train to tackle pirates MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Royal Navy Lynx aids capture of suspected pirates MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Marines train to tackle pirates MoD News 0
soleil Falmouth Pkt: "Cornish Pirates Players Put Through Their Paces By Culdrose Trainers" The Fleet Air Arm 0
soleil Bath Chronicle: "Bath Naval Volunteer Helped Beat Pirates" Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 0
soleil Independent: "Navy Frees Four Out Of Five Suspected Somali Pirates" Current Affairs 8
soleil Western Morning News: "Royal Navy To Tackle Somali Pirates" The Fleet 0
MoD_RSS RFA Fort Victoria disembarks pirates for prosecution in the Seychelles Current Affairs 0
Seaweed Should the payment of ransoms to pirates be criminalised? Current Affairs 10
MoD_RSS Navy captures 13 Somali pirates Current Affairs 2
soleil BBC News: "Royal Navy Arrests Suspected Pirates Off Somali Coast" Current Affairs 8
soleil Pompey News: "Captain Who Took On Pirates Awarded An OBE" The Fleet 0
MoD_RSS Royal Navy frees fishermen from suspected Somali pirates Current Affairs 2
soleil Express: "Pirates Foiled As Navy Strikes Again" The Fleet 1
MoD_RSS Navy frees hostages from pirates in Indian Ocean Current Affairs 0
trelawney126 RN Board Italian Vessel taken by Somali Pirates Current Affairs 0
soleil Navy News: "Somerset Ready To Take The Fight To Pirates" The Fleet 0
Naval_Gazer Health and safety defeats Marines who tackled Somali pirates The Corps 1
soleil Express: "Pirates Outwit Us, Says Royal Marine" Current Affairs 1
soleil Express: British Firm Finds Weapon To Defeat Somali Pirates ... Golf Balls Current Affairs 6
trelawney126 Indian Navy 61 Pirates 0 Current Affairs 2
MoD_RSS HMS Cornwall rescues hostages from pirates Current Affairs 21
soleil Telegraph: "Spirit Of Adventure: Behind The Rise Of The Somali Pirates" Current Affairs 5
soleil Daily Express: "Pirates: The Shocking Truth" Current Affairs 3
daffy1 South Korea deals with Pirates. Current Affairs 3
soleil Navy News: "Royal Navy 4 Pirates 0" The Fleet 0
Scouse_Castaway RFA take down Pirates Current Affairs 11
Hermes_R12 Royal Navy are pirates, says Argentinas president Current Affairs 34
soleil "NATO Warship HMS Montrose Disrupts Pirates" The Fleet 1
soleil Register: "Dutch Send Submarine To Fight Somali Pirates" Submariners 0
Naval_Gazer BBC News: HMS Chatham foils Somali pirates again The Fleet 2
NotmeChief Russia forces storm oil tanker seized by Somali pirates. Current Affairs 14
R12_CV British Navy Hands Suspected Pirates Over to Kenya Current Affairs 2
HarryBosch HMS Chatham foils pirates Current Affairs 6
soleil Lancs. Evening Post: "Navy Dad Foils Somali Pirates" Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 1
soleil Reuters: Somali pirates arrested by RN sentenced to 20 years Current Affairs 3
S Yeovilton pilots' efforts to stop Somali pirates (Beeb) Petitions 3
soleil Navy News: "Chatham takes up the fight against pirates" The Fleet 0
BillyNoMates Somalian Pirates defeated at last ! Diamond Lil's 0
soleil Daily Mail 28/01/10 - Mac Cartoon - RN/Pirates Current Affairs 2
Seaweed Pirates hijack yacht Current Affairs 36
Seaweed Merchant skipper tackled pirates Current Affairs 12
trelawney126 HMS Lancaster Sails to Tackle Pirates (Guzz first stop?) Current Affairs 2
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

Top