Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

New Chinese fast attack craft...I want one!

MonkeyTennis

Midshipman
Yeah - looks gucci and all that but you know it's gonna run out of batteries, fall apart cos the plastic is cheap - and theres loads of hidden sharp bits that could hurt a child. Honestly - just think back to chrimbo...
 

stumpy

War Hero
;)

Whereas BAE make wonderful ships...

I makes me wonder, China are making these kickass ships, whereas we are building larger fishery protection ships armed with... a single 30mm...
 

Not_a_boffin

War Hero
Horses for courses chaps. Johnny Chink wants to do sea denial to a blue water force (can't think which) in sea state not very much, whereas we want to provide sustained MACP to DEFRA against Spanish trawlers in sea state bouncy.

Much as one might want to, you can't just go round popping SSM at yer poor Spanish trawlerman - it's against his human rights innit?

And as those things are emphatically not SWATHS, much more like the Incat wave-piercers, you wouldn't want to be on them in much more than a sea state moderate.......
 

McCloggie

Lantern Swinger
Yes, they look good and yes, they could be useful small ships.

Questions to be asked/answered:

Where are they supposed to operate?
Could they survive/operate in North Sea/North Atlantic conditions?
What is their role?
What would be thier role in the RN?
Can UK build something similar at the same price anyway?
And if not, would we buy a squadron of Chinese ships?

This is before we even get to the Chinese quality arguement!

IF quality is OK, and IF there is/was a role for something like this for the RN somewhere in the world then OK let's get something similar. My own feelings are that these boats are superfluous to the role of the RN.

McC
 

stumpy

War Hero
While deep water operations is important most of our operations seem to be in the litoral or in the Gulf region. These Chinese ships seem to have a shallow draft, perfect for the Gulf. By its nature minewarfare tends to happen in relatively shallow water near the coast, again this ship would be perfect, especially as with the living spaces above water I guess that crew survivability if it hits a mine could be relatively good, even if the ship was trashed (but what ship wouldn't be?). If the missile pods could be containerised/modular you could have a flexible ship able to go head to head with Iranian boats, or carry out MCM, or patrol for pirates/terrorists with a RIB replaceing a missile pod.

Miost of the designs for the C3 role are basically a OPV, this way you would get a mini warship with some punch and keep the new River Class ship for protecting our fish.

I know it is a pity that you can't use Harpoon on the Spanish fishermen, but then again I would have thought that Spearfish would be better anyway.... ;)
 

stumpy

War Hero
Also, what would make a Spanish fishermen think twice, a venerable Hunt class bimbling over the horizon, or one of these coming from astern at 36 knots....
 

Seaweed

War Hero
Book Reviewer
Presumably this thing is for use in the Formosa Strait. Nice of Australia to design it.
 

silverfox

War Hero
Moderator
Book Reviewer
stumpy said:
Also, what would make a Spanish fishermen think twice, a venerable Hunt class bimbling over the horizon, or one of these coming from astern at 36 knots....

In my experience - neither....
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
MoD_RSS UK warns of Chinese global cyber attacks MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Foreign Secretary call with Chinese Foreign Minister - 28 July 2020 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS The Foreign Secretary's call with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Chinese graduates of UK universities donate two ventilators to the NHS MoD News 0
U Has "Chinese Flu" crippled the West long term? Current Affairs 18
MoD_RSS Hong Kong protests and the Chinese-British Joint Declaration: Foreign Secretary's statement MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Dream comes true for Chinese twin Peppa Pig fans as they visit the UK MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Chinese market access gives a multimillion pound boost for British beef MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: PM and Chancellor meeting with Chinese Vice Premier Hu: 17 June 2019 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Downing Street transformed for Chinese New Year celebration MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: PM's Chinese New Year video message 2019 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Avian flu: advice for travellers over Chinese New Year MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: UK and allies reveal global scale of Chinese cyber campaign MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Chinese New Year 2017: Theresa May's message MoD News 1
blueschill A Chinese 3000mph Super Sub!? Really??? Current Affairs 13
scouse FAA Chinese Style The Fleet Air Arm 3
Ninja_Stoker Chinese adverts - anyone? Site Issues 5
soleil Mail: "Chinese Hackers Caught Trying To Steal Secrets Of Our New Stealth Fighter" The Fleet Air Arm 0
F Fancy a Chinese takeaway leftover The Gash Barge 9
BillyNoMates Chinese fake shit Diamond Lil's 13
Rumrat The friggin Chinese know how to name it. Miscellaneous 4
wave_dodger Chinese conduct deck landings with J-15s at sea Current Affairs 6
trelawney126 Chinese Navy & SSBN's boats Current Affairs 3
Drakey Learn Chinese in 5 minutes The Quarterdeck 0
J Chinese soldiers pass live grenade Diamond Lil's 7
Seaweed Chinese aircraft carrier Shi Lang, ex-Varyag Current Affairs 55
trelawney126 Greyfriers "Bobby" gets Chinese Makeover. Miscellaneous 0
Rigsby 2012 Chinese Olympic Team to be based in Leeds Diamond Lil's 2
stan_the_man New Chinese Carrier Diamond Lil's 25
trelawney126 Chinese Building Carrier Current Affairs 8
Constant_Bad_Mood Chinese couple Blue Jokes 3
D Chinese Laundry Porn Diamond Lil's 16
Stirling The Chinese are coming Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 2
trelawney126 Chinese unveil Stealth Fighter Current Affairs 8
soleil Guardian: "Chinese Businessman Bids £5m For HMS Invincible" The Fleet 9
whitemouse Chinese Delivery Man Miscellaneous 0
whitemouse Chinese Newly weds Blue Jokes 0
B CHINESE MEAL Miscellaneous 1
soleil T'graph: "MoD Drops British Socks For Cheaper Chinese Ones" Current Affairs 22
NotmeChief Hows about the Chinese singer known as 'Fat'? The Internet - Best and Worst 3
sussex2 Obamas' Chinese visit... The Gash Barge 9
M Black and white Chinese people?? The Gash Barge 0
N Russians sink Chinese Merchant Ship Current Affairs 10
D Chinese wedding cake The Quarterdeck 16
janner There was a Scotsman an Italian and a Chinese man The Gash Barge 2
Seaweed Chinese naval base Hainan Current Affairs 28
O Chinese laundry The Fleet 13
H Chinese checkers ? Current Affairs 0
Welshbird Anyone order a chinese? Diamond Lil's 6
chinamatelot The uninvited guest - Chinese boat embarrasses US Navy Submariners 28
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

New Posts

Top