Navy's new "Pointless Frigates"

wave_dodger

MIA
Book Reviewer
A colleague pointed this out to me Lewis Page writes yet more drivel, its pretty amazing that someone can write such ill-informed, opinionated rubbish and still expect to be regarded as a serious journalist!

I love the picture of the T23 with a "30mm for DHOWS", he managed to count the Harpoons but clearly became confused with the VLS Seawolf's :lol:

And then our expert spouts "Rather, its (a frigate) main job - if it can really be said to have one - is hunting submarines. However, this is actually done almost entirely by the frigate's helicopter*. Anti-submarine helicopters can be (and often are) operated at sea in larger numbers and much more cheaply aboard fleet-auxiliary vessels, so it's hard to see why you would bother buying expensive frigates for this purpose".

Now there it is, the experience of his PWO training and extensive time on DD/FFs. We hunt sub surface contacts entirely by HELO, never use the Towed Array Sonar, or the Hull Mounted Sonar (or other, CESM, SIGINT assets)...so therefore we can use RFAs and get rid of frigates entirely. :eek:

Then our illustrious educator has a crack at Harpoon "But eight Harpoons isn't an amount of punch you would need a several-thousand-ton ship with a crew in three figures to carry. Eight Harpoons would call for a fast-attack boat, or a corvette at best. And frankly, given that you're going to need aircraft to find or confirm the far-away targets to begin with, it makes more sense to deliver the munitions by air as well. Carrier jets are a much more sensible option here than frigates: helicopters can also carry powerful air-to-surface weapons."

I think there are more, and better, ways of identifying OTH targets than that these days. Smacks of a lack of currency and even imagination!

And displaying signs of utter fantasy: "In general, in a hypothetical battle between a Type 26 combat ship and an unarmed enemy merchant ship carrying several helicopters to the 26's single one, the merchant ship will probably win as it can keep aircraft flying round the clock. The merchant ship can also do a better job at hunting subs, for the same reason."

So, as the Frigates zipps around at XX knots, slapping Harpoon at the unarmed merchant ship before it can get its helo's airborne; or while its busy engagiong them with Seawolf!! I'd rather be on the frigate...plus has Mr Page even considered the personnel required to support, operate and maintain several armed helicopters from a ship - ah that would be OCEAN!

More deluded rambling, "A frequent justification for frigates and destroyers is that you need them to protect carriers, but the fact of the matter is that carriers can protect themselves on their own far better than the escort ships can."

So, a carrier with a limited AA capability, no towed array of its own- doesn't need escorts? So the entire US Carrier Battlegroup concept is wrong, Lewis has said so!

The final ramblings are interested; “Type 26 is a key component in sustaining a surface warship capability in UK industry," says BAE's surface-warship chief Alan Johnston", Or in other words we need to have some frigates so as to avoid closing our frigate yards, so that we will be able to have even more frigates in future. Tail wags dog: ice-cream licks itself"

In this Page may have had a credible argument but I don't agree with his stance. At the height of WW2 we were churning out a submarine every 4 weeks, surface ships of varying types in generally 4-6 weeks. These days ships (and aircraft) are so incredibly complex they take years to design and build even if you ignore the MoD contractual snags. Do we or don't we want an organic UK industrial capacity? I suggests its in our national interests to ensure we do, yet Mr Page clearly isn't so sure.
 
G

guestm

Guest
He's a clown. Not for the first time he has made himself look a tit to anyone with even a basic understanding of Naval Warfare and RN capability.

He also writes like an 11 year old.
 

Toucan

Lantern Swinger
Montigny-La-Palisse said:
He's a clown. Not for the first time he has made himself look a tit to anyone with even a basic understanding of Naval Warfare and RN capability.

He also writes like an 11 year old.
His CV is somewhat worrying...

http://lewispage.blogspot.com/ said:
Armed Forces Career:

University Air Squadron, RAF 1988-91

Royal Navy officer 1993-2004

* Navigator, HMS Quorn 1994-96
* Long Mine Clearance Diving Officer course 1996-97
* Ops Officer, HMS Middleton 1997-98
* All-arms Commando course 1997
* Executive Officer, HMS Bridport 1998-01
* Officer in Charge, Southern Diving Unit One 2001-04
* Joint Improvised Explosive Device Disposal No. 1 Operator course 2001

Education:

Cambridge University (Engineering degree 1988-91, St John's College)
Islington Green Comprehensive
 

Guns

War Hero
Moderator
Must. Not. Swear.........F":*ing C&*K

I really would like to meet him and discuss his ramblings. He has no idea of current maritime operations, is limited in his Naval experience and I suspect some PWO off a FF/DD did his misuses when he was at sea. It can be the only reason I can think of.
 

Spidiver

War Hero
I had the misfortune to train this feckin cretin on his LMCDO's course, his Daddy was something big in the Telegraph, can't remember what, but this cnut was a typical silver spooned feckin hurah.

I tried to have him removed from training but was over-ruled, I took solace in the fact that I personally would never have to serve any where near the twat.

I can't be arsed to explain just how big a cnut this twat is.
 

IS-Potential

Lantern Swinger
hmmm a few more threads with carefully chosen keywords and we might get the Rum Ration threads about Mr Page to appear first in search engine rankings....

Not a problem W_D, interesting to see reactions from people who missed the first thread ;)
 

Toucan

Lantern Swinger
I can see what FF/DD stand for, but why FF and DD? Why not just F and D?

Bone questions R us...
 
Toucan said:
I can see what FF/DD stand for, but why FF and DD? Why not just F and D?

Bone questions R us...
As with many things, we and NATO have followed US Navy policy:

USN Ship Designations

www.navweaps.com/ said:
Nomenclature History

Warships in the United States Navy were first designated and numbered in system originating in 1895. Under this system, ships were designated as "Battleship X", "Cruiser X", "Destroyer X", "Torpedo Boat X" and so forth where X was the series hull number as authorized by the US Congress. These designations were usually abbreviated as "B-1", "C-1", "D-1", "TB-1," etc. This system became cumbersome by 1920, as many new ship types had been developed during World War I that needed new categories assigned, especially in the Auxiliary ship area. On 17 July 1920, the designation system was revised so that all ships were now designated with a two letter code and a hull number, with the first letter being the ship type and the second letter being the sub-type. For example, the destroyer tender USS Melville, first commissioned as "Destroyer Tender No. 2" in 1915, was now re-designated as "AD-2" with the "A" standing for Auxiliary, the "D" for Destroyer (Tender) and the "2" meaning the second ship in that series. Ship types that did not have a subclassification simply repeated the first letter. So, Battleships became "BB-X" and Destroyers became "DD-X" with X being the same number as previously assigned. Ships that changed classifications were given new hull numbers within their new designation series...
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
S US Navy leadership culture International 4
B Royal Navy Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 10
soleil Portsmouth News: "34 Great Old Photos Of The Famous Royal Navy Aircraft Carrier HMS Hermes" The Fleet 1
soleil Sun: "Royal Navy Submarine Crews Face 14-day Quarantine To Prevent Coronavirus Outbreak" Submariners 7
soleil Portsmouth News: "Royal Navy Aircraft Carrier HMS Prince Of Wales To Carry Out Investigation After Flooding Onboard" The Fleet 16
soleil Scuba Diver Mag: "Heart of Oak – On Board The Royal Navy’s HMS Richmond" The Fleet 0
soleil YT: Royal Navy - An Interview With F-35 Pilot Lt Cdr Stephen Collins, Call Sign Lothar The Fleet Air Arm 1
soleil VE Day 75 - A Royal Navy Retrospective The Fleet 0
H Navy or RAF Nursing? Joining the Royal Navy 7
soleil The News: "Royal Navy Warships To Blast Sirens And Light The Sky As Portsmouth Marks VE Day" The Fleet 9
soleil Helensburgh Advertiser: "Royal Navy To Pay Faslane Tribute On VE Day 75th Anniversary" Bases / Shore Est 7
S Merchant Navy to RNR Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 3
soleil The News: "Royal Navy Destroyer Prone To Breaking Down In The Gulf Leaves Portsmouth For Key Engine Upgrade" The Fleet 3
soleil FB: "Video About The Royal Navy Photographic Branch, Created By Leading Photographer Dan Shepherd" #RNPhoto100 The Fleet 0
D What's wrong with the navy today? The Gash Barge 25
soleil FB: Royal Australian Navy Band - In Flanders Fields - Anzac Day 2020 History 1
A Am I banned from joining the navy? Joining the Royal Navy 19
M Holiday booked will I still be able to go if I start my navy application? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 9
soleil FB: National Museum Of The Royal Navy - Warrior Webcam Bases / Shore Est 1
0 Joining the Navy as AET compared to RAF aircraft technician Joining the Royal Navy 26
soleil FB: Royal Navy and Royal Marines Charity - RNRMC Submarine Fund (RNRMC-SMF) Submariners 1
D Corona virus-Will Navy Net ever recover? Diamond Lil's 20
higthepig Navy news March 2020 The Quarterdeck 0
E Considering joining the Royal Navy- looking for advice Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 16
soleil Daily Record: "Royal Navy Crew Salute NHS Staff On River Clyde In Show Of Thanks Amidst Coronavirus Lockdown" The Fleet 0
soleil LadBible: "Former Navy Submariner Shares Coping Strategies For Self-Isolation And Social Distancing" Submariners 3
H Army JNCO to Navy Officer Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 4
soleil Army v Navy Rugby Match, May 2nd 2020, Cancellation Sports and Adventure Training 0
higthepig Navy news February 2020 The Quarterdeck 0
D What do biomedical scientists do in the Navy? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 5
soleil KL.FM 96.7: "Navy Boat Visit For King's Lynn" SCC and URNU 3
soleil Asian Image: "Royal Navy Admiral Visits Birmingham’s Central Mosque" The Fleet 2
soleil The Maritime Executive: "How the Royal Navy Searches Boats for Narcotics" The Fleet 6
soleil Royal Navy And Royal Marines Charity - Build Your Own Aircraft Carrier Charity 2
H How long is a contract in Royal Navy? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
D Is the Royal Navy psychometric test the same for the Royal Marines? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 1
C Are the Royal Marines part of the Royal Navy itself? The Corps 5
higthepig Navy news January 2020 The Quarterdeck 2
soleil FB: "A Royal Navy Valentine" The Fleet 1
M Barrie Trower fake ex Navy microwave weapons expert The Quarterdeck 5
J Applying for pilot roles in Navy and RAF simultaneously Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 48
R Royal Navy Engineering Advice Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 39
A Unknown Navy bullion badge History 4
soleil Droitwich Standard: "Sailors To Dock In Droitwich To Talk About 'The Role Of The Royal Navy'" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil Navy News (FB): North Shields - HMS Northumberland - Ship Open To Visitors - Saturday, February 8th 2020 The Fleet 1
soleil PlymouthLive: "Royal Navy Frigate Shares Video Of Dolphin Escort After Russia Mission" The Fleet 0
A LET transferring from Navy to RM Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 13
soleil D. Star: "Royal Navy Warship Intercepts Four Russian Vessels In English Channel" The Fleet 3
soleil CornwallLive: "Search To Find Owner Of Royal Navy Service Coin Found On Cornish Beach" The Fleet Air Arm 1
O Territorial Army to Navy Paperwork Joining the Royal Navy 1
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

Top