Lt Cdr to Cdr Promotion

wave_dodger

MIA
Book Reviewer
Anyone else looked at the Galaxy Brief that was issued last week regarding SO2 to SO1 promotion. Of real interest is the introduction of “Man-Years’ Limits†to control the average time left to serve.

Now don't call me a cynical old bluffer but isn't that just pushing the age on promotion up to at least 40/41.

I'm sure I've read somewhere that promotion was to requirement and based upon MERIT. This seems to say its on time served and age!
 

purpleronnie

Midshipman
Promotion is based upon merit AND potential, not just merit. If you are CINCFLEET material then age is irrelevant and you will be promoted as and when the system needs to in order to keep you moving and get you the right experience. If, like the rest of us mere mortals, you have a ceiling of say Commodore, then it is obvious that there is no point in being promoted to Commander too young. Working backwards from the retirement age of 55, if you serve one job as a Commodore, then you need to be promoted at 53. This means that if you are to do 2 jobs as a Captain, before being promoted, then you need to be promoted to Captain around 48/49. In order to be promoted to Captain, you need to have experienced at least 3 of the following 4 : Sea Command, a Staff Job, a MOD job and possibly a NATO job. Assuming you get promoted after the 3rd or 4th job, you need to be promoted to Commander between 40 and 42.

I would suggest that the ages you quote are based on that logic rather than a mandatory "time served" criteria.

But I might be wrong!
 
In a recent brief I received from the promotion section of DNCM, it was revealed that irrespective of time served either in the RN or in the rank of Lt Cdr, promotion to Cdr is being aimed at 40 year olds and above. What utter typical woolly thinking guff from the intellectual pygmies and halfwits who now stuff our exalted "human resources" directorate.

Purpleronnie is absolutely correct in his assertions about working backwards from 1*, but what if you have some bright SO2 who has achieved all of the requisite skills by 35, having joined up at 18? Should he be held over for 5 years while his equally clever graduate colleague, who joined BRNC at the same time at 23 be pushed up the system? An age based system is perverse, unfair and probably illegal and the sooner the (rather impressive) new 2SL sees this the better.

The RN is the only organisation in the world who treats their brightest officers like this - other companies and even other services recognise that an experienced (note I'm not talking about token promotions of boy Cdrs for show) and capable young manager can easily hold their own amongst people many years older. It works in commerce, it works in the Army (I met a 37 yr old full Colonel last month) and up until recently it worked in the RN.

No wonder everyone's leaving to work for a decent employer. I bet the monkeys who put McDonald's employees into branches don't call themselves "career manager" (who in the RN purely appoint).

Rant over!
 

SILVER_FOX

War Hero
Since I'm between posts at the moment and my next role is likely to keep me well away from the circulation for such things - any chance that one of you fine fellows could zap me a copy to read?
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
F Lt Cdr Promotion Signal The Fleet 3
boredwafu Lt-Lt Cdr Promotion signal The Fleet 85
F Lt Cdr/Major Promotion Signal Current Affairs 2
soleil YT: Royal Navy - An Interview With F-35 Pilot Lt Cdr Stephen Collins, Call Sign Lothar The Fleet Air Arm 1
soleil London Bridge: "40 Years In The Reserves" - Lt Cdr Liz Church Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 13
Stirlin Lt Cdr Derek Eggleton SCC and URNU 0
Magic_Mushroom Lt Cdr Kris Ward RN (Retd) RIP The Fleet Air Arm 1
R Lt Cdr Henry 'Nobby' HALL. Obit. The Fleet Air Arm 1
W Lt/Cdr (S.C.C.) Cyril Bartlett M.B.E. R.N.R RIP Nearest & Dearest 1
BARNEYRNSM LT CDR (SCC) Eddie Temple MBE RNR SCC and URNU 1
Seaweed Cdr HW Goulding RNR The Quarterdeck 10
Seaweed Lt Cdr RS Baker-Falkner DSO DSC RN, 1916-44 The Fleet Air Arm 0
A A polite request for info ref Lt Cdr Glen Robinson Moltke HMS Coventry. Nearest & Dearest 4
Waspie Lt Cdr Tim Barker (Deceased - Oct 2013) The Fleet Air Arm 0
scouse Lt Cdr Peter Davis The Fleet Air Arm 4
scouse This day 12 th February LT/CDR Eugene Esmonde The Fleet Air Arm 0
scouse Cdr Doc Golden and Winching The Fleet Air Arm 17
Naval_Gazer RIP - Lt Cdr Peter Twiss OBE DSC* RN The Fleet Air Arm 3
G Lt Cdr Ian Molyneux Memorial Trophy, 25/08/11, Barrow in Furness Charity 3
trelawney126 Boarding School. Courts Martial of Cdr. Current Affairs 78
scouse LT /CDR Monty Davenport Current Affairs 1
scouse LT/CDR Stuart Jewers The Fleet Air Arm 0
scouse LT/CDR Barklie Lakin Submariners 5
soleil Metro: "Lt Cdr Mike Jones-Thompson - The Last British Soldier Left In Basra" Bases / Shore Est 5
soleil Telegraph: Cdr Jeff Tall RN (SM) On The Chilean Miners Submariners 15
B LT CDR Colin Demowbrey RN Rtd The Fleet Air Arm 1
scouse LT/CDR David Foster The Fleet Air Arm 0
scouse LT/CDR LEE FAA The Fleet Air Arm 2
soleil Lt-Cdr Florry Ford notches up 5,000 flying hours The Fleet Air Arm 5
soleil Lt-Cdr Martin Lanni receives Air Force Cross at Holyrood The Fleet Air Arm 1
scouse LT/CDR Max Shean Submariners 6
P Lt Cdr - Cdr Signal The Fleet 25
soleil CSS Awards to Lt Peter Reed and Lt Cdr Micky Norford Sports and Adventure Training 2
alfred_the_great Lt - Lt Cdr Signal (not Norman!!!!) The Fleet 25
A Obituary Cdr Alec Dennis, captured Enigma machine and codes Current Affairs 4
A Cdr Ian Coulton Current Affairs 29
drwibble Surg Lt Cdr David Hughes RN Current Affairs 1
T Lt Cdr John Bridge GC GM* RNVR Current Affairs 3
D CDR JEFF J TALL Submariners 23
MoD_RSS UN Human Rights Council 43: UK statement for the Interactive Dialogue with the Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights and MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Northern Powerhouse Minister backs Liverpool’s regeneration plans in first official visit since Cabinet promotion MoD News 0
S Promotion times (deck officer) RFA 13
MoD_RSS News story: Minister for Trade and Export Promotion announces HSBC as founding partner at Expo 2020 Dubai MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Lord Chancellor welcomes promotion of new silks MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Brigadier promotion for lifetime Reservist and Dstl employee MoD News 0
J Getting deselected from promotion and loss of earning Health & Fitness 5
ws1602 Warfare Spec Promotion Ladder Joining the Royal Navy 3
J Promotion To leading hand Joining the Royal Navy 11
NateDogg Promotion time/ pay scales UPO/Careers Office 15
S Promotion likelyhood for Sea Spec Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 4
Similar threads


















































New Posts

Top