Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Just to prove that the Septics really can't fly


Deleted 7

And that, my friends, is why the yanks shouldn't fly under 100 feet!
The guy on the camera was as impressed as I was.

I fully admit fukc all knowledge of flying and all things flying beyond being cargo however can any of you fly-boys help me out. This accident occurred on a calm sea, excellent visibility and everything hunky-dory. Does this lull the pilot into a false sense of security? Are pilots more alert when say the sea state is more challenging or visibility is poor?


War Hero
Seen this one before, sent to me by an ex-CRAB. As he put it, it was a "failure of the stick-seat interface unit". Apparently the chap leaning out of the port side door didn't make it.


War Hero
Not a WAFU but:

Looks like ditched helo may have had snags before and on the approach. Two crash boats already in the water? Perhaps the fast approach and clumsy, short lived landing were pucker factor rather than showing off.

Nasty. I hate helos but I would like to be at the interview, sans coffee with the pilot who was showing off in the second clip assuming he and his more sensible buddy survived.

Pilot: May day, we're going down.
Controller: Can you tell me the nature (of your emergency).?

Why? Will it help?


This one's been doing the rounds for a while and (apparently) got the full picture on the sea knight crash from DHFS.

- Nothing wrong with cab

- Too fast and low on approach for no reason

- Crewman only one to get out - 18 marines + front seats didn't

Numnums, from personal experience yes. Just something you have to be aware of until your skids hit the ground.
junglynx said:
This one's been doing the rounds for a while and (apparently) got the full picture on the sea knight crash from DHFS.

- Nothing wrong with cab

- Too fast and low on approach for no reason

- Crewman only one to get out - 18 marines + front seats didn't

Numnums, from personal experience yes. Just something you have to be aware of until your skids hit the ground.

I thought I'd read it was 8 that didn't make it and about a dozen rescued. Hope I'm right.

In wherever I read the previous bit about survivors, the follow on boats were part of an exercise with special ops; either SEALS or their a unit of their Special Boat Squadrons I'd guess.


This clip is shown during the Dunker course at Yeovilton. Sadly only one person got out - the crewman in the hatch.


This accident occurred off San Diego in 1998 during a USN SF exercise. The facts of the accident are as follows:

- The approach attempted was a 0/0 due to the hot conditions and heavy aircraft being flown. What this means is the pilot did not have the performance to hover, therefore was attempting to land on the deck just as he hit full power, this is a recognised and regularly practiced although difficult technique.

- He missed the spot and was attempting to re position. Once over the deck, the 'cushion' effect of the downwash over the deck would have improved his performance enough to allow him to do this.

- His left rear wheel was caught in the flight deck netting. None of the crew were aware of this.

- The application of power coupled with the 'attachment' of the aircraft to the deck created a pivot point about which the aircraft rotated. This led to an aerodynamic phenomenon in helos known as dynamic rollover. In brief, the aircraft reaches a point where the aerodynamic forces effectively 'fly' the aircraft over despite any inputs to the contrary from the pilot. It is a divergent condition.

- Look at the video again and you will see certain clues. First the ship is moving fast (wake) to generate wind to assist the pilot. They are conducting an offset approach to maximise 'clear' air over th flight deck. Look out for the trapped wheel on lift off. Watch the rate of roll closely, it accelerates.

- The crewman escaped, 19 people perished despite the attendance of the boats.

- These are the facts, I was in the US when it happened. There was no 'unprofessionalism' involved, just a very sad and very avoidable accident.



War Hero
I do not doubt the professionalism of the pilot Greenking, and I know nothing of the accident report but you do appear to, some questions then:

How far off San Diego?

Why attempt something so difficult with 18 marines in the back in peacetime?

What pressure was put on this pilot to land on the ship as opposed to diverting ashore?

Did they set out to attempt this?

A/C accidents are nearly always down to a chain of small, sometimes apparently insignificant errors, what were the conclusions of the BOI?


Lantern Swinger
It's easy to poke fun at our ex colony and I try to every day, but this is an awful example of needless loss of life. The technical description given a couple of posts ago suggests that this was a practice, but God, you don't practice with people in the back. If it was a genuine emergency maneouvre, fine, but what do you tell the relatives when the exercise planners just f**ked up? And presumably the dead were all SF?


Gents, I'm afraid we do practice with people in the back, it's the nature of the business. There is no such thing as a helicopter with so much power the pilot never has to worry about operating it. Even the CH47 struggles for performance in certain conditions with certain loads.

Training gives crews the tools to maximise their available performance while minimising risk to themselves and those who fly with them. However, like all military opetrations to a greater or lesser extent, you can never completely eliminate risk.

CT, to answer your questions, this was a routine approach during a routine exercise - nothing special. Unfortunately, the pilot got it wrong and they then became victims of an unfortunate series of events.

CTD, this was nothing to do with exercise planners 'f***ing' up. Support/Battlefied Helicopters are designed and operated to move troops around in all conditions.



War Hero
I appreciate we have to practice these things, I bet alot of Bootnecks who travel in MkV's might not be so keen to find that out though! Possibly worth looking into mitigating that risk some more.

I guess it brings it all home though, do you know what happened last time I F*****ked up? One of my lads ended up doing two weekend duties, I lost my duty roster somewhere in the ether!!


ChiefT, I was probably a bit woolly in my explanation regarding practice. We do practice and teach the techniques with nothing in the back. When we are full in the back or carrying a heavy load, we are doing these manoeuvres for real due to the weight of the aircraft and the consequent diminished performance.

This is true, in general terms, of all helos whatever their flavour. Just ask a bagger what his performance is like when he gets airborne from a CVS with a full fuel load. Likewise ASW drivers.

Just because we have the capability to hover, it doesn't mean we can and we have to have other techniques available to allow us to operate.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
MoD_RSS New coastal emergency 999 stickers could prove a real lifesaver MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Highways England traffic officers prove a real role 'model' for 10-year-old Toby MoD News 0
L Help to prove a chief wrong Diamond Lil's 48
D Trying to prove a medal History 6
soleil Pompey News: "Computer Tests Prove RN Carriers Will Be Able To Fit In Pompey Harbour" Bases / Shore Est 0
sgtpepperband Pompey News: "Charity challenge could prove a stretch..." Charity 0
5dits Ex Marine has to prove he is British Current Affairs 14
wet_blobby OIY, jesse prove me wrong...... Diamond Lil's 14
soleil So the Septics don't think we're up to it! Current Affairs 68
Rumrat Septics. Diamond Lil's 42
scouse Septics training Wafus??? The Fleet Air Arm 23
scouse Could be in for a bit of fun!!! when the Septics train us up for Flight Deck Ops The Fleet Air Arm 4
Topstop So F-18s it is then if the Septics want to save more money? The Fleet Air Arm 3
scouse Ark Royal Hands to flying Stations "Septics Only" Current Affairs 10
N Pongo`s discussing septics on arrse,quite funny Diamond Lil's 22
T Septics: Don't rely on the Brits during a battle! Current Affairs 7
bikerman septics fly pasts The Internet - Best and Worst 0
N Do not slag Septics by on the Net Diamond Lil's 26
chinamatelot For the septics... Diamond Lil's 10
soleil ForcesNet: "John Inverdale Praises 'Really Good' Navy Rugby Final" Sports and Adventure Training 0
MoD_RSS Grant Shapps: new ‘On Time’ statistics will stop masking whether trains are really on time MoD News 0
Coggie Really old photos History 1
C Really upset, and i dont know what to do??? Joining the Royal Navy 5
superpom Mmmmmm.....really? Diamond Lil's 84
Antonio555 How much will i really earn? CIS submariner Joining the Royal Navy 8
SONAR-BENDER I'm a Girl Guide! No, REALLY! I am! Diamond Lil's 13
ws1602 What is it really like? Joining the Royal Navy 7
Mess Webly Time What's it really like in the RNR? Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 11
B If these are Navy Leaders, we really are sunk The Gash Barge 91
SONAR-BENDER REALLY been stabbed in the back Diamond Lil's 3
slim Was the RN really better in the Old Farts Day? Diamond Lil's 102
S Navy Nursing, whats it really like?? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 5
SONAR-BENDER Has Argentina REALLY lost the plot? Diamond Lil's 4
PompeyPusser Is this really the best we can do? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 125
blueschill A Chinese 3000mph Super Sub!? Really??? Current Affairs 13
stan_the_man They really know how to get things right in Cornwall fcuking Pointy Heads Diamond Lil's 19
M What being is a Medical assistant general service really like? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 13
S HMS RALEIGH; What is it really like? The Fleet 83
Siannn. Just some really slightly tipsy daft stuff that I need to get off my chest... Diamond Lil's 76
fails_as_is Duty watch really turned to under the glory shower here... The Gash Barge 2
S What's life in the RN REALLY like? (please be honest) Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 56
2 Worked on a gash barge but it wasn't really what I had pictured.... The Gash Barge 28
MG Maniac Proof beer goggles really do work! Diamond Lil's 20
LaurenMc What really pisses me off Diamond Lil's 52
frogman007 Footballers really are Poxy queens The Quarterdeck 8
witsend Do you really want to join up? Diamond Lil's 13
wave_dodger Is this really newsworthy? Current Affairs 9
M Is it really that bad? Current Affairs 30
Magda Films you really don't like (but actually do). Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 6
Rumrat Their really trying Diamond Lil's 33
Similar threads

New Posts