Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

'I was told to pay death duty on Dad's medals'.

sweetpea

War Hero
Most - but not all - war medals won by heroic servicemen and women are subject to inheritance tax, as Rod Gilchrist discovered.

Like most old soldiers, my father Jim would never talk about the horrors he witnessed in the Second World War. He served as a signals officer with the Royal Navy on convoy duty in the treacherous waters of the north Atlantic, on the bridge of the admiral’s flagship on D-Day, and in operations to search and destroy enemy submarines in the Indian Ocean and off the west coast of Africa. It was dangerous work, and the sight of men drowning in torpedo oil as merchant ships were sunk in freezing waters was too painful to recount...

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/...as-told-to-pay-death-duty-on-Dads-medals.html

SP.
 

mikh

MIA
In a nutshell, yes, they should be valued, assessed and taxed, they are now the possessions of someone other than the person they were awarded to and they have an intrinsic value. Service personnel are taxed, their pensions are taxed, and their estate is taxed after they pass on. Medals are bought and sold every day, sometimes due to hardship, but often by people who have inherited them and see no reason to keep them and have no interest in them apart from their monetary value.
 

Ninja_Stoker

War Hero
Moderator
If the estate is worth £325,000 and the medals of significant commercial value, then rather than leave them gathering dust in a drawer, it would make sense to give the medals to a local museum to commemorate those brave deeds to a wider audience. The family could still see them, they would be secure and tax free.

The last living RN VC recipient sold his medal group and passed on the proceeds to his children to avoid any unseemly discontent. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/obituaries/2670609/Ian-Fraser-VC.html
 

FAAFLYNAVY

Lantern Swinger
I've always been of the opinion that medals should be awarded/issued on a loan only basis & should be returned after the death of the recipient.

Trading in them should be illegal, as should the wearing of them by anyone other then the recipient.

An old fashioned viewpoint perhaps, but this trading in them is unseemly to me.
 

fishhead

War Hero
I tried very hard to catch the outrage bus but it has left without me. If HMRC don't know you've got the medals they won't try and levy tax for them. Something along the lines of " I've no idea where they are, Dad moved house a few years ago and I haven't seen them since, he may have sold them" should suffice when they enquire.
 

Ninja_Stoker

War Hero
Moderator
The medals were of no significant value. £40. He should have kept his mouth shut.
To be honest, if my parents had left me an estate worth more than £325,000 I wouldn't quibble over £16. I accept the principle of ownership of the medals, but not the argument about being taxed.
 

danny

War Hero
I've always been of the opinion that medals should be awarded/issued on a loan only basis & should be returned after the death of the recipient.

Trading in them should be illegal, as should the wearing of them by anyone other then the recipient.

An old fashioned viewpoint perhaps, but this trading in them is unseemly to me.

I understand the wearing part, the rest seems of your post seems bizarre. What about people who die earning a VC in your eyes the VC should never be issued out.
I also wouldn't call it an old fashioned view considering the hundreds of thousands of medal sets claimed for killed family members during both world wars.
 
Last edited:

FAAFLYNAVY

Lantern Swinger
Not at all, medals/awards that are given posthumously would be recorded/certificated but not issued in a solid state, this would prevent them from entering this unseemly open market.

What has gone on before would be a "dead mans shoes" issue, but with the centenary of ww1 taking place I can envisage some being worn & paraded that have been handed down that were issued to old great uncle Fred who was someone's cousin twice removed who no one one ever knew.

Hardly a fitting tribute to old uncle Fred I feel.

But of course this is just a personal view.
 
Last edited:

danny

War Hero
Not at all, medals/awards that are given posthumously would be recorded/certificated but not issued in a solid state, this would prevent them from entering this unseemly open market.

What has gone on before would be a "dead mans shoes" issue, but with the centenary of ww1 taking place I can envisage some being worn & paraded that have been handed down that were issued to old uncle Fred who was someone's cousin twice removed who know one ever new.

Hardly a fitting tribute to old uncle Fred I feel.

But of course this is just a personal view.

No I agree they shouldn't be worn.

I just dont have an issue with them being sold. If someone wants to part with there hard earned cash to buy a bit of metal they never earned thats their business. It wouldn't stop walting as you can just buy copies anyway.
 
I

In_my_day

Guest
Not at all, medals/awards that are given posthumously would be recorded/certificated but not issued in a solid state, this would prevent them from entering this unseemly open market.

What has gone on before would be a "dead mans shoes" issue, but with the centenary of ww1 taking place I can envisage some being worn & paraded that have been handed down that were issued to old uncle Fred who was someone's cousin twice removed who no one one ever knew.

Hardly a fitting tribute to old uncle Fred I feel.

But of course this is just a personal view.
So you would not accept that the medals of a loved one killed in action would be an apt and cherished reminder to their children who must one day be told why they are growing up without a parent. I picture the scene (in the masculine) "...yes little Johnny your father was proud to serve his country and he was very brave. He saved 2 of his friends from being killed but tragically he died doing it, he was awarded the highest honour the country can give...here's the piece of paper!!" Bizarre isn't the half of it.

Even the wearing isn't wrong same family wife attends rememberance service, memorial or whatever. Why should she be deprived of the privilege of pride in the actions of her dead husband evinced by the wearing of his medals?

IMD
 

FAAFLYNAVY

Lantern Swinger
So you would not accept that the medals of a loved one killed in action would be an apt and cherished reminder to their children who must one day be told why they are growing up without a parent. I picture the scene (in the masculine) "...yes little Johnny your father was proud to serve his country and he was very brave. He saved 2 of his friends from being killed but tragically he died doing it, he was awarded the highest honour the country can give...here's the piece of paper!!" Bizarre isn't the half of it.

Even the wearing isn't wrong same family wife attends rememberance service, memorial or whatever. Why should she be deprived of the privilege of pride in the actions of her dead husband evinced by the wearing of his medals?

IMD
It's a case of each to his own, as I clearly stated it's just my personal & honest opinion, but these medals aren't all that cherished by families/descendents as it proved by the numbers that are being traded on the likes of eBay or at boot fairs/£10 auction houses.
 
Last edited:

MG Maniac

War Hero
A while ago Mrs MG got given the WWI medals of her great uncle (as she is the last surviving relative) who was killed on day one at Passchendaele. They were still in the original packaging unmounted. Since then we have managed to find a picture of him and the plan is to mount them and put them in a display case with his picture alongside them. Intrinsic value?? probably about 2/6d but as a bit of family history ... priceless.
 
I

In_my_day

Guest
?...but these medals aren't all that cherished by families/descendents as it proved by the numbers that are being traded on the likes of eBay or at boot fairs/£10 auction houses.
Another sweeping statement, approx 1.25 million war dead since WW I and how many sets of medals sold? It does raise the interesting point as to when a personal memento becomes either an heirloom or bric a brac. Given the nature of modern British society I would suggest that many youngster feel no real connection beyond the second generation before them. I would suggest also that why should anybody that sells their medals be judged, are you aware of the personal circumstances of every one of them, obviously not and therefore who are you to suggest that as a group their motives are purely mercenary?

IMD
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
slim Learner driver was told she could pay with sex Diamond Lil's 14
baldricks_bullet I was told this would be right up your alley... The Quarterdeck 5
soleil FB: National Museum Of The Royal Navy - On This Day - Sir Thomas Sean Connery Was Born History 2
Stirlin Well that was a good plan...............not. Current Affairs 1
MoD_RSS UK scientists help NASA answers the questions, 'was there life on Mars?' MoD News 2
Waspie Was the skipper a BMW owner!!! Submariners 11
J Can I join the Navy if I was previously on Anti-Depressants? Joining the Royal Navy 51
MoD_RSS Social housing sector was in a good financial position at end of March 2020 but faces considerable challenges due to coronavirus MoD News 0
MoD_RSS AAIB Report: Guimbal Cabri G2, helicopter caught fire and was destroyed MoD News 0
soleil i News: "'You’re Only Ever 15 minutes Away From Launching A Missile': What It Was Like To Be A Cold War Submariner" Submariners 27
MoD_RSS 2019 was record-breaking year for UK exports MoD News 0
MoD_RSS HM Coastguard volunteer saves man who was choking in Paris restaurant MoD News 0
B Dad was on schooner Zuoduchos Pigi in WW2 The Fleet 0
MoD_RSS Man overboard rescued off Dover 'was wearing lifejacket with good strobe light' MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Charity wound up after claims it was building bathrooms and installing IT equipment in Caribbean schools could not be proved MoD News 0
Alfacharlie Was the old rum ration days better? Diamond Lil's 4
slim Was Rum Ration a Better forum in the Olden Days Diamond Lil's 14
MoD_RSS Record amount of heroin seized in the UK that was bound for Antwerp MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Commission inquiry finds charity was not carrying out any charitable or other activities MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Speech: Notre Dame was a tragedy, but in too many parts of the world it's the Christian congregation that perishes: article by Jeremy Hunt MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Garden Bridge project was a ‘failure for charity’ that risks undermining public trust MoD News 0
soleil Mail: Royal Navy Keeps Old Offshore Patrol Ships It Was Due To Retire For Post-Brexit Coastline Protection The Fleet 1
MoD_RSS News story: Grave of a Seaforth Highlander rededicated 100 years after he was killed in world war 1 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Speech: "The Russian State was responsible for the attempted murder...and for threatening the lives of other British citizens in Salisbury." MoD News 0
skyvet Was it you? Diamond Lil's 7
C Newly Passed Pilots, how was your time? The Fleet Air Arm 5
vauxhall Another payout for an LE officer whose pension was upderpaid Finance & Pensions 0
MoD_RSS News story: World War 1 soldier who was killed in the Battle of the Somme finally laid to... MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: If the Somme was fought today, it would be a very different battle. MoD News 0
dapperdunn When I was on the Massive Diamond Lil's 6
Stirlin He was right. Sports and Adventure Training 0
slim Was the RN really better in the Old Farts Day? Diamond Lil's 102
jesse W.T.F. Was billy lewis? Diamond Lil's 0
BillyNoMates What I actually meant was. Blue Jokes 0
H If you thought the journey to HMS Raleigh was tough!!! Nearest & Dearest 117
BillyNoMates Before Wonder Woman there was.... Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 1
Green_and_Blue New evidence shows HMS Victory was afloat in 1933 ***(April Fool)*** Current Affairs 6
MG Maniac Chavs ... the reason Business Class was invented! Diamond Lil's 14
MrIndeed I was sent a email stating that i must be a 'sole British citizen' to join as a Submariner. Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 35
MG Maniac Breaking News! Just when you thought it was safe to come out the water! Current Affairs 1
C hello guys i was wondering....... Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 24
BillyNoMates They thought it was all over. Diamond Lil's 14
C What was a 'Hammer-driver'? My great uncle was one in Hood battalion. History 8
W If ever there was a natural candidate for becoming a PTI... Diamond Lil's 16
W Can any one tell me when the First British Submarine through the Suez canal was? Submariners 13
soleil Metro: If Only Your Mum Was Ten Years Younger: 10 Of The Worst Valentine’s Day Dates The Internet - Best and Worst 2
P Does anyone know why Ark Royal (Invincible Class) was longer than her sisters? The Fleet 2
exJenny How was it for you? Diamond Lil's 12
soleil Channel 4: "Armed Forces’ Involvement In Sectarian Rangers ‘Party’ Was A PR Disaster" Current Affairs 89
Dealwithit What was your first 4 months like? RFA 1
Similar threads


















































Top