Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Historical Punishment (RN/RM)

maninblack

Newbie
Book Reviewer
In looking at my Grandafther's history in the RMLI during WW1 there is a deduction of a good conduct badge in 1915 with the reason listed agaist it as ' "C" 10 Days '

Is this "Confined" for a minor transgression or is it more significant?

cheers from an Arrser.
 

tiddlyoggy

War Hero
Book Reviewer
If the "c" is listed as the reason, then surely it categorises the offence and has nothing to do with the punishment? Where's SGtP when you need him? You can never find a copper when you want one.
 

Guzzler

War Hero
Not really.

I take it that it's the Service Certificate we're talking about here.

The details on said document are what would now be considered vague to say the least.

Offences have a consequential effect so, for instance, 'Cells' or 'Confined' or whatever it means may, in those days, have meant deprivation of a badge - therefore 'C' would be a valid 'reason'.
 
The ten days cells was usually done onboard and the Good conduct badge
is taken as part of the punishment The yearly assessment of conduct is also graded as good instead of VG [very good]

There is usually a remarks column on the old type doc's that note
why the guy got cells !!
Most likely drunk on board or missing the ship/returning onboard late.


G .
 
maninblack said:
In looking at my Grandafther's history in the RMLI during WW1 there is a deduction of a good conduct badge in 1915 with the reason listed agaist it as ' "C" 10 Days '

Is this "Confined" for a minor transgression or is it more significant?

cheers from an Arrser.

Hi M-i-B,

:idea: Have you thought about inquiring of the staff at here?:

http://www.royalmarinesmuseum.co.uk/index2.html

Most military Museum are experts at handling this type of fast ball,



Best of luck - I was 'marines, too...........

.........'kin Submarines, though :twisted:

Bob
 

stirling2

Banned
My SC has a 'D' for detention for the 28 I was 'awarded' in DQ's .
To confuse the matter, under Time Forfeited there are abbreviations thus

P - D - C - C.P. - A - F.P., - W.T., - Pay F., - U.L.

My yearly assessment dropped to 'Fair' also losing my first badge.
 

maninblack

Newbie
Book Reviewer
Cheers, chaps. I may pop down to the RM Museum next week, it is only 1 mile down the road from me.

Continuing this theme does anyone know what "HB Ledger" was in respect of Eastney?
 

sweetpea

War Hero
Maninblack,

Are you reading the information written in your Grandfathers service record correctly? :wink:

Are you sure that your Grandfather forfeited his Good Conduct Badge? Or did he actually forfeit 10 days service towards his Good Conduct Badge due to a Conduct issue?

Had he been confined it would have been listed as CB = confined to barracks, CP = confined to port, (these are the abbreviations used during WW1).
Had he been placed under arrest/in the cells it would state Cells in his service record.

As for HB Ledger, Eastney, it crossed my mind that it could be relating to the Howitzer Brigade which was at Eastney, although they were RMA :? so I now have my doubts.

In general: The Service Ledgers are about 3ft x 4ft, and they contain the service records for those who served on ships. A ledger was used because it was not practical to use a lot of paper onboard ship. The Ledger was kept at the servicemans Depot and would have been update constantly. Your Grandfather will be listed by his service number in the Ledger. I have no idea what the HB relates to, but I think somewhere written in your Grandfathers service record there will be a clue.

SP.
 

maninblack

Newbie
Book Reviewer
sweetpea said:
Maninblack,

Are you reading the information written in your Grandfathers service record correctly? :wink:

Are you sure that your Grandfather forfeited his Good Conduct Badge? Or did he actually forfeit 10 days service towards his Good Conduct Badge due to a Conduct issue?

Had he been confined it would have been listed as CB = confined to barracks, CP = confined to port, (these are the abbreviations used during WW1).
Had he been placed under arrest/in the cells it would state Cells in his service record.

As for HB Ledger, Eastney, it crossed my mind that it could be relating to the Howitzer Brigade which was at Eastney, although they were RMA :? so I now have my doubts.

In general: The Service Ledgers are about 3ft x 4ft, and they contain the service records for those who served on ships. A ledger was used because it was not practical to use a lot of paper onboard ship. The Ledger was kept at the servicemans Depot and would have been update constantly. Your Grandfather will be listed by his service number in the Ledger. I have no idea what the HB relates to, but I think somewhere written in your Grandfathers service record there will be a clue.
SP.

Howitzer Brigade could make sense, he went from Eastney to the Royal Garrison Artillery. I was told that a fair proportion of RMLI served as gunners and that a lot of RMA served as infantry. Amongst other sailings he did serrve as a deck gunner on a submarine and served also as gun crew on HMS Q1.
 

maninblack

Newbie
Book Reviewer
janner said:
maninblack said:
sweetpea said:
Maninblack,

Amongst other sailings he did serrve as a deck gunner on a submarine

SP.

Do you have any more details on this part of your post?

Absolutely no information whatsoever. The detachment does not show on his records but he ended up being treated for chlorine poisoning due to salt water on the batteries after being depth charged.
 

maninblack

Newbie
Book Reviewer
Right, I have an answer for HB Ledger at Eastney.

Home Base Ledger; the list of men who are posted for UK deployment only. I will find out more about this in a week or so when I meet the archivist at Eastney.
 

Bart150

Newbie
My grandfather in the RMA in 1891 was guilty of 'laughing in the ranks whilst another man was being spoken to'; punishment 3 days confined to barracks.

A cousin of mine served in the RN in the 1950s. He tells me that discipline was stricter for the marines than for the sailors. Thus a minor offence might lead to just a telling off in the Navy but in the Marines there would be a formal charge and punishment that would be in the man's record for ever more.
Any opinions on that?
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
MoD_RSS New indemnity scheme for historical clinical negligence claims in general practice introduced MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Going the extra historical mile MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Public consultation on new laws launches to protect armed forces from historical allegations MoD News 0
linoleum Solo RN Historical Research - Help Sought The Quarterdeck 3
O Royal Marine Police records and other historical info History 3
G RAF Towed Target 'Rushton' needs a new home, historical interest.. History 13
S Another boring historical uniform question? History 18
Ageing_Gracefully Pot Luck - Historical Novels Competitions 16
dogsnaffle An Historical First... RMR 4
soleil RFA Historical Society: Website RFA 2
C Historical Deployments Site Issues 2
slim Apologising for historical events. Diamond Lil's 12
MoD_RSS Speech: Beyond prison, redefining punishment: David Gauke speech MoD News 0
Rachelthree Punishment for thieves? The Gash Barge 58
Ninja_Stoker Unspent convictions - Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 0
stan_the_man Corporal Punishment in Schools 1970 style Diamond Lil's 26
stan_the_man Best days No9 punishment you ever had Diamond Lil's 8
Catballou Cruel & Unusual punishment required Diamond Lil's 36
J Capital Punishment Type Diamond Lil's 0
F Capital punishment - would you pull the lever or.... Diamond Lil's 31
B punishment;in the rattle The Gash Barge 3
H A new perspective of punishment Diamond Lil's 30
whitemouse Punishment- US soldier is jailed for 100 years The Quarterdeck 7
Top