Guardian: "Women To Serve On RN Submarines From 2013"

#64
There's one question that looks not to have been asked.

Due to the crew needing to rely and depend on each other, is it not unreasonable to expect females to do exactly the same fitness test as their male counterparts?

Ie. An 18 year old female is expected to do 9:10 on the MSFT as is an 18 year old male.
 
#65
There's one question that looks not to have been asked.

Due to the crew needing to rely and depend on each other, is it not unreasonable to expect females to do exactly the same fitness test as their male counterparts?

Ie. An 18 year old female is expected to do 9:10 on the MSFT as is an 18 year old male.
We've been around this buoy many many times: the RNFT is a relative test of fitness, based on your VO2Max, an internationally accepted standard of fitness based around oxygen efficiency for a given age and gender [1]. The RN does not use an absolute test of fitness (like the Advanced CFTs required by the Infantry), nor does it test maximum repeatable strength.

[1] - VO2 max - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 
#67
It's not engaging outrage, I'm actually genuinely curious if it was taken into account seeing as they go on patrol for long periods and have to go it alone.

Edited to add: Mind you, I'm in a branch notorious for being slack on fitness. Maybe looking at loggies getting fit first might be a better idea.
 
Last edited:

witsend

MIA
Book Reviewer
#68
There's one question that looks not to have been asked.

Due to the crew needing to rely and depend on each other, is it not unreasonable to expect females to do exactly the same fitness test as their male counterparts?

Ie. An 18 year old female is expected to do 9:10 on the MSFT as is an 18 year old male.
It's not engaging outrage, I'm actually genuinely curious if it was taken into account seeing as they go on patrol for long periods and have to go it alone.

Edited to add: Mind you, I'm in a branch notorious for being slack on fitness. Maybe looking at loggies getting fit first might be a better idea.
Good to see your living up to your name here Scribes.
 

Similar threads


Top