Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Guardian: "Flaws In Nuclear Submarine Reactors Could Be Fatal, Secret Report Warns"

Subsunk

Lantern Swinger
Book Reviewer
I love it when a newspaper instantly goes from total disinterest in the RN in general to sudden subject matter expertise in one niche area. Agree with Witsend, there are a lot of weasel words and conditionals going on here. Still, it makes for a good fear-mongering dit that hinges for best effect on readers not being well-informed on the detail. And maybe that's the point.
 

T-H

Badgeman
So, to summarise: nuclear reactors are dangerous if they break, and submarines that fail to surface could kill the whole crew.
 

Subsunk

Lantern Swinger
Book Reviewer
In The Observer this Sunday, they will have a special investigation which will reveal that ducks float on water.
 
I started reading this report with interest as I have a lot of respect for Andy MacFarlane. As soon as I read comments by John Large and John Ainslie I gave up as these two would never have anything positive to say about "atom-death subs".
 

Joe_Crow

War Hero
.... As soon as I read comments by John Large and John Ainslie I gave up as these two would never have anything positive to say about "atom-death subs".

John Large is a tool who knows very little about nuclear engineering, but says the kind of things that journalists love to print, which is why they use him.
 
John Large

From the above link:

"John Large is a nationally and internationally recognised professional, consulting engineer who, not infrequently, contributes comment and opinion on nuclear and technical matters to national and international media."

The man is indeed a grade A tool who will spout a load of half-informed garbage to anyone who asks (pays) him. Because he has some knowledge he is believed by lazy journalists who cannot be arrsed to look anywhere else.
 

Joe_Crow

War Hero
During the Tireless repair, Muzza (God rest his soul) had to take Large to one side in Gib, whilst they suspended the meeting, to explain to him how the pressuriser works. We expect young dabbers to have this level of understanding, and many of them have little in the way of formal educational qualifications, so what does this say about the validity of his views?
 
Well lads, it's good to learn of your confidence in me.

And about Tiresome's pressuriser as I recall the problem was not about my understanding of how the pressuriser worked but the fact that it didn't work!
 

Joe_Crow

War Hero
Well lads, it's good to learn of your confidence in me.

And about Tiresome's pressuriser as I recall the problem was not about my understanding of how the pressuriser worked but the fact that it didn't work!

'Confidence' is an apt word. In this instance, it should be used in conjunction with the word 'trickster'.

If Tireless's pressuriser didn't work, it would have been breaking the law. Boyle's law.
 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator
Well lads, it's good to learn of your confidence in me.

And about Tiresome's pressuriser as I recall the problem was not about my understanding of how the pressuriser worked but the fact that it didn't work!

The pressuriser worked fine, that wasn't the problem but you've proved a point made in the previous posts!!
 
Since you're all upset about the pressuriser, it seems to me that you need a shot of something to lower your blood pressure - tune into C4 News tonight, that might just do the job!
 

Joe_Crow

War Hero
Lighten up Joe, you sound like a Grumpy Old Man!
I can't see how you have arrived at that conclusion, but reaching logical conclusions based on a sound assessment of the facts doesn't seem to be your thing.

Now I understand why the Admiralty wanted to repair the Tireless in Gibraltar.
What, apart from the fact that it was there? They would have much rather carried out any repair in Devonport, but were caught between a rock and a hard place.
 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator
Since you're all upset about the pressuriser

Don't see how we're all "upset". You were the one who got it wrong and it seems your not happy about being corrected. I can see now why your articles are badly written, assuming you are John Large of course and not Monty or BR on a wind up.
 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator
Joe & Wrecker - I see that your American buddies at Bubbleheads have expressed their full confidence in the Royal Navy kit - The Stupid Shall Be Punished: Brit Reactor Design Flaws?

Try reading it yourself, it's a blog with a link to the Guardian story. If your read the comments beneath they (apart from the first one) treat the story with the contempt it deserves.

Hardly scientific proof to back your pressuriser comment is it.
 

Joe_Crow

War Hero
This is what they say...


They're saying stuff like
anonymous said:
Before you start with the flag waving and Brit bashing, maybe consider the possibility that the flaws came from parts of the design they lifted from us.

Blah said:
You do realize that this is The Guardian you're quoting, right, Joel...? Pretty tin-foil hat stuff....

....The report is heavily redacted, but the net-net is that THERE IS NOTHING in this report that goes beyond boiler plate LOCA (loss of cooling accident) yadda-yadda that accompanies any PWR design.

which kind of makes a point, but not the one you appear to be insinuating.

By the way, the first comment says
If they design and build reactors like they did their cars then watch out.
How ironic then that Rolls Royce cars are so highly regarded.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
soleil Guardian: "We're Learning From Astute Submarine Flaws, Admiral Promises" Submariners 1
MoD_RSS National Data Guardian launches public consultation about the Caldicott Principles and Caldicott Guardians MoD News 0
soleil Guardian: "Man Accidentally Ejects Himself From Fighter Jet During Surprise Flight" The Fleet Air Arm 4
soleil Guardian: "Huge UK Naval Figureheads Rescued From Obscurity To Go On Display" History 14
MoD_RSS Nick Goodwin appointed as Public Guardian MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Response to Guardian story about language learning in schools MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Dame Fiona Caldicott appointed as the first statutory National Data Guardian for Health and Social Care MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Alan Eccles to retire as Public Guardian MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Alan Eccles to retire as Public Guardian MoD News 0
soleil Guardian: " MoD Faces £21bn Budget Shortfall, Warns Spending Watchdog" Current Affairs 2
MoD_RSS News story: Defence Secretary announces £80m Guardian to protect the skies MoD News 0
P Guardian article on the sinking of HMS Sheffield - for what it's worth History 2
D Up the creek..The Guardian on the RNR Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 17
Good CO Women in Leadership - RN Lt (Guardian) The Quarterdeck 0
soleil Guardian: "Territorial Army Captain Resigns Over Afghanistan Book" MoD News 1
soleil Guardian: "Paint Detectives Uncover True Colours Of Nelson's Victorious Flagship" History 0
soleil Guardian: "Britain's Armed Forces: The Future Of War" Current Affairs 10
soleil Guardian: "Multicultural Britain Rejecting Foreign Conflict, MoD Admits" Current Affairs 80
soleil Guardian: "'Minister for Portsmouth' Role Created To Help City" Bases / Shore Est 11
soleil Guardian: "Ministry Of Defence Funding Research Into Online Habits" MoD News 0
soleil Guardian: Philip Hammond - "In Defence Of Drones" Current Affairs 13
soleil Guardian: "Armed Forces Make Over 300 Visits To UK Universities In Two Years" Current Affairs 15
sgtpepperband The Guardian: "Will Chimps Soon Have Human Rights?" Current Affairs 3
soleil "New Anti Piracy 'Guardian' Barrier Beats Royal Marines" The Corps 5
soleil Guardian: "Quay Concerns Delay Launch Of Navy Submarine" Submariners 0
soleil Guardian: "Giant First World War Gun On The Move Across Southern England This Week" History 2
trelawney126 Blow me, it's in the Guardian The Gash Barge 0
soleil Cornish Guardian: "Royal Navy To Re-Affirm Ship's Links With Padstow" The Fleet 3
soleil Guardian: "Royal Navy Sends Warship To Libya To Showcase Defence Equipment" Current Affairs 3
soleil Guardian: "Royal Navy Sea Kings Search-And-Rescue In Action - Video" The Fleet Air Arm 1
soleil Guardian: "Sea Survival And Bird Routes: The Varied Life Of A Naval Press Officer" Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 0
soleil Guardian: "Political Support For Afghan Campaign Has 'Departed Stage Left'" Current Affairs 11
soleil "Guardian: "MoD: Trident Submarines Cannot Be Moved From Scotland To Plymouth" Submariners 30
soleil Cornish Guardian: "Top Sport Award For 'Inspiration' Dale" Sports and Adventure Training 0
soleil Guardian: "Royal Navy Test Flies New Drone" The Fleet 24
soleil News Guardian: "Air Cadets Swap Skies For The Sea" Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 0
soleil Guardian: "Vince Cable Doubts Viability Of £150m BAE Shipbuilding Project" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil Guardian: "Army Comes Top For Public Sector Gender Equality" Current Affairs 3
soleil Cornish Guardian: "New Commandant Returns To His Roots" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil Guardian: "How Do I Buy-to-let While Serving In The Royal Navy? Finance & Pensions 15
soleil Guardian: "A Minority Report From The British Armed Services" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil Guardian: "Commander: The Life And Exploits Of Britain's Greatest Frigate Commander" History 1
soleil Guardian: "Cuts Force Royal Navy To Drop Somalia Piracy Patrol" The Fleet 8
soleil Exercise Olympic Guardian Current Affairs 0
soleil Cornish Guardian: "Village Cordoned Off As Hand Grenade Found In Barn Roof" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil Guardian: "Royal Navy Crew Help Douse Antarctic Research Station Fire" The Fleet 1
soleil Guardian: Sea Ceptor: "MoD Signs £500m Missile Defence Deal" The Fleet 6
soleil Guardian: "Big Job Losses Loom At Devonport Naval Base In Latest MoD Cuts" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil Guardian: "US Diving Crew Finds Wreck Of British Submarine Used In Second World War" Submariners 0
soleil Guardian: "Thatcher Warned Of Defence Cuts Dangers Before Falklands War" History 0
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

Top