Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Graduate joining as a rating?

tangerine

Newbie
I might be jumping the gun a bit as I haven't graduated yet, I have queries about the suitability of my medical history and I know I have a bit of work to do on my fitness but...

I'm currently in uni and I'm considering joining the Navy after I graduate. I know I want to apply to serve on submarines and having looked at the details of the available roles on the RN website and this forum I'm considering CIS (SM).

My initial thought was that being a graduate with a 4 year integrated Bachelor's and Master's degree, I would be expected to become an officer but (as my degree is not in Engineering) my choice would be between Warfare Officer and Logistics Officer. From reading the forum it seems that if I went with Logistics I wouldn't actually spend all that much time on boats or even at sea at all, which for me would defeat the object of signing up in the first place.

Comparing the official (and unofficial) job descriptions for Warfare Officer with those for CIS, the former inspires a reaction of 'oh, well, I guess I could do that', while I am genuinely excited by the prospect of the latter job.

I'm also not sure if I have a personality suited to becoming an officer (although I suppose the tests and training I'd go through to get there would clear up the issue one way or another), but really I'm considering the rating route because it's genuinely the Navy job I'd most like to do.

Is this a common situation people find themselves in? Will the recruitment people try to convince me to go for officer? Should I go for CIS (SM) or pick an officer role? Will my (over)qualification make any kind of difference once I'm actually on the job as a rating - either positive or negative?

Any other thoughts or advice on the topic welcome.
 
I've had plenty of ratings with degrees working for me. They were the usual spread of good, bad and indifferent. Equally, I've had more than a few non-grad officers working for me (and I've worked for); the same applies.

Do what you want, it'll be what you make of it!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Ninja_Stoker

War Hero
Moderator
Fully concur with Alf.

A degree doesn't automatically mean "officer" or higher earnings. There's a common misconception in the lower deck that graduates must always be commissioned officers and you'll often hear "What were the AFCO thinking?" when a well-spoken , educated and intelligent individual joins as a rating.

In any event, if they have what it takes, anyone joining up to around age 30 as a rating can become an Officer with just five GCSEs at a later stage.

A good example is Royal Marines - every recruit troop has a couple or more graduates, one troop of 55 had 17! Around 40% of Royal Marines Other Ranks join educationally qualified for officer.

The world, as they say, is your lobster.
 

jrwlynch

Lantern Swinger
Comparing the official (and unofficial) job descriptions for Warfare Officer with those for CIS, the former inspires a reaction of 'oh, well, I guess I could do that', while I am genuinely excited by the prospect of the latter job.

I'm also not sure if I have a personality suited to becoming an officer (although I suppose the tests and training I'd go through to get there would clear up the issue one way or another), but really I'm considering the rating route because it's genuinely the Navy job I'd most like to do.

Is this a common situation people find themselves in? Will the recruitment people try to convince me to go for officer? Should I go for CIS (SM) or pick an officer role? Will my (over)qualification make any kind of difference once I'm actually on the job as a rating - either positive or negative?

Any other thoughts or advice on the topic welcome.

Not regular RN, but work with them a fair bit...

I've known junior rates with postgraduate degrees and doctorates, I've known officers who gratefully bailed out of education at eighteen to escape to BRNC. (Admittedly, the AB who walked me through - physically and functionally - the water treatment plant aboard a destroyer during my Fleet Time, demonstrating an articulate and fully functional grasp of the necessary chemistry, biology and legislation, probably didn't stay an AB very long - in terms of competence, definitely a "promote!" Didn't ask about education, didn't need to, he was on top of his job with no problems at all)

Once you're in and working, nobody much cares about paper qualifications (wish they did, says Lt Jrwlynch RNR, BEng(Hons) MSc MA - will all that academic paper get me promoted faster? It doesn't even get me any free socks!) - whether you're good at your job and a useful member of the team matters much more.

Keep asking, learning and looking around, but from what you've said here it sounds like CIS(SM) is what you want to do, and a submarine is not a place you want to be stuck for months doing a job you don't enjoy.

As Ninja_Stoker points out, it's not a "decide now and forever" issue - the opportunity's there to go officer later should you and the Navy agree it would suit you and there's a role that appeals. (I think 25-30% of the RN's officers started out as ratings - anyone got the number?)
 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator
I think it's 40% plus that started as ratings in the engineering branches, probably wrong knowing me but it's definitely higher than 30%.
 

tangerine

Newbie
Of course the degree could be in Origami o_O
It's actually in Biochemistry, not that it will matter at all after I graduate. I almost wish I hadn't signed up for the extra 4th year (thinking I'd remain deeply in love with the subject and the idea of a career in academia) now but there's no backing out at this point.
 

SONAR-BENDER

War Hero
//Thread drift//

I hated the idea of academia (OK, classrooms) so much, that, despite passing the entrance exams and being given an entry date, that I turned down being an Artificer when I found it meant 4ish years in 'school'. Joined as a Dabber, 'cos I liked the pictures they showed me!

23 years later I left as.......... a Chief Artificer (Mech really!)

//As you were//
 

Texast

Midshipman
I’m in a similar position to you, im a post grad hoping to join as a rating. Personally the reasons why I want to join the navy are not academic and when you’ve finished your service your degree will still be there. Just don’t let being a graduate become your identity or feel like you have to be pigeon holed into something you don’t want to do just because it’s percieved as better
 

SONAR-BENDER

War Hero
Genuine question - not aimed at the OP, but in general.

Why spend 3 or 4 years doing a degree you hate, are not going to use and incurring possibly £50k of student loan and other accumulated debt, when 3 or 4 years ago you could have joined up and earned nearer £100k by now?

Puzzled.
 

tangerine

Newbie
Genuine question - not aimed at the OP, but in general.

Why spend 3 or 4 years doing a degree you hate, are not going to use and incurring possibly £50k of student loan and other accumulated debt, when 3 or 4 years ago you could have joined up and earned nearer £100k by now?

Puzzled.

In my case:

1) I went to a school that was designed to be a pipeline into "Good Universities" and then "Good Careers", so I was not presented with any options other than going to uni. It also connected my sense of self-worth to my academic achievements to the extent that even considering anything else was unthinkable.

2) I genuinely do enjoy studying my chosen field, and at the time I started the degree was convinced that I'd just hang out at the uni earning ever more degrees until someone handed me a professorship. Or something. My decision not to go into academia was based on the realisation that I did not like the nature of a career in research, not that I did not like biochemistry.
 

Texast

Midshipman
@SONAR-BENDER people’s interests change as they get older just like you see people have major career changes. I don’t want to work in the industry I studied currently but have no regrets going to uni.

Student debt only ever seems to get brought up by people who didn’t go to uni. It’s a very manageable debt and people pay more for phone contracts than monthly loan repayments.
 

Ninja_Stoker

War Hero
Moderator
Bottom line is Universities are a business, like any other. The education system generates revenue and this is fed by secondary schools where a university education is pretty much the expected norm rather than a place for those who excel and enjoy academics.

Forty years ago the UK paid 16 year olds not to go to school and sit on their arse doing nothing at home. Twenty years ago the UK paid them thirty quid a week to stay in sixth form. Ten years ago we started charging for a degree education. Nowadays, schools mislead students into believing they must stay in secondary education to age 18 and ideally pay for a degree education until age 21.

As stated above, whilst not knocking those who gain vocational degrees, required to do a job, there's a system that gives a 16 year old the opportunity to gain 5 years work experience, travel and seniority earning around £100-£120,000 and there's a system to remain in education until 21/22 gaining a degree and then starting on the same wage as the 16 year old did five years previously, accompanied with a £50k (average) debt.

My son, incidentally, opted for a degree and in his second year. Did he listen to me? Nah, I'm only a careers adviser ;)
 

tangerine

Newbie
@SONAR-BENDER
Student debt only ever seems to get brought up by people who didn’t go to uni. It’s a very manageable debt and people pay more for phone contracts than monthly loan repayments.

Yeah, student loans are really not that big a problem - the repayments are structured so that it acts exactly the same as a tax and I really have no objections to it.

In any case I'm not sure I would have been mature enough for the Navy at age 16 or even 18 - being at uni has taught me a lot about motivating and looking after myself when at school I could just swan about being a ******** and glide to top marks while my mum kept me fed and did my washing. Of course some people don't need to try out adulthood with the training wheels on before they do the real thing!

Uni also lets me spend my time studying a fascinating subject in depth and I am sure I would have regretted not doing it.
 
D

Deleted 64868

Guest
I want to do the opposite, funnily enough! Join at 18 without a degree. Need to convince the school and my parents that degrees aren't a neccessity...
 

Taztiff

War Hero
My lad did his A levels, went to Uni to study Music Technology which he really enjoyed in college.
After the first year he realised that 1, they didn't teach him anything he hadn't already learnt in college and 2, they weren't going to teach him anything he wanted to learn.
So he came home and said he wasn't going back after summer.
'Ok' says I, 'What you going to do?'
'Join the Navy' says he!. 18 months later (after doing all sorts of menial and charity jobs he joined up and hasn't looked back. Been in 3 1/2 years now.

I think he starts paying some student loan back soon............
 

Ninja_Stoker

War Hero
Moderator
I want to do the opposite, funnily enough! Join at 18 without a degree. Need to convince the school and my parents that degrees aren't a neccessity...
Here's something to consider - an accelerated apprentice can join with BTEC or acceptable STEM subject A Levels, aged 18 and earning £31,100 starting pay.

An engineering graduate, aged 21 can join as an engineering officer, earning just under £26,000 starting pay.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
B Joining the Navy as a graduate engineer- newbie alert Joining the Royal Navy 7
MoD_RSS Paraguayans graduate from Royal Military Academy Sandhurst MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Apply for part time and post graduate master's student finance MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Somali soldiers graduate from UK-led training course MoD News 0
MoD_RSS VOA launches its 2020 graduate scheme MoD News 0
09traej RFA Engineering Cadetship - Graduate RFA 13
MoD_RSS Somali National Army Personnel graduate from UK led training in Baidoa MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Glasgow employer launches Graduate Apprenticeship Programme MoD News 0
MoD_RSS First generation of Unlocked prison officers graduate as scheme expands to north MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Graduate earnings remain high MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Third-year engineering apprentices graduate to roles in Dstl MoD News 0
B RN Graduate Scheme - Past Medical OD Joining the Royal Navy 0
MoD_RSS News story: Dstl opens graduate recruitment scheme for 2017 MoD News 0
B Entry as a Graduate Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 116
W Non Graduate Entry Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 10
ForcesJobShop Employment Opportunity: Graduate RF Engineer The Afterlife - Resettlement and Jobs 0
V Graduate Career Change to RN - Advice Needed Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 20
S graduate rating Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
S Non Graduate Pay for 22Yr Old Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 25
Chalky Midshipman as a Graduate UY? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 18
M Uni graduate scheme etc Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 8
Kelborn Graduate entry vs non graduate officer entry Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 8
L An all graduate navy The Quarterdeck 40
P Joining during COVID-19 RFA 3
O Joining date Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 8
F Joining RNR/RMR - Potential Transfer Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 5
A Course joining instructions Bases / Shore Est 7
D Female joining Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 5
W Pre Joining Fitness Test Advice Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 4
I Officer joining requirements Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 9
chorzxx Pre-joining fitness test Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 2
R Trying to trump the age stakes. Joining at 38, possibilities? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 13
A Joining up with hay-fever. Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
A Joining with hay-fever. Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 4
Multiirishman Joining the Rfa RFA 18
N Joining as a Warfare Officer submarine v surface Joining the Royal Navy 4
7 Joining the RFA as a chef apprentice RFA 8
Y Issue about Joining (Asperger's) Joining the Royal Navy 1
H Joining as a marine engineer (submariner) Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
W Joining kit l Joining the Royal Navy 36
N Joining Test Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 0
M Thinking of joining RNR. Ex raf rigger Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 35
S Joining tip’s and info Joining the Royal Navy 74
TechnicPR Joining with Aspergers? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 6
F Joining as a Systems Engineer as an ETO on Cruise Ships RFA 4
A Am I banned from joining the navy? Joining the Royal Navy 39
O Buying Life Insurance before joining... Finance & Pensions 17
0 Joining the Navy as AET compared to RAF aircraft technician Joining the Royal Navy 26
L Joining as Officer but undecided, need helping choosing Joining the Royal Navy 25
E Considering joining the Royal Navy- looking for advice Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 16
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

New Posts

Top