Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Flying boats

Chaffers

Newbie
With the exception of a handful of airframes produced by the Japanese and Russians it doesn't appear than any serious work has gone into flying boats since the 1950s.

With the demise of our MPAs, SAR and no carrier borne AEW / tankers I wonder whether it is an idea that could eventually be revised.

Granted we have two big floating decks on the horizon but other than the possible exception of the V22 nothing that could provide tanking, COD or high altitude AEW. Never mind long endurance ASW or SAR.

Apparently those pesky Iranians have revised the idea and deployed a squadron of stealthy ( I'm guessing this means plywood) small flying boats.
 

Waspie

War Hero
If the MoD was to go down the flying boat road the R&D costs would be phenominal!!!

If there was one on the shelf you would have to balance its usage against cost and to be honest in a SAR role I dare say it wouldn't be economically viable!
 

Pontius

War Hero
With the exception of a handful of airframes produced by the Japanese and Russians it doesn't appear than any serious work has gone into flying boats since the 1950s.

And there are plenty of good reasons for that. If the practicality of flying boats was viable then you'd already have fleets of them on the waterways and seas. The best thing about them is the availability of REALLY long runways. That, of course, is if the runway is not too bumpy to take off or land :smile:
 
Not wishing to sound ignorant but what is the difference between a seaplane and a flying boat?


Sent from my iPhone using The Force
 

flymo

War Hero
Well just to muddy the waters, WIG craft are classed as boats even though they fly using the ... umm .... WIG effect
 

Chaffers

Newbie
As I understand it the main problem with flying boats was the amount of maintenance they required rather than the conditions they could operate in. Also the availability of long runways in many party of the world was rather sparse, particularly in the Pacific. Once the focus shifted towards nuclear deterrence and the aircraft carrier they were pretty much consigned to the history channel.

Looking at the SeaMaster though performance wise it was pretty much two Buccaneers bolted together so maybe the difference between carrier aircraft and flying boats wasn't as extreme as it appears, in the 1950s at least.

As we lack an indigenous airframe for the roles I mentioned above, and the candidates are rather expensive and lacking in performance there might be a niche for the flying boat yet.

More powerful engines, composites, modern hull design, STOL technology, hell even GRP and other corrosion resistant materials may well make such an airframe viable. Something with huge range, fast enough to tank modern fighters, lift a decent package of avionics and operate relatively cheaply.

Did the Russian Navy ever order A-40s? Despite being an 80s design they were mooting it as their main ASW platform..
 

Seaweed

War Hero
Book Reviewer
Why would anyone want them? The US experimented with all sorts of flying boats in the 50s and none of them proved a success, including the Tradewind which was going to come creaming in from nowhere and disgorge leathernecks on some likely beach. The flying boat heyday for us - the Empire routes - preceded the general availability of runways, and maintenance from a bouncy little boat must have been an absolute pig. One of lour 1940s/50s little failures was the 'Flying Boat Fighter' - adverts showed it creaming upwards from its island base, presumably to defend the island base that would not have been there except to base the flying boat fighter. The performance penalty of the hull did for it as much as anything but you can still see one in the Southampton aviation museum.

As for SAR, given the sea state actually causing some of the disasters from which people need rescuing, it would have to be abn extraordinary flying boat to cope with that role. The US used them to rescue downed flyers in the Pacific in WW2 but they had been downed by the Nips, not by weather.

Surface effect is something else but greatly weather dependent.

Anyway to cheer you up here's a rather grotty copy from a 1937 Illustrated London News showing somebody's idea of a vast flying boat base in Langstone Harbour - that didn't happen.

ILN Langstone Hbr.jpg

And here's a nice big flying white elephant for you to take to bed instead of a teddy:

 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator
How about the Russian Surface Effect Craft, it'd get to the incident fast enough (if the sea was flat)
soviet-lun-class-ekranoplan-ground-effect-vehicle.jpg
imagesCA5LMMIM.jpg
wings-ground-effect-craft.jpg
 

FAAFLYNAVY

Lantern Swinger
Although not military, there was a plan several years ago to turn the "wash" into a large lake & develop seaplanes for long haul to Canada & America so as to avoid the main airports. Every so often it comes back up in the local press, so it could still come to fruition in the long term intercontinental aviation planning.
 
Last edited:

Chaffers

Newbie
Why would anyone want them?

Quite, not out of nostalgia that's for sure...

We don't lack long runways though increasingly wherever you go they are either in demand or fully utilized. Flying boats tended to carry more weight simply because their runways were practically unlimited.

If we took the A-40 as an example.

SAR, effecting a landing to rescue the victims is an option, one which the Japanese have used sporadically. Most likely though would be as a search platform whence Bristow's provide the chopper.

Why else would you want them? Well the Ruskies seem relatively keen on the idea ( though this hasn't translated to serious orders yet) probably due to the ability to land on the water and use a dipping sonar. I have no idea how an SSK would get around this. Also Beriev submitted the A-40 for the MPA2000 competition. The Navy, apparently, loved the idea. The RAF, not so much.

If you could think of another way to get a 30,000 ft 2000nm range AEW platform which could operate, most of the time, in support of our carriers and rather thirsty proposed F35Bs. As a tanker it could dispense 10 tonnes, more than twice what the only likely competitor ( the V-22 ) which is also rather limited conditions wise and hugely expensive.

As for as an MPA we still have the avionics fit from the MRA4, both aircraft are similar sizes. The only realistic alternative, purely as an MPA, would be the P-8, which is also rather pricey.

COfD might be a bit hair raising, but possible.

Last but not least a new design airframe could fulfill all of the roles listed above possibly rather well, rather than expensive and sub optimal solutions like the V-22.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
MoD_RSS UK flying displays - regulation and assurance MoD News 0
soleil Somerset Live: Royal Navy 'Legend' Still Flying After 50 Years And 9,200 Hours In The Air The Fleet Air Arm 2
P ‘Creamy’ Flying Instructors The Fleet Air Arm 15
MoD_RSS High-flying young women and girls celebrated at Downing Street reception MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Airspace modernisation to make flying greener and more reliable as football fans travel to Madrid on busiest-ever day for flights MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Aviation minister meets airlines and allergy sufferers to improve flying for those with nut allergies MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: New aviation passenger charter to improve flying experience MoD News 0
onions Wasp still flying? The Fleet Air Arm 2
MoD_RSS Speech: Flying through Fire and Ice MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: £260m deal signed to keep RAF giants flying MoD News 0
TechFin When are Flying Aptitude Tests usually completed? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
TechFin When are Flying Aptitude Tests Usually Completed? The Fleet Air Arm 4
W Maths - Flying Aptitude Test Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 4
MoD_RSS News story: Drones – are you flying yours safely? (and legally?) MoD News 0
A What is the Flying Aptitude Test? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 9
Simon - Quest Magazine Want to keep flying? Here’s how … The Afterlife - Resettlement and Jobs 0
MoD_RSS News story: New Flying Display Directors (FDDs) Competence Framework MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: New helicopter deal boosts UK's investment in military flying training to £2.8... MoD News 0
Trainer Army Navy Tickets: FLYING FOX Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 12
MoD_RSS News story: £1.1 billion investment by MOD in future military flying training MoD News 1
G The flying Lemon: more F35 / C&T bollocks The Gash Barge 13
MoD_RSS News story: Publication of Regulatory Notice (RN) regarding display flying MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Boeing flying high after signing the Armed Forces Covenant MoD News 0
joeG need help with preparing for flying aptitude test for AIRCREWMAN position The Fleet Air Arm 2
BE19Pilot Flying Naked Diamond Lil's 14
S HMS FORWARD AND FLYING FOX Royal Guard at dedication of Naval Memorial Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 2
soleil HMS Flying Fox - Channel 5 - Monday, April 14th 2014 - Gadget Show - 19:00 Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 5
R Been told i can attest at Flying fox what to wear? Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 5
DemobJob Aircrew Flying Instructor - Wiltshire The Afterlife - Resettlement and Jobs 0
A New WW1 ebook: Manfred von Richthofen:WW1 German Flying Ace. The Book Club 0
A New ebook: The Red Baron:WW1 German Flying Ace. 100th WW1 Anniversary Edition. The Book Club 10
scouse Wessy flying again The Fleet Air Arm 0
F I have my flying aptitudes, but can you please help? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 12
soleil BZ To LS Andy Westlake, HMS Flying Fox - Best Reservist Nomination, The Millies 2013 Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 4
soleil Mail: "Will Churchill's Seaplane Soar Again? Plans To Rebuild 100-yr-old Flying Boat" The Fleet Air Arm 0
soleil BBC Inside Out South West: "From Red Squirrel To Flying Squirrel!" The Fleet Air Arm 0
J Royal Navy Flying Aptitude Tests....... The Fleet Air Arm 11
soleil Somerset County Gazette: "The High Risks Of Low Flying At RNAS Yeovilton" The Fleet Air Arm 1
W the flying doughnut History 0
soleil This Is The West Country: "Flying Visit Gives Pupils A Taste Of Life In The Navy" The Fleet Air Arm 1
soleil Pompey News: "Simulator Puts Pilots Into The Flying Seat For Fighter Jet Training" The Fleet Air Arm 0
SONAR-BENDER Flying porkers pay more! Diamond Lil's 45
TotalAlien Flying aptitude test validity Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 2
Waspie Mad flying display. The Fleet Air Arm 8
scouse BBC2 - Thurs Feb 28th 2013 - "The Sea King - Britain's Flying Past" The Fleet Air Arm 39
soleil Bolton News: "Flying Ace’s Beer Passes Taste Test!" The Fleet Air Arm 3
soleil Herald: "Flying A Flag For The Naval Base" Bases / Shore Est 0
S HMS Flying Fox Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 3
Olly013 Flying Aptitude Tests (FATs) - My experience and advice Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 27
MoD_RSS Flying Tigers hunt submarines off Norway Current Affairs 2
Similar threads


















































Top