Falklands can be defended with pre-1914 rifles, said MoD

LancashireHussar

Lantern Swinger
I'd never heard this one before. Very interesting reading.


http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2005/12/29/nnat429.xml

Falklands can be defended with pre-1914 rifles, said MoD
(Filed: 29/12/2005)

A highly classified file released today reveals the secret weapon relied upon by the Government in 1975 to defend the Falkland Islands from an Argentine invasion - the pre-1914 Lee Enfield rifle.



A top secret assessment by British military planners carried out seven years before the invasion caused dismay in Whitehall by concluding that the islands could properly be defended only by the deployment of a full brigade.

But ministers baulked at the proposal on the grounds of its cost and the risk that the impending arrival of an effective garrison might provoke the Argentines into staging a pre-emptive invasion.

Both the Ministry of Defence, which was wedded to Nato operations in Europe and the North Atlantic, and the Foreign Office, which was anxious to seek an accommodation with Buenos Aires, preferred to ignore the Argentine threat.

Instead, they decided to continue to rely on a "tripwire" force, consisting of a platoon of Royal Marines and the grandly-named Falkland Islands Defence Force.

The latter was 100 civilian men scattered across an area the size of Wales, with only about 30 in Port Stanley, the obvious target for an invasion.

A Foreign Office file from May 1975 shows how the department fought with the MoD over the cost of equipping the defence force with modern self-loading rifles, as used by the British Armed Forces. Despite the tiny cost, the MoD refused to pay. That left the sheep farmers with a collection of antiques, including "pre-1914 303 rifles", one "ancient Vickers machine-gun" and more 303s and Bren guns from the Second World War.

The military planners concluded that should an invasion take place, the recovery of the islands would be a "major operation", although "far from impossible".

The Foreign Office was far less sure, arguing: "Defence against a full-scale Argentine invasion is not considered a realistic course of action and recovery of the islands after a successful invasion would be so costly and risky as to be impracticable.

"In the last resort the solution to the Falkland Islands dispute must be political rather than military."
 
The talk of the old 303 rifles and that era well the Navy was still shooting the ex WW2 Lee Enfield till about 1968 .

They didn't get the SLR 7.62 untill they dismembered the old TA and got their weapons!!

The days of cut the defence costs -----the Falklands war Task force was a real eye opener -------------I think they had already flogged the Hermes to India and renaged on the deal so they could keep it for the Harriers.
 
Greenie, it was Invincible and the Australians.

The idea that emerged from the Nott Review, IIRC, was that the RN should have two CVS, rather than the three that were originally planned for. The Australians were retiring HMAS Melbourne (which had developed some problem that made it impossible to conduct ops safely with the RAN's A-4s), and were on the look out for a carrier - which meant either Invincible or Invincible, since there was nothing else practiable out there for them to buy.

Invincible was to go at about the time that Illustrious entered service, and Hermes would stay on until Ark Royal was commissioned, whereupon it would then be paid off. Again, relying on hazy memory here, but I seem to think that the Indians were expected to be willing buyers, since they wanted a second carrier capable of operating the SHAR.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
soleil The Times: "Captain Mike Booth, 70: Helicopter Pilot In The Falklands, Naval Attaché And Cabinetmaker" The Fleet Air Arm 3
soleil BBC: "Falklands Veteran 'Forced Out Over Sexuality' Will Get Medal Back" History 31
soleil BBC News: "German WWI Wreck Scharnhorst Discovered Off Falklands" History 1
MoD_RSS Winners of the Falklands Regional Student Competition 2019/2020 announced MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Concurso para estudiantes universitarios para viajar a Falklands MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: UK and Argentina agree new flight linking the Falklands and South America MoD News 0
soleil Portsmouth News: "Falklands Fighter Ace Calls For Cost Controls Over UK’s £9.2bn F-35 Project" The Fleet Air Arm 45
SONAR-BENDER Falklands medal found RFA 14
MoD_RSS News story: Improvements to Mare Harbour jetty in Falklands complete MoD News 0
BRP Writing a novel about the Falklands War... History 30
J HMS Active reunion 35th Anniversary of Falklands homecoming Social & Reunions 4
Naval_Gazer 'Falklands 35' Charity Dinner Charity 8
Stirlin Falklands veterans mark 35th anniversary in Gosport The Quarterdeck 17
F RFA ships Falklands War research History 0
HistoryBoy AB David McCann, HMS Glamorgan died August 1982 (Post Falklands) History 6
janner The Falklands War. History 139
MoD_RSS News story: Defence Secretary sees brighter future on Falklands visit MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: British Forces go to assistance of stricken cruise liner in the Falklands MoD News 1
Wightsparker Falklands rescue Current Affairs 1
Stirlin Abuse of Falklands Argentine conscripts. The Quarterdeck 8
Naval_Gazer 11th MCM Sqn (Falklands 1982) Reunion in Hull 13-14 Jun 2015 Social & Reunions 0
Tomahawk Apparently the sinking of the General Belgrano caused the Falklands War Current Affairs 11
soleil NW Evening Mail: Falklands Veteran Sub Leaves Barrow And Embarks On Her Final Voyage Submariners 3
Ageing_Gracefully Book Competition FALKLANDS COMMANDO by Hugh McManners Competitions 17
soleil USMC Website: "EWS Students Gain Insight From Falklands War Commanders" History 0
soleil Record: "Video: Falklands Veteran David Cruickshanks Makes Return To Battle Scene" History 8
Pandaplodder Letchworth war veteran dies in Falklands after returning for Rememberance Day The Corps 0
R HMS Alacrity's "mine" run in the Falklands History 19
R Hermes and which ship and date & Glamorgan in Falklands The Fleet 22
soleil Times: "Royal Navy Ship Torpedoed Whales In Falklands" History 39
H The Falklands War Then & Now The Book Club 0
J Some questions on Falklands 1982 History 18
soleil Augusta-Margaret River Mail: "Veteran’s Memories Of The Falklands" History 1
soleil Bermuda Sun: "Action In Falklands Changed My Life’" History 4
BARNEYRNSM selling a Falklands Conflict medal. Charity 12
Handler Falklands referendum Current Affairs 22
Stirling Falklands.....how close to defeat. Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 45
F Argentina claims Falklands will be under their control in 20 years time Current Affairs 47
trelawney126 SirRex Hunt dies at 86 yrs old Falklands governor Current Affairs 0
Blackrat Memoirs of The Falklands Diamond Lil's 41
T PR:BF2 Falklands v0.1 Addon Gaming 0
G HMS Invincible (Falklands 82) Ships Reunion 2013 Social & Reunions 0
F Falklands style conflict looming in S.E. Asia Current Affairs 16
TeddyT USN report on Falklands Conflict History 18
H Falklands Memorial Plantation - rededication 06/12/12 Current Affairs 0
S Save the last surviving warship from the Falklands Conflict Petitions 12
soleil Herald: Iconic Image By Plymouth Photographer Captured End Of The Falklands Conflict The Corps 3
soleil BBC: "Remembering The Falklands Sacrifice 30 Years On" History 1
soleil BFBS: "Falklands Memorial For SBS Sergeant" The Corps 4
soleil Western Daily Press: "Insight Into Falklands War Father's World At RNAS Yeovilton" The Fleet Air Arm 0
Similar threads


















































Top