Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Do RN Chaplains want to be armed? (Daily Mail)


War Hero


Army chaplains want right to carry weapons to protect themselves against the Taliban
by MATTHEW HICKLEY - More by this author »

Last updated at 20:28pm on 20th November 2007

British military chaplains in Afghanistan are urging an historic change in the rules to allow them to carry weapons when out on patrol alongside troops fighting the Taliban, because of the risk of capture.

For the first time in any theatre of conflict chaplains are no longer considered to be protected by the rules of war, because of the propaganda Taliban extremists would gain from showing "trophy" footage of a captive Christian priest.

By long tradition, clergy serving in Britain's armed forces have not carried weapons in war-zones, but now some Royal Navy Commando chaplains want to be allowed to carry a side-arm, stating that as a last resort they would rather take their own life than fall into the hands of the Taliban.

The issue has sparked an intense debate within the chaplain community, where some oppose the move on principle.

Under the Geneva Convention all military chaplains are 'non-combatants' and are granted certain protections if taken prisoner, but in Afghanistan such rules are irrelevant since the Taliban pay no heed to international law or the Convention.

UK forces in Afghanistan have already stopped observing one requirement of the Geneva Convention, as for the first time both chaplains and frontline medics have abandoned their traditional Red Cross arm bands when out in the field.

The assessment by commanders is that far from enjoying any protection, anyone wearing the Red Cross would be at greater risk from the enemy.

So far the firearms debate only involves Royal Navy Commando chaplains who minister to the Royal Marines, currently fighting and working to build security in southern Afghanistan.

Commando chaplains routinely visit forward operating bases to conduct services and offer pastoral support, and unlike most of their Army counterparts they also join troops on patrols in order to share and understand their experiences.

Uniquely among military clergy they have all completed the same training as their "flock" - in this case the gruelling 32-week Commando training course - enabling them to live and work on the frontline without being a burden to the men or their commanders.

Without Red Cross armbands they are now indistinguishable within a group of Marines, wearing identical uniform, body armour and helmets.

During training they are taught to handle and fire SA-80 assault rifles and pistols, because as trained first-aiders they are allowed to use a wounded Marine's own weapon to protect him on a battlefield.

But now some chaplains are pressing for the rules barring them from carrying their own personal weapon to be relaxed - specifically within Afghanistan, because of the nature of the enemy - giving them the discretion to take a sidearm on patrol.

There are about a dozen chaplains in Afghanistan.

The Revd Stuart Hallam, (Church of England) Royal Navy Chaplain to 40 Commando, currently serving in Afghanistan, is one of those in favour.

He told the Mail: "For the first time in any theatre of war we are seen as a legitimate target by the enemy.

"We are already effectively breaking the Geneva Convention by not wearing red arm bands. Maybe we're passed gentlemen's agreements, and have to re-think the way we go about our ministry in this kind of conflict.

"The Convention itself doesn't actually prohibit us from carrying a weapon, but long tradition and UK military rules do, and the issue has divided the chaplain community.

"For Commando chaplains our ethos is that to serve our people we have to be able to go through what they go through, which includes patrolling on the ground.

"In theory if we're captured in war we are supposed to be allowed to go about our ministry among prisoners. But that's a very long way from the reality in Afghanistan."

He added: "It's very unlikely we could be captured here, but if we were, the Taliban may well use us for publicity, and then probably execute us - just as they probably would any other coalition serviceman.

"I don't think I could put my wife through that. I personally would not want to let myself be captured.

"For that reason I think we should be pragmatic over sidearms. None of us are comfortable with this, and there are those who think it's going too far.

"But it's a debate which needs resolving, because of the kind of operations the Royal Marines are carrying out and are likely to in the years ahead."

Monsignor Paul Donovan, (Roman Catholic) Director of the Naval Chaplaincy Service (Operations), said: "The Chaplain on the ground needs to make the judgement whether the Red Cross symbol, which is meant to afford protection under the Geneva Convention, instead stands him in greater danger.

"Whilst some other nations do arm their chaplains as a matter of course, current British practice is not to."

Military chaplains - commonly known as Padres - have a proud history of supporting Britain's frontline forces often at great personal risk, and some have been decorated for extreme valour in helping wounded troops under fire.

In World War Two 134 British and Commonwealth Padres were killed, and chaplains followed the troops ashore on D-Day and jumped with Paratroopers behind enemy..."


War Hero
A minor point but typical that the Daily Mail has a large article all about Royal Navy Chaplains...then calls them Army on the title!

But seriously, this is a major issue. What do you think?
It seems rather hypocritical. It also makes one question if their faith is genuine. If you believe in God's Will and get captured, surely that should be seen as a test of your faith?* In Jesus's time being a Christian was a very risky business as Christians were persecuted and faced being killed for their beliefs. Today Christianity is the norm and the persecution and, in some places, the killings, are being carried out by the Christians (eg Robert Mugabe).

*I personally regard it as foolhardy in the extreme, but after all Priests' own position has been compromised by their leaders' insistence (in Britain & Europe) that where the majority are Christian, Christian moral norms should be prevail and be enshrined in law. In Afghanistan the majority are Muslim. If the Taleban, who are, after all, natives of the country, choose to enforce their moral norms on Christians, who are we to condemn them? As Jesus said: Do to others as you would have done to yourselves.

End of being Mr Nasty.
As one of the Padre's said, he doesn't want his missus having to watch him in an orange jump suit on telly.

It's a matter of personal choice, I can see no problem with it.


War Hero
Having reread the article it seems that it is not the fear of being captured or killed that is the issue, but rather sparing their wife having to watch their execution.

A tough decision. I think that they shouldn't be armed, but it is easy to say that sitting at home in my dressing gown just before I go upstairs to a nice warm bed, rather than being somewhere hot and sandy.


War Hero
This is not without precedent. I have spoken to a Chaplain who carried a weapon in Vietnam for much the same reasons. The VC /PAVN were no respecters of the clergy or the Red Cross and he considered it his duty to defend himself and the wounded he looked after.

I doubt God has a problem with that.
I would leave it up to the individual Padre concerned. If they wanted to carry a side arm then let them, those that don't want it, don't force them to carry one.
Did I read correctly that the side arm was to use to commit suicide rather than be captured? Surely anyone daft enough to believe in a supreme being would consider this a mortal sin?


Lantern Swinger
IMHO its got to be down to indivudual choice.

One thought did occur to me and that is if they are no longer wearing red cross armbands then by not carrying a weapon on patrol, they are still singling themselves out as every other member of the foot patrol will be armed.

As an aside, one of the best shots I ever encountered in the mob was a padre, he was an exceptional shot with an SLR, put me in my place on several occasions.

Anyway safe trip to all those in hot dusty places
I think it clearly should be down to the concsience of the individual. What ever ones views of their beliefs these guys do wonderful work for the man they minister to and are among the few god botherers I have respect for.

Thingy, remeber some of the other padres may be women too.
Maxi_77 said:
What ever ones views of their beliefs these guys do wonderful work for the man they minister to and are among the few god botherers I have respect for.

Slapdown accepted. My dealings with Service chaplains have usually been cordial and as one who has been involved with many hundreds of bereaved families, I do appreciate their work. Still don't believe what they do, though.
asst_dep_to_dep_asst said:
Maxi_77 said:
What ever ones views of their beliefs these guys do wonderful work for the man they minister to and are among the few god botherers I have respect for.

Slapdown accepted. My dealings with Service chaplains have usually been cordial and as one who has been involved with many hundreds of bereaved families, I do appreciate their work. Still don't believe what they do, though.

You don't have to agree to respect.

I might add I have also known a few ministers who have worked just as hard for non believers in their parish as they would have done for church members. AS I said not my scene but respect where it's due.


War Hero
Book Reviewer
I think this whole thing is the wrong way up. Any Service person sent into danger by the Govt surely has the right to the best protection and means of self-defence obtainable. If some individual Chaplains by reason of their individual belief then CHOOSE not to bear arms this has to be respected, subject to the Command's assessment that by so doing they do not increase the physical risk to their comrades.

The RC church's long support for Irish terrorist murderers suggests that not all branches of Christianity (if indeed it is one - I have my doubts) think alike on the question of taking life.


War Hero
Notwithstanding the place of priests/padres/rabbis/imams in the Forces, which has been discussed ad nauseum in other threads, one observation: the UK/US/NATO/Allies are not fighting this "war" as a religious war against Islam. If the Taleban/AQ choose to single out priests for "special" treatment, it is they who are effectively fighting a religious war against Christianity.

Now the Bible is quite explicit on the case: thou shalt not commit murder. Nothing there about self-defence, nothing there about suicide. Surely carrying a weapon (well, using a weapon against another person) is tantamount to breaching one of the founding tenets of Judeo-Christianity?

But dogma aside, if the priest is in theatre, then it should be up to their conscience whether to be armed. Given that they might be in the position of having to fire to save the life of one of their flock, it would seem apt.


War Hero
stumpy said:
A minor point but typical that the Daily Mail has a large article all about Royal Navy Chaplains...then calls them Army on the title!

But seriously, this is a major issue. What do you think?

And to echo that, Paul Donovan is very much a dark blue-suited Bish.


What a preposterous idea a ‘Devil Dodger’ carrying a gun and being prepared to use it, if they did that it would mean that they would be prepared to break one of the commandments, ‘Thou shalt not kill’ and since when did the Padre start going into action in Helmand Province with the lads?
40's padre obviously is. I dont think the issue is padres going on patrol trying to slot taliban but more about if they get caught.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
finknottle Commando Chaplains The Corps 0
soleil Channel 4-July 12th 2009-Programme on Royal Marine Chaplains The Corps 2
golden_rivet 11am radio4 prog on army chaplains 12/3 Current Affairs 3
MoD_RSS British Armed Forces Minister arrives in Cairo MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Fish bred at Environment Agency’s fish farm used for rehabilitation of armed forces MoD News 0
MoD_RSS New Nesscliff kitchen and dining facility improves experience for armed forces MoD News 0
soleil BBC R4: Wed, 23rd September 2020 - 3 PM - Money Box Live - Armed Forces Financial Help Finance & Pensions 2
MoD_RSS CNC officers proud to take part in webinar on women in armed policing MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Peace Agreement - Sudan Armed Opposition Groups: Troika Statement MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Innovation call for technology to stop armed or violent offenders MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Call for armed forces community to contribute to the Frontline Project MoD News 0
MoD_RSS CNC achieves silver award in supporting the armed forces community MoD News 0
soleil Armed Forces’ Pay Review Body - Forty-Ninth Report - July 2020 The Fleet 0
MoD_RSS 127 new employers awarded for supporting the armed forces community MoD News 0
soleil Armed Forces Pay Review Body - 49th Report - 2020 Finance & Pensions 3
MoD_RSS Armed Forces personnel to receive 2% pay rise MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Minister for the Armed Forces James Heappey MP: The Ministry of Defence Response to the Covid-19 Pandemic MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Armed Forces lead tributes to Dame Vera Lynn at her funeral MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Free ‘wraparound’ childcare for the armed forces MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Scottish Secretary Alistair Jack marks 2020 Armed Forces Week MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Armed Forces week MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Armed Forces announce launch of first Cyber Regiment in major modernisation MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Welsh Secretary commends Armed Forces’ contribution to the fight against coronavirus in Wales MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK Armed Forces step up support to the Caribbean Overseas Territories during coronavirus pandemic MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Funding to support armed forces charities doing vital work during pandemic MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK Armed Forces Maintaining Critical Defence Activities MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Welsh Secretary praises UK's Armed Forces' support in Wales' fight against coronavirus MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK's Armed Forces efforts recognised by Scottish Secretary MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Armed Forces protected from vexatious claims in important step MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Suspension of War Pensions and Armed Forces Compensation Scheme Medical Examinations and Assessments MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Gaming technology trialled in training UK Armed Forces MoD News 0
soleil FB: SSAFA, The Armed Forces Charity - With Love From RNAS Yeovilton The Fleet Air Arm 1
MoD_RSS We must protect Children in Armed Conflict: "Children have been robbed of their childhood and forced to participate in brutal wars" MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Armed Forces heroes celebrated at The Sun Military Awards MoD News 0
soleil ITV News: "Armed Forces Tattoos Photography Exhibition Opens In London" History 25
MoD_RSS Armed policing code strengthened in response to Grainger Inquiry MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Armed Forces Covenant Report shows support for military community MoD News 0
MoD_RSS New pledges for the Armed Forces announced in Queen's Speech MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Armed Forces lead nation in Cenotaph service on Remembrance Sunday MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Production starts on world-leading respirators for UK armed forces MoD News 0
MoD_RSS New Office for Veterans’ Affairs will ensure the UK leads the world in care for Armed Forces Veterans MoD News 0
vauxhall Public Consultation on Legal Protection for Armed Forces Personnel Serving Abroad on Operations The Quarterdeck 1
MoD_RSS CNC proud to play key part in inaugural Women in Armed Policing conference MoD News 0
MoD_RSS PM praises role of UK's Armed Forces MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Defence Minister visits West Africa and extends language training to Senegalese Armed Forces MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK Minister for Armed Forces Rt. Hon Mark Lancaster visits Ghana MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Armed forces personnel complete Hajj MoD News 0
MoD_RSS 100 employers awarded for supporting the armed forces MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Armed Forces mark 50 years since the start of operations in Northern Ireland MoD News 0
vauxhall Armed Forces Pay Rise Confirmed as 2.9% Finance & Pensions 2
Similar threads

Latest Threads

New Posts