Did a sub sink this trawler ?

Discussion in 'Submariners' started by lsadirty, Aug 13, 2009.

Welcome to the Navy Net aka Rum Ration

The UK's largest and busiest UNofficial RN website.

The heart of the site is the forum area, including:

  1. Most trawlers are in poor condition......so just blame RN :oops:
     
  2. This saga has been going on for years - it's complete bollocks that a UK SSN was involved. However a load of "legal experts" and "rent a nuclear expert.co.uk" will make loads of money out of it.
     
  3. Some trawler skippers play lets catch a sub to get new nets, sometime they get more than they bargain for.
     
  4. oooo ooooo this is a good game 'random speculation'


    Lets see, my contribution...


    I think, right, that the missing freighter, the Maltese Flagged, Russian crewed one carrying 'timber' was sunk by a SSN because MI6 had information that it was carrying nuclear weapons, and SF couldn't land on it and take it over! I'm not sure which country to blame though. Maybe the French, seeing as it has an Algeria connection...
     
  5. Considering every time this happens the finger is pointed at the submarine fleet I would have thought this could degenerate into a simple "cut and paste" media exercise. No doubt the resident South West "Naval Expert" M**e C******ly will give everyone the benefit of his knowledge :roll:

    Glad no porpoises were killed or the surface fleet would get blamed for that
     
  6. ANTARES

    PESCADO
     
  7. Antares yes
    Pescado no

    1 proven SM related accident does not automatically mean every trawler incident involves the RN
     
  8. OK so it has happened before but it is certainly not the only reason fishing boatys sink, in fact it is one of the least common causes of fishing boats sinking, but the military haters and compensation lawyers enjoy making up stories every time a fishing boat sinks.

    Now which one are you, a miltary hater or a compensation lawyer?
     
  9. It happens...


    Interesting information at this site... http://lists.peacelink.it/armamenti/msg00252.html

    Of course RN never gets compensated when it
    s the other way round... :D



     
  10. 99% of the time the reason a trawler goes over is they snag their nets and the skipper won't cut them free… bit of a chop and you start pulling hard on a snagged net to try and free it and gravity meets mr bouyancy with predictable results.
     
  11. As this really winds me up and Bergan hasn't done his research and resorted to tabloid style false accusations I thought I'd stick this in ref. the Pescado

    http://www.independent.co.uk/news/pescado-disaster-blamed-on-owner-1199850.html

    If you bother to read it Bergan, it had nothing to do with the RN but a greedy owner sending an unseaworthy boat out and cutting every available corner

    rant over
     
  12. Serves them right, they shouldn't be out in little boats at that time of night.
     
  13. I`ve seen it happen ..off Bournemouth …a small fishing boat with 1 owner crew suddenly started going fast astern …it was immediately swamped and the skipper jumped clear ..this was in the 80s when I kept a boat at Poole…I don`t know what came of the incident but I have always thought it must have been a submarine…

    Of course I don`t believe for a moment it was one of ours

    ……..
     
  14. It seems that all their 'experts' have said is that the damage seems to have been caused by a sub. Why does it particularly have to be British?
     
  15. Look….
    A sub is an out of town post office …
    It describes an inferior item…or something subline..
    Or a standin for your duty..
    It is wot you bum off your oppo when you are short of cash….


    But it is never EVER used in the Andrew to describe a feckin BOAT….

    Not in front of submariners anyway…


    …
     
  16. Oh dear another expert.

    I put both names up to illustrate that one was a real submarine incident and one wasn't.

    FYI I led the salvage of both vessels. Lifted the Pescado from just off the Manacles with the Seaway Harrier with the D&C police forensic team onboard and ended up months later in Bristol Crown Court giving expert witness testimony against both the owner and the manager of the Pescado for six charges of manslaughter.

    RM
     
  17. witsend

    witsend War Hero Book Reviewer

    :roll: Why not say that in the first place.
     
  18. No, not an expert or claiming to be in my post, just an experienced submariner so get off your high horse. Just posting 2 names of sunken trawlers and nothing else implies (to me) that you were insinuating they were both the result of submarine accidents. I hope your testimony was less ambiguous!!
     

Share This Page