Crying during training

[24681012]

In most of the documentaries I've seen about recruit training in all the services, recruits are sometimes crying. What is the view of this, is it seen as weakness or just an inevitable result when things are going badly? Accepted or disapproved of?

 

[janner]

Why do you ask?

 

[WreckerL]

It makes good TV and boosts their telly ratings.

 

[iipodgeii]

In most of the documentaries I've seen about recruit training in all the services, recruits are sometimes crying. What is the view of this, is it seen as weakness or just an inevitable result when things are going badly? Accepted or disapproved of?

No negative view or weakness as we're all in the same boat, if anything it makes us all stronger as fellow oppos and instructors gel together to help eachother when theyre down, things that usually cause people to cry are; homesickness, 1st 4 weeks are the hardest, stress builds up, new environment and the militarisation etc, it gets to some people and eventually it just lets loose. One of our lads had his wife questioning their marriage as they had gone from seeing each other everyday to not seeing them for weeks! They're good now tho, instructors helped them out.
Ofc if people do mess about or get watnings sometimes the disappointment or act of getting warnings and scare some individuals or upset them.

 

[24681012]

Why do you ask?

I want to know if it is seen as a normal response, or if you get marked down for it.

 

[WreckerL]

I want to know if it is seen as a normal response, or if you get marked down for it.

The question is why do you want to know, what will you do with the opinions expressed on this thread.

Writing an article perchance?

 

[24681012]

No, much more personal reasons which I will not discuss, but shouldn't be too difficult to work out.

 

[janner]

How is the Journo business nowadays?

 

[Taztiff]

I want to know if it is seen as a normal response, or if you get marked down for it.

The question is why do you want to know, what will you do with the opinions expressed on this thread.

Writing an article perchance?

The concern here @24681012 is that you have only been a member since Monday and your question is being seen as dubious and interesting for a first post.

An off the cuff remark by a RR member about recruit crying for whatever reason could be used as 'A senior Naval source said.....'

 

[Purple_twiglet]

People under traiming are going through an enormous physical, mental and psychological period of change unlike anything they will ever do again in their lives. Frankly if you dont find yourself feelig overwhelmed or pissed off or feeling threaders during training, then chances are you may not be human. Some people let off steam by crying - is it a problem - no, provided that you dont sit there in the classroom with tears rolling down your eyes at all times.

That said, crying during training is mandatory for chefs, usually when preparing onions.

 

[Ninja_Stoker]

I think there's been some good replies to the query. Sometimes initial training can be a bit emotional and generate tears of frustration or angst, self pity, loneliness, homesickness, relief, jubilation or laughter. Particularly laughter.

It's an emotional roller-coaster for most but I guess it depends also on the individual. If they repeatedly blub everytime someone shouts, then there are possibly underlying issues covering a wide range of potential triggers, some minor, some just attributed to growing-up, some more significant, some requiring medical intervention.

Is it an issue? Depends on the circumstances I guess.

 

[24681012]

The concern here @24681012 is that you have only been a member since Monday and your question is being seen as dubious and interesting for a first post.

An off the cuff remark by a RR member about recruit crying for whatever reason could be used as 'A senior Naval source said.....'

Yes I understand your concerns. But no..... Nothing devious going on!