Comradeship

#1
This Post is similar to one I posted elsewhere, amongst a mainly Civvy Population. As Submariners, serving or Ex, like me, our comradeship is of different but none-the-less sharing nature to that of the 'Brown Jobs'.

I Posted (in Response to 'Favourite Lyrics?') ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Brothers in Arms" Dire Straits

These thought-provoking* lyrics reflect upon Comradeship (especially poignant and relevant throughout the current operations of our Armed Forces.)



They float along all through a beautifully slow, haunting and soulful melody:


"Brothers in Arms"

These mist covered mountains
Are a home now for me
But my home is the lowlands
And always will be
Some day you’ll return to
Your valleys and your farms
And you’ll no longer burn
To be brothers in arms

Through these fields of destruction
Baptisms of fire
I’ve watched all your suffering
As the battles raged higher
And though they did hurt me so bad
In the fear and alarm
You did not desert me
My brothers in arms

There’s so many different worlds
So many differents suns
And we have just one world
But we live in different ones

Now the suns gone to hell
And the moons riding high
Let me bid you farewell
Every man has to die
But its written in the starlight
And every line on your palm

We’re fools to make war
On our brothers in arms



*We are led into assuming/believing that it is about same-side Comradeship.

However an intriguing and thought-provoking ambiguity is introduced, joltingly, at the final two lines:
“Were fools to make war
On our brothers in armsâ€


Could we also consider those fighting on the opposite side as OUR comrades?

Alternatively, these final Brothers in Arms could be interpreted as same-side Comrades but of a different stamp:
i.e. Commissioned Officers vs. non-Commissioned Ranks who fought wars together but after their common battles may revert foolishly to prejudiced class or political conflicts.


Such is the power of the Dire Straits poetry, here and in some other of their works ….

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~End Of Original Posting.


(I now cannot get this song out of my head & Civvies dont understand 'Comradeship...')

So - What do other Submariners really think, putting aside winding each other up!?
Or - Am I getting too soft, having been inboard/outside for too long/not yet in any S/M'ers Asscn. ?

A Genuine Question and I am stone cold sober.


Bob
 
#3
Guzzler said:
I suppose they could be spacemen as well.

Little green ones.

Bet you hadn't thought of that eh?
What? Like E.T? Or the Kling-film-ons on the starboard bow, starboard bow etc?

You have got me thinking now, & that's dangerous at this time of night,

Thank you, anyway, rack time for now.

Then:

"Next Please....."
 
#4
I think it is true to say that Submariners regard there opposite numbers in other navies with a level of respect and given the chance would be quite happy to be their comrades.But whether this would extend to not wanting to harm them in a war situation is another matter.If it came down to him or me I would definitely choose me.
 
#5
I think submariners of all nations share a common bond as it is a somewhat unique lifestyle. I've had some great runs ashore in Hamburg and Bremerhaven with U-boat old comrades and a lot was done for the families of the Kursk when she went down. Doesn't stop you killing them in wartime though, just have an empathy with your foe IMHO
 
#6
WreckerL said:
I think submariners of all nations share a common bond as it is a somewhat unique lifestyle. I've had some great runs ashore in Hamburg and Bremerhaven with U-boat old comrades and a lot was done for the families of the Kursk when she went down. Doesn't stop you killing them in wartime though, just have an empathy with your foe IMHO
Nice one WreckerL,thats respect,
 
#7
WreckerL said:
I think submariners of all nations share a common bond as it is a somewhat unique lifestyle.
Aunty Betty's finest failed to select me as an intrepid bird man but the same, I believe, is true for aviators. On balance, though, I'd rather be up there than down there.

What goes up must come down. The reverse is not true.