Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Channel 4: "Falklands' Most Daring Raid" - Sunday, March 18th 2012

scouse

War Hero
Spent many a day at Farad head, duty pinky for the Buccaneers dropping I000 lbs bombs on Garvie Island, ps never saw any seagulls, after 809 sqdn had shed its load lol
 

Handler

War Hero
Great story, the book about the Black Buck mission was good too, surprising just how much they had to muddle through, Martin Withers is also the pilot who flies the display Vulcan, very accomplished and a true pro.:worship:
 

Seaweed

War Hero
Book Reviewer
The bloke who pushed to lead the raid seemed to be the right stuff. The other one who seemed to feel hard done by not to have spent his 22 years drawing flying pay sat on his arse in Lincolnshire came good though. The one who was worrying about the blokes on the ground I suppose votes Lib Dem.

I thought the actual doc about the trip was good and certainly brought out how totally unprepared the RAF was for flight refuelling and iron bombing (so what were the Vulcans up to after the RN took over nuking in 1968?). The bods in the Vulcan and the Victors certainly did their bit on the night as best they could, and scary too it was, but it looked to me as if there was still room to use one side of the Stanley runway for fighters and craters don't last forever if there are blokes with shovels and the odd bag of cement about. Worth a mention thsat it wasn't the RAF who put the carrier out of business so that its planes had to fly from the mainland. The shots of destroyed aircraft were a complete irrelevance.

In sum, good doc spoiled by too much misleading spin. As was expected.
 

Handler

War Hero
He doesn't have to be a good shot SJRM, he only flies or flew the cab, the sad thing is , how it sits forlorn on the far side of Waddo airfield. Fortunately the Vulcan preservation society and joe public keep a Vulcan flying ( just ) and its a magic sound when it takes off, known as the Vulcan Howl, climbs steeply out and hard banks away. They have been rolled too and for many years were a sight for those who live in Lincolnshire, especillay doing a QRA take off of 4 cabs.
 

Blackadder D25

Midshipman
i actually thought it was good "more PR for the Crabs right enough" but good all the same, good vision from the chief of staff to actually have the balls to commit all those assets... prob be buggered if we tried to re-enact that now with all our ....eeehhmm "air assets"
 

Ninja_Stoker

War Hero
Moderator
Interesting when the story is told from an RAF propaganda perspective.

Notwithstanding the raids were a logistical nightmare & extremely well executed by the crews operating at full-stretch, half of the Blackbuck sorties failed to reach their target. From the dozens of bombs dropped, just one hit the runway, three weeks before the landings.

Routine supply flights between FI & Argentina continued throughout the war as Stanley airfield was only out of action for a day. Pucara & Aermacchi strike aircraft continued to operate from Stanley throughout the land-phase as they only needed a relatively short take-off.


Stanley Airfield runway was physically too short to operate jet fighter or bomber aircraft, so we were told - hence the Royal Engineers extending the runway immediately post-conflict for the Phantoms before the construction of MPA, so it's interesting to claim the Mirage III's were not deployed to Stanley due to Black Buck.

The RAF claim that the Black Buck raids stopped Argentine attacks from taking off in the Falklands is also a rather economic with the truth - My ship was strafed by a Stanley-based Aermacchi on 21st May, causing two serious casualties. The SAS had much more success on Pebble Island with regard reducing the threat to the task force in my opinion.

The raids undoubtedly had a big & much needed psychological effect, to the extent Argentina feared an attack on the mainland & initially held-back aircraft in reserve to defend Argentina. An epic logistical achievement undoubtedly undertaken by brave men, of that there is no denying, but less spin please.

And, the Vulcan is and was a beautiful aircraft.
 

Seaweed

War Hero
Book Reviewer
I take the point about the implied threat to BA (a shorter trip) and suppose the modern equivalent is a Tomahawk sauntering down the Avenida Florida to the admiring gaze of the shoopers and then whacking into the Casa Rosa.
 

Dredd

War Hero
Super Moderator
For a laugh I though I would take a look and see what the Crabs take on it was, so clicked on the tab at the top of this page.

ARRSE - Active. Rum Ration - Active. RAF - Security down!
 

Stirling

Banned
I take the point about the implied threat to BA (a shorter trip) and suppose the modern equivalent is a Tomahawk sauntering down the Avenida Florida to the admiring gaze of the shoopers and then whacking into the Casa Rosa.

Indeed, locals pointing at Tom's following street layout in Baghdad springs to mind.
 

jack616

Midshipman
I wonder - now its been proved we need to be able to bomb things 8000 miles away from time to time - are we still capable
now the Vulcans are done for?

Have to agree about the Vulcan - very majestic aircraft and what a credit to the designer that they could achieve this
with tech that old.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
soleil Channel 5: "The Great Falklands Gamble" - Tuesday, March 13th 2012 - 20:00 History 3
MoD_RSS Commission seeks new trustees at Sikh Channel charity MoD News 0
guns1969 Channel Security Diamond Lil's 2
MoD_RSS P-8 Poseidon aircraft to support Border Force operations in the Channel MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Eleven arrested linked with illegally facilitating Channel crossings MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Priti Patel and new French Interior Minister agree action on Channel crossings MoD News 0
higthepig Channel 5 The Quarterdeck 8
soleil D. Star: "Royal Navy Warship Intercepts Four Russian Vessels In English Channel" The Fleet 3
MoD_RSS New Charity Inquiry: Sikh Channel Community Broadcasting Company Limited MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK’s independent seat at WTO to include Channel Islands MoD News 0
S Is HMS Raleigh like the Channel 4 programme makes it out to be? Joining the Royal Navy 3
MoD_RSS News story: Undulate Ray by-catch allowance in the English Channel MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Navy vessel to be sent to the Channel MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Home Secretary visits channel operations MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: Home Secretary bolsters Border Force fleet in the Channel MoD News 0
Ballistic HMS Belfast on Channel 5 Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 9
MoD_RSS News story: Four fishermen rescued after vessel capsized in English channel MoD News 0
WannabeAdmiral Royal Navy YouTube channel has kit guides now Joining the Royal Navy 3
MoD_RSS News story: UK and France increase security cooperation in the Channel MoD News 0
Ninja_Stoker Warship Channel 4 Documentary Series Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 94
BillyNoMates Coming to a channel near you soon. Current Affairs 55
M Channel 4 Series - Could you be a spy? Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 10
Ballistic Quest TV channel: Devonport Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 36
soleil HMS Flying Fox - Channel 5 - Monday, April 14th 2014 - Gadget Show - 19:00 Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 5
soleil Channel 5: "Big, Bigger, Biggest" - Thursday, Oct 10th 2013 - 1900 Submariners 3
soleil Channel 4: "Armed Forces’ Involvement In Sectarian Rangers ‘Party’ Was A PR Disaster" Current Affairs 89
F Channel 4 Ramadan broadcasts Current Affairs 4
Good CO Get your tattoos removed on TV - Channel 4 The Quarterdeck 0
Bad CO Discovery Channel Series - FUTURE FIREPOWER Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 1
janner Channel Four TV Diamond Lil's 2
soleil Military History Channel - 23rd October 2012 - "Officers And Gentlemen" Bases / Shore Est 22
Naval_Gazer Royal Navy to pay tribute to Channel Dash heroes Current Affairs 0
soleil Channel 5 - Tuesday, 05 June 2012 - 19:00 - War Hero In My Family The Corps 0
C Channel 5 needs you and your diy disasters The Quarterdeck 10
sgtpepperband Channel 4 - 10 O'Clock Live: "Charlie Brooker's Rant About 'The Sun' Newspaper" The Internet - Best and Worst 8
S Royals on Channel 5 Current Affairs 15
finknottle Programme of Interest starting 30th Jan 2012 on Channel 5 @ 2100 The Corps 2
soleil Nelson’s Navy: Back From The Dead - Channel 4 - Sunday - September 04 2011 - 2000 History 21
SEP86 Charity Long Cycle and Channel Swim Charity 0
A Channel 5 - Royal Navy Submarine Mission - 5th September 2011 - 2000 - HMS Turbulent Submariners 139
soleil Channel 5 - 'Submarine School' - Tuesday 21 June 2011 - 20:00 Submariners 26
Scouse_Castaway Dambusters: Building the Bouncing Bomb, Channel 4 Monday History 1
soleil "How To Command A Nuclear Submarine" - w/c 14/03 - Military History Channel Submariners 26
trelawney126 HMS ARK ROYAL Discovery TV Channel Current Affairs 7
soleil Channel 4: March 15th: 2100: "Heston's Mission Impossible" Submariners 39
Kev73 HMS Ark Royal on Discovery Channel The Fleet 1
trelawney126 LastVoices of World War 1 Sky Military Channel History 2
soleil Channel 5: February 7th 2011: "Royal Navy Caribbean Patrol - HMS Manchester" The Fleet 17
J Royal Navy Caribbean Patrol, Channel 5 Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 1
B GOD TV Channel Diamond Lil's 9
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

New Posts

Top