Can a stoker (marine engineering) do the AACC?

Im soon to be starting training, however i am just wondering whether a Marine Engineer (rating) can comeplete the All Arms Commando Course (AACC)?

Cheers
 

dapperdunn

War Hero
Book Reviewer
If you want a green lid, join the Royal Marines. If you want a blue one, join the Royal Navy. It's not exactly rocket science.
 

Drakey

War Hero
Im soon to be starting training, however i am just wondering whether a Marine Engineer (rating) can comeplete the All Arms Commando Course (AACC)?

Cheers
Can't see the need for it. The navy doesn't support "badge collectors" as places on the AACC are limited to the people who need to do it for the job they are in. CDO ME - not likely.
 
My issue is the marines wont have me as ive got a metal plate in my wrist, due to the absolute nonsense fact that jumping in and out of cold water could shatter my metal plate. 1, titanium doesnt shatter at those temperatures, 2, ive been signed off by the doctor that im fully fit and that my wrist is actually stronger then before with all 100% movement back with no pain, so I literally dont get why they wont accept me?
 
Yes, i know but it doesnt make much sense if there is no limitations, i can fully understand if someone hasnt got the full range of movement and if it causes pain but my wrist is absolutely fine, i can drop to the floor and bang out the 70 press ups pain free.
 

dapperdunn

War Hero
Book Reviewer
My issue is the marines wont have me as ive got a metal plate in my wrist, due to the absolute nonsense fact that jumping in and out of cold water could shatter my metal plate. 1, titanium doesnt shatter at those temperatures, 2, ive been signed off by the doctor that im fully fit and that my wrist is actually stronger then before with all 100% movement back with no pain, so I literally dont get why they wont accept me?
Are you sure that it's the metal plate that's holding you back? Have you had a medical?
 
Are you sure that it's the metal plate that's holding you back? Have you had a medical?
I applied to join the marines last year , and got a date to start training, completed selection and passed and then had a motorbike crash a few weeks after which broke my wrist and therefore the metal playe got put in and when i went back to the AFCO they said the marines wont accept you anymore but the navy will, and at that point the Army CA said the paras will still have you, but i could never join them as my dad was one and to which we argue about whose better, so thats why im joining the navy
 

dapperdunn

War Hero
Book Reviewer
I applied to join the marines last year , and got a date to start training, completed selection and passed and then had a motorbike crash a few weeks after which broke my wrist and therefore the metal playe got put in and when i went back to the AFCO they said the marines wont accept you anymore but the navy will, and at that point the Army CA said the paras will still have you, but i could never join them as my dad was one and to which we argue about whose better, so thats why im joining the navy
Did you not just have to wait 12 months?
From the medical standards:"Fractures within the last 12 months, except fractures of the digits / clavicles".
 
Did you not just have to wait 12 months?
From the medical standards:"Fractures within the last 12 months, except fractures of the digits / clavicles".
Its been over 12 months now well i started a new application a few months ago so that when 12 months after the fracture was up i could literally get straight into selection and training, but the navy CA said to me “the marines wont take you with a plate in, to join u would have to take it out, or you can join the navy” but then again they did say that someone with my academic ability should really join as an officer but i just want to be a rating to be honest and everyone I use to speak to about joining the marines would say im to clever to join the marines but thats not how i see it, its something ive always wanted to do.
 

dapperdunn

War Hero
Book Reviewer
Its been over 12 months now well i started a new application a few months ago so that when 12 months after the fracture was up i could literally get straight into selection and training, but the navy CA said to me “the marines wont take you with a plate in, to join u would have to take it out, or you can join the navy” but then again they did say that someone with my academic ability should really join as an officer but i just want to be a rating to be honest and everyone I use to speak to about joining the marines would say im to clever to join the marines but thats not how i see it, its something ive always wanted to do.
There's only 2 things you can do
1) Ask @Ninja_Stoker his opinion. Although I'm sure he'll be quick to tell you that as with most everyone on here, he's not qualified to give you a medical opinion, only a doctor can give that.
2) Apply and get a doctor to either pass or fail you.
You'll get no definitive answer from chatrooms on the internet.
 

SONAR-BENDER

War Hero
Why not join up, maintain a VERY high fitness/comittment level, then apply to join the SBS? It will be harder for you coming from a 'non infantry' type soldiery background, but it CAN be done.
 
There's only 2 things you can do
1) Ask @Ninja_Stoker his opinion. Although I'm sure he'll be quick to tell you that as with most everyone on here, he's not qualified to give you a medical opinion, only a doctor can give that.
2) Apply and get a doctor to either pass or fail you.
You'll get no definitive answer from chatrooms on the internet.
Okay, cheers
 

Seadog

War Hero
Moderator
This subject warrants a forum of its own, it's been done to death.

There were opportunities for clankies to do AACC and not only for working in RM units. I know a former POMEM who did a near 3 year draft
(appointment) to 539 ASRM without AACC although it was 'desirable'. It isn't 'essential' and a gusting 3 month non essential pre joining course may be viewed as a luxury in the current manning climate.

My direct knowledge of this subject has reached its statute of limitations so I shall return to my Telegraph letters page and STFU.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
Ninja_Stoker Marine Engineering Mechanics (Stoker) Branch query - can you help? History 9
H Message for ninja stoker Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 9
S Stoker John Webster The Fleet 3
BreathingOutOnTheWayUp The stoker down below The Fleet 1
H Seeking WW2 RN stoker History 0
J CPO Chris Smithson (Stoker) Submariners 1
janner HM Submarine Saracen - Stoker Metcalfe History 0
I RNR stoker branch Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 27
G Leading Stoker Albert Peach History 1
I Baby stoker course book needed! The Book Club 2
Stirling Stoker Wilson History 5
W Stoker training? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 18
Bond509 Passed for Aet!!!! (special thanks to Ninja-Stoker) The Fleet Air Arm 22
C ex killick stoker Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 4
S FAO: Ninja Stoker Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 50
Seaweed Henry Stoker and AE2 Submariners 1
josiecats oi Ninja stoker The Gash Barge 0
andym Help for a Baby Stoker. Diamond Lil's 10
josiecats Ninja Stoker 's nail biting thread....... The Gash Barge 8
D Ex Stoker trying to become a Kiwi The Afterlife - Resettlement and Jobs 14
Two_Clips_Two_Pins ME Dept shake up and the passing of the stoker... Submariners 31
andym RN Stoker at War memoirs. History 0
MoD_RSS An update from Tom McCormack, CEO, Marine Management Organisation MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Marine charity benefits by £61,966 from Enforcement Undertaking MoD News 0
MoD_RSS The Marine Management Organisation (MMO) are administering the new £15.4 million Maritime & Fisheries Fund (MFF). MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK Government works with Southern Africa to support the development of a safe, secure and thriving marine economy MoD News 0
MoD_RSS New £2.5 million project launched to restore fragile marine habitats MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Marine Management Organisation board reappointments MoD News 0
J Accelerated apprentice scheme in marine engineering Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 11
MoD_RSS Marine Station, Isle of Cumbrae, Ayrshire MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Have your say on Marine Planning in England MoD News 0
soleil Aberdeen Press & Journal: "Commemoration Arranged For Royal Marine Hero And His Son In Beauly" 26/01/20 The Corps 2
MoD_RSS Marine Management Organiation (MMO) to administer new £15.4 million funding scheme for English fishing industry MoD News 0
B Marine Engineering phase 2 Course length?? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 13
J Joining as marine engineer at 16 Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 17
C Marine Engineer Officer Career change Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 5
MoD_RSS Honduras joins high-level dialogue on marine litter and waste management in the Caribbean MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Guatemala joins high-level dialogue on marine litter and waste management in the Caribbean MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Britannia Protects the Waves: £7m extra funding to protect UK marine life MoD News 0
C AA Marine Engineer Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 15
MoD_RSS Marine Management Organisation appoints new Chief Executive Officer MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Highly Protected Marine Areas review panel confirmed MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Inspector of Marine Accidents (Nautical) - Southampton MoD News 0
E RFA APPRENTICE MARINE ENGINEER INTAKE 2019 RFA 1
P Marine Engineering apprenticeship vs Regular intake Joining the Royal Navy 3
MoD_RSS Press release: England's Marine Life Protected With Blue Belt Expansion MoD News 0
E HELP with basic information on a marine The Corps 5
S Marine technician or supply chain Joining the Royal Navy 30
MoD_RSS News story: Joint statement on the UK-U.S. marine technology SME best practice exchange MoD News 0
N ACCELERATED APPRENTICE SCHEME (MARINE ENGINEERING) Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 8
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

New Posts

Top