Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Britain's Great War - Sir Douglas Haig???

Parade_Ho

Badgeman
Dear All,

I've been watching Jeremy Paxman's programme on Monday nights and this week, 17 Feb, a question of identity arose.

If you've recorded this - or go on to i Player - around the 17:57 timing mark, there is reference to Sir Douglas Haig and at that point a photo of a senior officer is shown. I don't think it is Haig at all, I did half wonder about it being Sir John French, but on reflection I don't think it is. A poster on the BBC PoV website thought it might have been Field Marshal Birdwood, but then even they had doubts about their choice. Do any WW1 experts have a view as to the identity of the individual ? Thanks.
 

finknottle

Banned
Dear All,

I've been watching Jeremy Paxman's programme on Monday nights and this week, 17 Feb, a question of identity arose.

If you've recorded this - or go on to i Player - around the 17:57 timing mark, there is reference to Sir Douglas Haig and at that point a photo of a senior officer is shown. I don't think it is Haig at all, I did half wonder about it being Sir John French, but on reflection I don't think it is. A poster on the BBC PoV website thought it might have been Field Marshal Birdwood, but then even they had doubts about their choice. Do any WW1 experts have a view as to the identity of the individual ? Thanks.

Did he bear any resemblance to a donkey?
 

sweetpea

War Hero
Dear All,

I've been watching Jeremy Paxman's programme on Monday nights and this week, 17 Feb, a question of identity arose.

If you've recorded this - or go on to i Player - around the 17:57 timing mark, there is reference to Sir Douglas Haig and at that point a photo of a senior officer is shown. I don't think it is Haig at all, I did half wonder about it being Sir John French, but on reflection I don't think it is. A poster on the BBC PoV website thought it might have been Field Marshal Birdwood, but then even they had doubts about their choice. Do any WW1 experts have a view as to the identity of the individual ? Thanks.


You are quite right, there was indeed an error made. The photo shown in the BBC programme was that of Sir Charles Carmichael Monro and not Haig.
Well spotted!


SP.
 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator

Good article.

I am talking about the high command, not the subaltern who led his men over the top armed only with a service revolver, they have my utmost respect.

Whilst there were Generals stuck in there ways and unable or unwilling to accept change (reminds me of some on here) and caused un-necessary losses (Gallipoli and Sir Ian Hamilton for instance, wrong man for the job) many in the High Command were quick to grasp the changing environment. Don't forget the war lasted for 4 years and massive technological advancements were made at a mind boggling rate.
 

finknottle

Banned
That would be why they sent thousands to their deaths in order to gain a few yards of mud and signed the death warrants of men suffering from shell shock. It looks like we will just have to agree to disagree.
 

danny

War Hero
That would be why they sent thousands to their deaths in order to gain a few yards of mud and signed the death warrants of men suffering from shell shock. It looks like we will just have to agree to disagree.

But who was sending them? Generals or politicians?
 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator
That would be why they sent thousands to their deaths in order to gain a few yards of mud and signed the death warrants of men suffering from shell shock. It looks like we will just have to agree to disagree.

It would seem so Finks, you would seem not to grasp the reason for the First battle of the Somme, and it was as big a shock to generals as to the troops, most of the British artillery shells never went off, which is why the German defences were intact, and which is why standards in manufacture were brought about which became Defstans.

But it's pointless debating it with you, you have you're opinion, I prefer to read the historical facts.
 

Guzzler

War Hero
Blackadder is the historical truth.

It isn't, but that's sort of my point.

I don't know how many primary sources Wrecker has researched to confirm his 'facts', but if his sources are purely 'history' books, which can only be an individual's interpretation of the sources that they have used, then Blackadder is a viable counter-argument.

Richard III was a bastard because Shakespeare said so. Richard III's death heralded the start of the Tudor dynasty. Shakespeare lived during Tudor times and would have had to be mental (until his head went [if the history books are anything to go by - see what I did there?]) to have described him in any other way.

The First World War was 'glorious' at the time (so we are told), then with post WWII liberalism the 'Lions led by...' naughtiness started by all those homosexual commies became accepted by many, but now the tides have turned and this theory is being disputed by the neo-conservatism of the naughties and onwards.

History and 'fact' are uncomfortable bedfellows.

Edit: Sorry, all the gibberish about Richard III was to emphasise my point about how history can be, and often is, twisted to suit the needs of the writer.
 
Last edited:

finknottle

Banned
It would seem so Finks, you would seem not to grasp the reason for the First battle of the Somme, and it was as big a shock to generals as to the troops, most of the British artillery shells never went off, which is why the German defences were intact, and which is why standards in manufacture were brought about which became Defstans.

But it's pointless debating it with you, you have you're opinion, I prefer to read the historical facts.


Oh look general our shells are duds and the hun's machine guns are still capable of putting down scything fire on our men; no matter Darling send our brave boys over the top anyway'. Twats!


Posted from the Navy Net mobile app (Android / iOS)
 

WreckerL

War Hero
Super Moderator
I see Guzzler's point and I'm not going to put a long list of the books I've read on the subject, which, incidentally, cover both sides of the argument and none of which involve wikipedia or Max Hastings, it's just the blanket "Lions led by Donkeys" rhetoric followed by one liners that I find irksome.

Yes, there was wholesale slaughter on scale never seen before, yes Generals of all armies made terrible mistakes in the beginning as no-one had fought an industrial war before. Finks has kind of confirmed my thoughts by his previous post which hardly contributes to any debate and Guzzler bringing in a left wing/right wing slant is fairly predictable TBH.

As to Guzzler's point about the books I've read, what's the alternative..regard every history book as bullshit and ignore the past?
 
Last edited:

Ageing_Gracefully

War Hero
Moderator
Review Editor
Book Reviewer
The trouble with this thread is that people are imposing the mores of today on events of 100 years ago.

The 'lions led by donkeys' was invented by one of the derided historians, Clarke; this viewpoint was seized on in the swinging 60 s when it was posited by the left who saw it as a good way to undermine all views on WW1. This viewpoint has been universally trashed in the past decade, notably by Corrigan.

Don't forget that Haig was revered by the men who served under him and tens of thousands turned out for his funeral.
 

Seadog

War Hero
Moderator
During the war more than 200 generals were killed, wounded or captured. I bet that didn't happen in their chateaus miles behind their front lines. There is more good stuff in that article.

Like all wars, WW1 was fought with the doctrine and technology available at the time. Massed ranks of archers were the machine gunners of their day. The result of a face to face charge of lines of armed men may have been decided by whose archers got the most, most accurate rounds down from the greatest distance. Little changed over centuries.

Some of those who ridicule Haig just don't like the officer class of any era.
 

finknottle

Banned
This could go on ad infinitum but if my source is correct in 1917 Haig gave the order for a cavalry charge at Arras involving the Household Cavalry. The charge was against heavy machine gun fire and barbed wire; our cavalry were slaughtered by the German defenders. As this was not early on in the war it would appear that Haig had not learnt the lesson that a cavalry charge against modern weapons would be suicidal.

Seadog, you seem to be obsessive in your belief that some service men hate the officer class. Have you considered the possibly that the men would only look upon them with disdain if they were utter tools, tools that do crop up now and again in all ranks.

I do wonder if you had a bad experience during your service? I do hope not as you come across as being a jolly good chap.
 
Last edited:
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
soleil BBC1: 'Britain's Great War' - Monday, 27th January 2014 - 21:00 History 20
MoD_RSS Avian Influenza incursion risk raised to high in Great Britain MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Traffic Commissioners for Great Britain publish 2019-20 annual report MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Government to safeguard vital Great Britain-Northern Ireland air links MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Rail stations across Great Britain receive £20 million funding boost for accessibility improvements MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Traffic Commissioners for Great Britain publish 2018-19 annual report MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Highways England statement following publication of DfT’s Reported road casualties in Great Britain: 2018 report MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Great Britain and China Are Global Partners MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: Hammond tells Davos: “Britain is a great place to do business” MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Speech: Green Great Britain: Climate Policy and Energy Transition MoD News 0
perrym Great Britain Armed Forces Rugby League World Cup Squad Announcement Sports and Adventure Training 3
A Great Britain Diamond Lil's 22
slim Great Britain -- Our role as the worlds policeman Current Affairs 19
MoD_RSS New maps reveal heat stored in Britain’s abandoned coal mines MoD News 0
soleil Channel 5: On Board Britain's Nuclear Submarine: Trident - Wednesday, November 4th 2020 - 9 PM Submariners 25
MoD_RSS 4,500 new Work Coaches to join the frontline to help Britain build back better MoD News 0
MoD_RSS New 'Diversity Built Britain' coin unveiled MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Matt Warman’s Keynote Speech at Connected Britain 2020 MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Hundreds step up to help smaller employers Kickstart Britain’s recovery MoD News 0
soleil BBC4 - Wednesday, September 16th 2020 - 9 pm - Britain's Greatest Pilot: The Extraordinary Story of Captain Winkle Brown The Fleet Air Arm 2
MoD_RSS RAF looks to the future on Battle of Britain Day MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Prevalence of graffiti on Britain’s rail network: letter to Network Rail MoD News 0
MoD_RSS International regulatory cooperation for a global Britain MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Britain’s pension schemes lead on climate risk MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Britain eats out to help out – over 35 million meals claimed in first two weeks MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Home Secretary signals Britain is open for business MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Outside the EU, a bright future awaits Britain MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Rishi's Plan for Jobs will help Britain bounce back MoD News 0
MoD_RSS £1.57 billion investment to protect Britain’s world-class cultural, arts and heritage institutions MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Global Britain and the CPTPP MoD News 0
MoD_RSS PM: A New Deal for Britain MoD News 0
MoD_RSS ‘Build build build’: Prime Minister announces New Deal for Britain MoD News 0
MoD_RSS New plans to get Britain building in coronavirus recovery MoD News 0
D 801(FF) Squadron and the Battle of Britain???? History 40
MoD_RSS Business Secretary launches working groups to help unleash Britain's growth potential MoD News 0
MoD_RSS UK Government and Prince of Wales urge workers to pick fruit and veg for Britain MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Government guidance to help Britain's top sportsmen and women to return to training safely MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Britain’s biggest road project opens to traffic eight months early MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Britain’s biggest network of diagnostic labs are completed in 5 weeks MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Biking for Britain MoD News 0
soleil FB: RNRMC - Happy 100th Birthday Harry Melling - Britain's Oldest WW2 Submariner Submariners 2
MoD_RSS Robert Jenrick plans for the future to get Britain building MoD News 0
MoD_RSS New era of green fuel set to clean up Britain’s roads MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Britain is back: Liz Truss calls for new rules at WTO to tackle unfair trade practices MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Foreign Secretary's first Gulf visit to showcase Britain's strengths MoD News 0
MoD_RSS PM outlines new review to define Britain’s place in the world MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Our message to the world: Britain is open for business MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Britain's jobs boom continues as wages rise MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Spring opening for Britain’s biggest road project MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Britain’s first all-electric bus town to pave the way for green communities of the future MoD News 0
Similar threads


















































New Posts

Top