Navy Net - Royal Navy Community

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Asthma

Well ive been a member on RR for nealy a year now but time is just around the corner until i will go and get my application. Now down to the question, i had asthma when i was 7 will that affect on me joining?

Many Thanks
Luke
 

SILVER_FOX

War Hero
Unlikely - if you haven't suffered since but wise to seek professional advice. Anything you get from RR is (like my comment) likely to be based on best guess ... unless any of the medical types want to offer their thoughts.

SF
 

Ninja_Stoker

War Hero
Moderator
There are times when one feels the message isn't sinking in, no matter what you say:

Chicogiz said:
Hey, i was joining the royal navy to those who remember but i cant :) because my mum will not let me.
Ninja_Stoker said:
No permission, no go.

However, assuming your Mum has changed her mind:

The following has been lifted from the RN Website:

"The Armed Forces require anyone who joins to be medically fit to serve worldwide. New entrants to the Armed Forces undergo intensive training which is physically demanding and mentally taxing. New entrants must be of a robust constitution and free from disease or pre-existing injury to meet this challenge. If you do decide to apply and your application is accepted, you will be required to pass a full medical examination. Your application will be rejected if you fail to meet the minimum acceptable medical standard for entry. Before a Medical Officer examines you, you are asked to declare certain information about your medical history to identify obvious medical conditions for which rejection is automatic. Please note that your application will be rejected if:
You suffer from Epilepsy You suffer from Diabetes You suffer or have suffered from Asthma in the past four years You suffer from Colitis, Crohns Disease, or any other long standing bowel disorder or have had your spleen removed You have ever had a detached retina or corneal transplant You suffer from Rheumatoid Arthritis, or any other bone or joint disordersThe above list is not exhaustive and you may find that your application is rejected due to other medical conditions, not listed, but which are subject to the discretion of the examining doctor or Service Medical Authorities."


When all is said & done the Medical Officer is the person who will give a definitive answer. If they cannot answer your query on the information provided, they will request your medical notes to make a decision. If they cannot make a decision from your notes, they will refer you to a specialist.
Usually they can make a decision without the need to consult medical notes, it's only when there is a borderline issue that further investigation is necessary.

Good luck
 
Ninja_Stoker said:
There are times when one feels the message isn't sinking in, no matter what you say:

Chicogiz said:
Hey, i was joining the royal navy to those who remember but i cant :) because my mum will not let me.
Ninja_Stoker said:
No permission, no go.

However, assuming your Mum has changed her mind:

The following has been lifted from the RN Website:

"The Armed Forces require anyone who joins to be medically fit to serve worldwide. New entrants to the Armed Forces undergo intensive training which is physically demanding and mentally taxing. New entrants must be of a robust constitution and free from disease or pre-existing injury to meet this challenge. If you do decide to apply and your application is accepted, you will be required to pass a full medical examination. Your application will be rejected if you fail to meet the minimum acceptable medical standard for entry. Before a Medical Officer examines you, you are asked to declare certain information about your medical history to identify obvious medical conditions for which rejection is automatic. Please note that your application will be rejected if:
You suffer from Epilepsy You suffer from Diabetes You suffer or have suffered from Asthma in the past four years You suffer from Colitis, Crohns Disease, or any other long standing bowel disorder or have had your spleen removed You have ever had a detached retina or corneal transplant You suffer from Rheumatoid Arthritis, or any other bone or joint disordersThe above list is not exhaustive and you may find that your application is rejected due to other medical conditions, not listed, but which are subject to the discretion of the examining doctor or Service Medical Authorities."


When all is said & done the Medical Officer is the person who will give a definitive answer. If they cannot answer your query on the information provided, they will request your medical notes to make a decision. If they cannot make a decision from your notes, they will refer you to a specialist.
Usually they can make a decision without the need to consult medical notes, it's only when there is a borderline issue that further investigation is necessary.

Good luck

Well m8 i went on HMS Bulwark on saturday with my MUM and she liked it and said she would let me in because the navy personal on the ship was saying what i would be doing etc.
 
A

angrydoc

Guest
Surely one of the attributes we try to eschew in RN personnel is problem solving. The information Ninja Stoker has given (and has repeatedly given on numerous occasions, as people ask questions like this on a near daily basis!) is lifted from the RN website - which everyone can access.

How about using your own initiative once in a while and trying to find out for yourself instead of expecting other people to tell you?

Endex rantex.
 

chirp_single

Badgeman
Just as anyone would expect, an RN doc sloping a simple question. Let me guess, take some bruffen and call me when I have gone on draft.
Anyway I have had asthma for the past 13 years. If you get in and you develop asthma when you are in then they will look after you. But if you have it before you join then you are out before you get in. Unless you have not used ventolin in the last 5 years. Or your doctor can put it off as something else.
 

witsend

MIA
Book Reviewer
There was me sitting on the sofa, Saturday night reading your post about O boats, while the boss watches X factor on sky +, and thinking "it would be just my luck if he joins my boat ( nips my head about everything from how long toenails should be, to how long will it take me to become a WO) and i read you say you have asthma. I believe you may have a VERY hard time becoming a sundodger.
 

chirp_single

Badgeman
Correct. If I could then I would. But as luck may have it I can't. So I will just have to make good with fast promotion, visiting many ports and not stinking of my own s**t. Oh and not being based in Scotland.
SM. nothing a NDB would not take care of.
 

witsend

MIA
Book Reviewer
Me thinks you have a case of mistaken ID Chrip, but now you ve laid you chips on the table, how do you get fast promotion being a steward? hahaha
 

chirp_single

Badgeman
Yes, you got me. I am not one of the select few who can do whatever it is you lot do. I have lots of respect for you lot and like i said, if i could, then i would. But Steward.... come along, you can do better than that!
 
A

angrydoc

Guest
Chirp_single

Read my post. I was not sloping the question - I answer lots of medical questions on this forum and if I don't know the answer I look up the BRs and find out. The initial question had already been answered with casual reference to the RN website by Ninja Stoker. I merely pointed out that if the info is there, why is there a need to ask. And I wouldn't recommend brufen for your asthma - it can set it off.

Your opinion of the medical branch is obviously tarnished - I don't know why - but if you were to get off your high horse and have a look at what is provided for Services personnel compared to what the NHS has to offer you wouldn't be criticising us. I am the first to accept the treatment of medevac'd personnel to Birmingham is far from ideal (see threads passim) but primary health care (ie GP) in the Services is second to none.

The reason we give out a lot of brufen is - shock, horror - the RN is full of people who routinely fall over etc and give themselves soft tissue injuries (sprains, strains, etc), the treatment of which is anti-inflammatories. If you don't want them then stop moaning and get on with it.

Similarly, if you want to spurn the RN Medical Branch completely, feel free to pay to see a civilian GP, wait twice as long for an appointment, and then look forward to a 6 month wait for physiotherapy or potentially longer for referral to secondary (hospital) care. More for the rest of us.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
jjake101 Is it even worth applying with my Asthma history? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 5
A I very very mild asthma can I still join Joining the Royal Navy 3
D Asthma Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
D asthma for AET Joining the Royal Navy 8
CSM00 Asthma + Peak flow Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 2
SeaKing2001 Capita and Asthma Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 10
E Aircrew Asthma - 4 years clear? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 13
S Asthma Health & Fitness 7
A Asthma-Overseas Doctor Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 0
MoD_RSS News story: Better, faster, more personalised asthma treatment MoD News 0
W Asthma and aircraft technicians Health & Fitness 1
B Aircrew Roles and Asthma Joining the Royal Navy 3
Mr_X [Asthma] Can anyone help me find the exact policy regarding Oral Steriods? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 10
N Medical - asthma Health & Fitness 5
A Asthma Joining the Royal Navy 4
Frusciante Pilots and Asthma Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 1
Andrew Thompson Applicants with Asthma Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 7
southernbhoy96 Asthma chances need advice Health & Fitness 10
P Asthma Questions Health & Fitness 1
S Not your average asthma question Health & Fitness 22
J Joining the Royal Marines with asthma Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 1
F Asthma and the Fleet Air Arm (Help!) Health & Fitness 3
4 Asthma thread again Health & Fitness 3
E Asthma Info Health & Fitness 6
A Asthma - Any chance? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 14
C Am i allowed in RN with asthma Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 9
G Medical Discharge due to Asthma Health & Fitness 18
jefferson1666 stupid asthma problems.. sorry angry doc o worry alot about these things.. Health & Fitness 18
R Asthma query - not in FAQs Health & Fitness 5
J asthma and pilots The Fleet Air Arm 9
J asthma and pilots The Fleet Air Arm 1
T asthma Health & Fitness 22
Y Another Asthma Question - Sorry I know its repetative Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 9
XS650BOBBER Asthma Health & Fitness 3
U !Asthma! Yes, I know...You've seen this 100 times before. Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 2
hamisatypeofcheese ASTHMA Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 12
P Asthma query Health & Fitness 8
S Quick question on asthma? Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 4
S Asthma The Fleet Air Arm 6
N Joining Military with Asthma? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 2
M asthma Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 17
E can I join the fleet air arm with asthma? The Fleet Air Arm 5
S asthma Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 14
S On asthma The Fleet Air Arm 18
cmontheroyals asthma The Corps 3
W oh no my asthma!! Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
M Flying and asthma The Fleet Air Arm 18
L Asthma Health & Fitness 7
brazenhussy ASTHMA MAN WINS CASE OVER BAN BY IW FIRE SERVICE The Quarterdeck 8
J Joining the navy after having had Asthma Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 14
Similar threads


















































Top