army vs navy for a doctor

treacle

Newbie
Hi all, apologies if this isn't in the right place, I couldn't decide where to post it. I'm a medical student thinking about getting a cadetship with either the Navy or the army, it means being sponsored through med school and then paying back 8 years after qualifying as a Dr in five years time. I have done all the research I can and been on the relevant acquaint visits but am finding it hard to see past the PR to decide which would suit me (and which I'd suit). I was hoping there may be some doctors out there who can give me any insights or perspectives they may have,and an idea of whether they'd make the same choice if they had their time over. Any input is appreciated. Cheers.
 
Re: army vs navy for a medic

Depends what sort of life you want. At least in navy you get three squares and a bed for the night.
 

treacle

Newbie
Re: army vs navy for a medic

i think thats the crux of the problem, not knowing what sort of life each offers and having to chose without that knowledge of what it will really be like.
 

Full_ahead_both

Midshipman
Re: army vs navy for a medic

As far as I can tell, the initial bits and pieces are the same in both the Army and Navy. Basic training and stuff harder in the Army (lots of trenches and mud) but then the doctoring at the early stages is then the same. I guess the difference kicks in later when the Army will spend a lot of time on operations in field hospitals (there are not enough of them) and the Navy doctors will be more slightly more carefully managed in terms of career etc. You'll still do 6 month deployments but the time ashore will be medically more useful.

All I can suggest is that if you are really serious then ask to spend some time 'in the field' with both types of medic. It's done all the time and a week at sea or a week in a field hospital with the Army should give a less 'doctored' :wink: view of the job.

Hope that helps and where are the medics when you need one?
 
D

Deleted 7

Guest
Re: army vs navy for a medic

Thought the RN's cure for everything was 3 days of ice treatment and Ibrufen?
 

Chalky

Lantern Swinger
Re: army vs navy for a medic

If you get in touch with AMS TA they will arrange an away weekend where you'll follow a medical unit on exercise. Most army medical support is provided either by the TA or by scivvys these days.

PM me if you want any assistance.
 

andym

War Hero
Re: army vs navy for a medic

IMHO the RN MA is a lot better trained than the Army medics.On a lot of ships the medical cover is supplied by Medics not Doctors(or has this changed?)They used to have a Dr onboard the Head Ship so the SNO had the best med cover.I think there are several types of Army medic ranging from almost Stretcher bearers with minimal 1st aid to Combat Medics.Personally i'd find sitting in the cold on Salisbury Plain a most unedifying experience.
 

drwibble

Badgeman
Re: army vs navy for a medic

As far as I can tell, you're asking about being a doctor in the RN or the Army rather than being a medic.

I'm a Navy anaesthetist having joined as a medical cadet at the start of my 3rd year.

Feel free to PM me and ask any questions you might have.

Kate
 

Ventress

Midshipman
Re: army vs navy for a medic

Got to be the RN unless you like sitting in a hole full of mud for weeks on end training to go a desert for 6 months.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
H Army JNCO to Navy Officer Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 4
soleil Army v Navy Rugby Match, May 2nd 2020, Cancellation Sports and Adventure Training 0
O Territorial Army to Navy Paperwork Joining the Royal Navy 1
soleil Plymouth Live: "Royal Navy And British Army Reduce Presence In Caribbean" RFA 3
P Royal Navy or British Army? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 46
soleil Portsmouth News: "HMS Queen Elizabeth: Royal Navy, RAF & Army Form Up For Stunning Remembrance Day Tribute On Deck" The Fleet 3
C Re-joiner Army to Navy Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 21
W Army Navy rugby The Quarterdeck 2
S Unsure of whether to join the Army or Navy Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 5
soleil Forces Network Sports: Army V Navy Babcock Trophy: How To Watch LIVE Sports and Adventure Training 0
Armouredcav18 British Army to Royal Navy transfer Joining the Royal Navy 3
soleil Extra Seats Made Available For Army Navy Match On May 5th 2018 Sports and Adventure Training 0
soleil RNRU: Priority Access to Army v Navy 2019 Tickets Sports and Adventure Training 7
S Army vs. Navy Medicine Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 1
K Transferring from the army to the navy Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 14
C Army to Navy transfer advice. Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 7
J Army v Navy Rugby tickets Social & Reunions 0
sj25105815 Ex Army, joining Navy age 36, going comms tech! Got questions Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 201
AETButler Navy to Army Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 19
Bill6001 Army Reservist transfer to Royal Navy Officer Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
R Army Sgt Vehicle Mechanic (REME) transfer to Royal Navy ME Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 32
Trainer Army Navy Match Current Affairs 62
soleil Army v Navy 2017 Tickets On Sale Sports and Adventure Training 3
D Army to Navy qualified nurse transfer. Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 3
J Army to navy transfer UPO/Careers Office 3
J Army transfer to navy Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 10
Yetiboy48 Do the army release medical info to navy? Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 2
Trainer Army Navy Tickets: FLYING FOX Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 12
I Army to Navy Transfer Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 11
T Transferer from Army to the Navy Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 2
benbass Joining the navy from the army Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 4
S Army Navy 16 - RNR Bash Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 9
Topstop Twickenham Army Navy 2015 Diamond Lil's 9
T FFL to Navy or Army Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 23
cutchmc Army to Navy transfer Marine Engineer Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 44
A Navy vs RAF vs Army pilots? The Fleet Air Arm 13
S RNR Army Navy Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 28
S Army Navy Sat 3rd May Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 5
soleil Shepton/M Journal: "Somerset Flooding: 'Army? We Need The Navy!' Photo Goes Viral" Current Affairs 0
soleil NFF: "Competition: Be a Mascot for the Army V Navy Rugby Union Match" Sports and Adventure Training 0
T Navy vs Army in skiing Sports and Adventure Training 1
Bluebird79 Army vs Navy Rugby 2014 Sports and Adventure Training 54
G Army to Navy The Gash Barge 12
1 army to navy Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 8
soleil HMS Sultan - Army/Navy Combined Training Marine Engineering Course Bases / Shore Est 5
soleil Union Jack Club - Army v Navy Rugby 2013 - April 27th 2013 Sports and Adventure Training 1
MoD_RSS News story: Army and Navy units deploy to Afghanistan MoD News 0
Joint_Force_Harrier Army v Navy Rugby 2013 Sports and Adventure Training 3
Naval_Families_Federation Competition: Be a Mascot for the Army V Navy Rugby Union Match Current Affairs 0
C I want to join the navy but im an army applicant! Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 8
Similar threads


















































Top