Albion & Bulwark in the news

Archangel

Badgeman
Not good for Devonport, regardless. This is set against a backdrop of Portsmouth "demanding" all future frigates, and the Commodore of the base going on record with saying that Pompey would 'get frigates'. It's part of a wider struggle between Babcock and BAE, and the Navy is unfortunately caught in the middle of it.
 
"The government announced "additional work to review national security capabilities" in July - a review by stealth - under the leadership of its national security adviser Mark Sedwill." How reassuring that advice is being taken from a Civil Service pencil neck whose previous relevant experience seems to be the Home Office. So yet another 1SL has been left to paint himself into a corner.
 

Waspie

War Hero
Politics aside.
Ditch the amphibious vessels and you open the door to get rid of Royal.
But hasn't 'goodbye Royal' already been discussed in the corridors of power!!!!!
Doesn't look good either way!
 

Archangel

Badgeman
Politics aside.
Ditch the amphibious vessels and you open the door to get rid of Royal.
But hasn't 'goodbye Royal' already been discussed in the corridors of power!!!!!
Doesn't look good either way!
The cynic in me sees the MOD thinking that this is a perfect solution to their current woes. A £5.2bn shortfall to 2020, and there isn't any more money coming after that.

If you get rid of Albion and Bulwark, you can get rid of the Marines. If you get rid of the Marines, then Portsmouth becomes the predominant naval base and a real conversation is had about Devonport's future. Why keep Devonport if it has no submarines, no frigates, no destroyers and no bootnecks? It's valuable land... probably a couple of billion given the Marine Enterprise Zone that's just sprung up in South Yard beside the dockyard. Would save the MOD a huge financial headache...

Maybe if certain ministers and Sea Lords dropped the "I'm alright Jack" approach, the MOD might realise that there are easier targets for cost-savings.
 

photface

Lantern Swinger
If we get rid of amphibious ships and eventually the Royals we may as well be opening the doors to the country and hanging a neon sign saying 'please invade!'.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Anchor Faced

Lantern Swinger
So if we wanted to save amphibious but had to balance the books where should we cut? (Not being sarcastic, curious as to what people think). Survey? FAA? MCMV? 1 carrier? Less Dreadnaught class?
 
D

Deleted 59428

Guest
If we get rid of amphibious ships and eventually the Royals we may as well be opening the doors to the country and hanging a neon sign saying 'please invade!'.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Who on earth would want to invade us?
 

photface

Lantern Swinger
I don't know! I guess this little chunk of land may be useful to someone! :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Anchor Faced

Lantern Swinger
It could be argued that an amphibious capability isn't just about protecting our green and pleasant land but is also an important offensive capability (Falklands?), power projection tool and large ships like this class have great potential for humanitarian missions...but I guess (keyword here) that can all be done off a QE class too, we shall see
 

photface

Lantern Swinger
It could be argued that an amphibious capability isn't just about protecting our green and pleasant land but is also an important offensive capability (Falklands?), power projection tool and large ships like this class have great potential for humanitarian missions...but I guess (keyword here) that can all be done off a QE class too, we shall see
I would certainly agree that it would be good for offensive ops etc, however, HMS QUEEN ELIZABETH doesn't have the capability to launch an amphibious attack.
From what I have been reading they may be making some significant adjustments to HMS PRINCE OF WALES to enable her for these types of op but will still be relying on external temporary pontoons etc to launch boats from and there will not be any way to launch vehicles.

Does this mean that we will simply be without amphibious capability for a time? Or that there will be an overlap?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Waspie

War Hero
Who on earth would want to invade us?
Do you walk around our fair country?
You have to multi lingual to earwig these days. Even quiet Fraggle has its fair share of Jonny Foreigner living here. We are a cosmopolitan society in Britain. We have been invaded over the past 5 decades, a trickle here a trickle there!
 

wave_dodger

MIA
Book Reviewer
Wow, so much doom and gloom.

My take is that this is a good posture for 1SL to adopt. We know and report we're structurally underfunded to meet the Navy Plan which was agreed at SDSR at the same time as we know and report we're undermanned. These two massive factors are hugely exacerbated by a number of other challenges (that we all know), so 1SL has to present options over how he is going to operate the Navy, against the agreed plan, inside the agreed cost envelope.

He is simply saying he has run out of sensible options and now needs to cease tasking, and his professional opinion (staffed, of course) is that the least worst pain, is to take the LPDs.

This then triggers a huge debate in the centre and in wider London about the need/requirement and benefit of the LPD and of course RM.

Where are the RM now? Highly visible, operating off an 'amphibious' platform in a HADR operation. Useful timing methinks and supports 1SL inferred point.

I think this is a good play, it makes the point about stretch, underfunding and under resourcing - over to the Centre to make the decision.
 
Last edited:
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
jambosun HMS CENTAUR, HMS BULWARK, HMS ALBION - OLD BOOKS History 2
soleil Medics Rugby Challenge - Medical Students v RM - November 5th 2019 - Plymouth Albion RFC Sports and Adventure Training 3
MoD_RSS Press release: Royal Navy Ship HMS Albion to visit Indonesia 22-25 April 2018 MoD News 0
soleil Western Morning News: "Call To Return HMS Albion To Sea – And Save £14m" The Fleet 0
soleil Rugby: Royal Marines v Peninsula Medical School - 8/11/11 - Plymouth Albion Sports and Adventure Training 0
trelawney126 Albion on Extended Readiness until 2016 Current Affairs 6
scouse HMS Albion at Liverpool The Fleet 1
MoD_RSS Echo Leads Britain's Flagship Albion On Gulf Exercise The Fleet 0
soleil Navy News: "HMS Albion Mothers Middleton In The Middle East" The Fleet 0
soleil Guardian: "HMS Albion: 'I Don't Think We Do That Bad A Job' – Video" The Fleet 0
soleil BBC News: "Arab Spring Standby Role For HMS Albion" The Fleet 2
soleil YouTube: Matelots - Duck Sauce - Barbra Streisand ...... & HMS Albion (IFT 2011) The Quarterdeck 56
MoD_RSS HMS Albion Ready For Operations The Fleet 3
soleil Medics v Royal Marines - Plymouth Albion RFC - 02/11/10 Charity 0
soleil Navy News: "Valiant Role For HMS Albion" The Fleet 1
soleil Mirror: "HMS Albion: All You Need To Know" The Fleet 0
soleil Liverpool Echo: "HMS Albion on her way to Liverpool" The Fleet 0
soleil Chronicle: "Crew of HMS Albion to parade through Chester" The Fleet 8
soleil HMS Albion takes up role of fleet amphibious flagship The Fleet 1
soleil Navy News: "Albion on the road to fighting fitness" The Fleet 1
soleil HMS Albion returns to the Fleet after a £26 million re-fit The Fleet 2
M HMS Albion Command The Fleet 6
P Albion v Argyle Current Affairs 1
G HMS Albion The Quarterdeck 14
C HMS Albion next door The Fleet 6
SONAR-BENDER Bulwark - trip to E Berlin Miscellaneous 17
R HMS Bulwark 1960 Chopper droping cars History 2
MoD_RSS News story: Prime Minister marks Armistice Day on HMS Bulwark MoD News 0
MoD_RSS News story: HMS Enterprise to replace HMS Bulwark in the Mediterranean MoD News 11
MoD_RSS News story: HMS Bulwark conducts largest rescue to date MoD News 0
babygravy HMS Bulwark rescues more migrants in Middle East Current Affairs 30
MoD_RSS News story: HMS Bulwark rescues over 400 migrants MoD News 0
MoD_RSS Press release: HMS Bulwark and Merlin helicopters ready for operations in the Mediterranean MoD News 0
Branch-Hopper HMS Bulwark - Med Ops Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 2
dixie_gooner Sailor dies in incident on HMS Bulwark MoD News 20
soleil Herald: "Plymouth-based HMS Bulwark Gets A New Commanding Officer" The Fleet 0
soleil Herald: "Royal Navy Flagship HMS Bulwark To Return To Plymouth On Friday" The Fleet 13
soleil Navy News: "Flagship Bulwark Hosts Navy Seal During Scottish War Games" The Fleet 0
P Defence Minister drops a ball over name of HMS Bulwark Current Affairs 1
soleil YouTube: HMS Bulwark - Aviation The Fleet Air Arm 7
A Bulwark comms mess Social & Reunions 0
MoD_RSS Flagship Bulwark cheers on Navy Olympian Reed Current Affairs 0
soleil Navy News: "Bulwark’s Crew Blag Their Way Across Blighty In Flagship’s Mad Challenge" The Fleet 2
MoD_RSS HMS Bulwark lands commandos in the Arctic Current Affairs 0
soleil Herald: "HMS Bulwark Going To Oslo" The Fleet 1
MoD_RSS HMS Bulwark visits home of German Navy Current Affairs 7
MoD_RSS HMS Bulwark develops her twin Chinook capability Current Affairs 0
MoD_RSS Bulwark takes over as UK flagship Current Affairs 1
soleil Daily Echo: "HMS Bulwark Lined Up For Visit To PSP Southampton Boat Show" The Fleet 1
soleil BBC: "HMS Bulwark Gets Olympic Sailing Command Role" The Fleet 8
Similar threads


















































Latest Threads

New Posts

Top