A Naval Base"Review", a Euphemism for Closure

The MOD announces that review into Naval Bases will begin, am I the only one that think that this is another way of saying Closure/Privatisation?

How can the Navy operate out of just two bases, and which one will go?

Doubtful to be a Scots base as Labour are trying to cling to their support up there, but you cannot close either Pompey or Guzz.

How can they justify shrinking the fleet further and further.

http://www.mod.uk/DefenceInternet/D...nceSecretaryAnnouncesReviewOfUkNavalBases.htm
 
If I remember rightly, Pompey was earmarked for closure in the early eighties. The Falklands war saved it.

It's one of the reasons they have diversified into the heritage industry. It's unwise to have all your irons in the same fire.
 
Hmm, let me see . . Cynical mode on. :p

Rosyth - although officially closed is in Gordon Brown's constituency

Faslane - the PM and his sidekick, together with much of the cabinet are Scots

That leaves Devonport and Portsmouth.

Now, bear in mind that the Government are attempting to move as many Civil Service jobs out of the South East.

I know which Naval Base I'd have my money on for closure!
 
D

Deleted 493

Guest
Okay. Here's my POV.

There is a 'review' of sorts, and the unions are well aware of it. Being as the carrier and 42 squadrons are kinda drying up, and the Chileans are snapping up the 23s, see if you can guess what's happening.

The Dreadnought Paper, is Pompey's justification study into why it should stay open as a Naval Base. When you consider the carriers are refitting in Babcock Rosyth and Gordon is the MP for Dunfirmline East (not west, which is another Labour MP) and certain pledges are in consideration for the LPD ships ... coupled with the fact that the DML biult (and therfore Halliburton-owned) 9 dock has been extensively refitted in Guzz as the refuelling location for the subs, and that Faslane can never shut as long as we have a strategic deterrent, somehow you could put anything ostentatious in the paper yet it still wouldn't be enough. The selling of Fountain Lake Jetty is merely a softener. The core yard workforce has been and will continue to be pared down to **** all. Eventuall it will become a wholly commercial venture with a nautical theme park bolted on to it.

And let's not even talk of a nearby large engineering establishment upping sticks and moving into pongo land before 2012.

Levers
 
There has been a recent poll (in the Scotsman last week I recall) wghich indicated growing support for Scottish independance. In view of this it would be logical to close a Scottish base. Of course what will happen is they will probably close BOTH Pompey & Guzz! I'm surprised we are not seeking to rent naval bases from Libya or Iran. I'm sure both could offer good value deals to the British taxpayer. :roll:
 
Levers_Aligned said:
Gordon is the MP for Dunfirmline East (not west, which is another Labour MP) .

Levers
Dunfermline West is now Lib Dem, as Labour got a spanking in a by election earliier this year. Normally you could pin a red rosette on a monkey, and it would've been voted in, but the worms finally turned.

Babcock Rosyth have been promised the new carriers, but if you notice, no date has been set.
At the moment Babcock seem to paying all the workers off, so it begs the question as to whether the skilled workers to do the work will actually be there.
As to this independance question, the SNP seem to think a navy based on the Norwegian model, based in Faslane and being refitted in Rosyth would suit everybody.

What a shower of tossers.
No matter what flavour!
 
Think you'll find that the Scottish 'independance' won't include any defence changes --Norwegian style or otherwise :lol: :lol:


Scotland is a Sovereign state within the United Kingdom --the Queen is still head of state. The Scots 'parliament ' members are sworn in to honour the Queen.

As for defence --well
they closed Chatham and just about all of the North Sea bases for the simple reason they became untenable due to the exit area's becoming easily blocked --Rosyth is fairly easily defended so it stayed as was.

Portsmouth although traditionaly a RN port is becoming less and less accessable. Its been getting 'run down ' for decades with bases closing and facilities moving elsewhere . The Navy is getting smaller aswell.

Guzz is established at the moment with lots of new investment
Faslane is really getting money spent on it -especially accommodation

So we'll see
 
D

Deleted 493

Guest
Streaky said:
Levers_Aligned said:
Gordon is the MP for Dunfirmline East (not west, which is another Labour MP) .

Levers
Dunfermline West is now Lib Dem, as Labour got a spanking in a by election earliier this year. Normally you could pin a red rosette on a monkey, and it would've been voted in, but the worms finally turned.
Apols for my oversight. She was one of Gordon's inner circle, however.

Babcock Rosyth have been promised the new carriers, but if you notice, no date has been set.
At the moment Babcock seem to paying all the workers off, so it begs the question as to whether the skilled workers to do the work will actually be there.
They laid off hundreds after the Tories decided that the ******* great big hold dug behind Lowden Building wasn't going to be the new nuke refuelling pen back in 1994. That didn't stop the whole yard regenerating and within ten years employing half as many workers with the new BES outfit.

As to this independance question, the SNP seem to think a navy based on the Norwegian model, based in Faslane and being refitted in Rosyth would suit everybody.

What a shower of tossers.
No matter what flavour!
They would, wouldn't they?

Levers
 

dt018a9667

War Hero
Gents please come down to Devonport the story is the same, .don`t these ******* understand?
Are we not an island? (I.e. we are surrounded by water) I think for that you need a navy!!! For protection.
One group springs to mind at once. The civil service (MOD) being the likely culprits me thinks if their past records are anything are to go by.
 
Always_a_Civvy said:
There has been a recent poll (in the Scotsman last week I recall) wghich indicated growing support for Scottish independance.
They'd never vote for it! I believe it has been established that the entire GDP of an independant Scotland wouldn't even pay their current dole bill.
 

Clouseau

Banned
The Naval Base Review will look at the amount of support supplied to the fleet. That doesn't mean closing bases. It means looking at the support and repair facilities afforded by the commercial providers. This review has to be taken as part of the overall UK Defence Industrial Strategy. That is to say that the UK Defence Industrial Base (not just dockyards) has to balance profitability, long term sustainability AND provide UK Defence with the equipment and support it needs.

The question here is not whether we need 3 bases, it is whether we need 3 private firms competeing for dwindling MOD contracts.

It is clear to me, (as an Engineer who has stood by a few refits), that our support base is not balanced with the ships it serves.
 
Ancient_Mariner said:
Always_a_Civvy said:
There has been a recent poll (in the Scotsman last week I recall) wghich indicated growing support for Scottish independance.
They'd never vote for it! I believe it has been established that the entire GDP of an independant Scotland wouldn't even pay their current dole bill.
An where does that stand with secret government reports that indicate that Scotland is a net contributor to Gordons hip pocket. Why do you think Maggie did not dump Scotland all those years ago when she was getting rid of anything that cost the government money? Financially England needs Scotland more than Scotland needs England.

Peter
 

Not_a_boffin

War Hero
Monsieur Clouseau has the right idea methinks, but it might not be as obvious as everyone thinks. It'll be an "interesting" outcome whatever happens. Just have the horrible suspicion it'll end up as usual making conclusions on the wrong assumptions.

Faslane will probably stay as is, if only because of the bomber infrastructure, which leaves a straight Pompey vs Guz fight. You might think it's a re-run of the Nott review of 81, but hold some horses here.

Pompey plus points : big enough jetties to take CVF, big enough jetties to take T45, only UHAF certified to handle Aster. Proximity to Coll / Sultan, VT/BAe presence (marginal plus point!) and plenty of large docks
Pompey negatives : Needs dredging, lots of historic buildings

Guz positives : Nuclear refit facilities, proximity to exercise areas, proximity to Raleigh, amphibs in proximity to Royals

Guz negatives : P1ss poor navigable approach (CVF will never get up there and Smeaton Pass is a limiting factor), very difficult to berth ammunitioned ships near Defiance / SSN, Frigate refit complex too small for T45 (and FSC if we ever get it), only one large dock usable for surface ships

Might be a closer run thing than people think, inlcuding the possibility that all surface ship refit work goes to Pompey, leaving Guz with Subs only.
 

Clouseau

Banned
I think you'll keep the 3 bases but the front line supprt provided by DML, for example, would be lost. This would mean surface ship refits/FTSPs/DDs only in Pompey.......

Or it could be the other way round.......
 
As ever it is a cost cutting excercise and there will be a shuffle and cuts but no closures especially after the Devonport/Rosyth fiasco which still comes back to bite the MOD from time to time. At the same time I have a suspicion that with Scottish Parliament elections next year it is a Labour/MOD ploy to create a scare over Faslane and the associated jobs there. Just watch for the build up to an announcement that Labour has saved Faslane just beofre the election.

Peter
 

Skunkmiester

Lantern Swinger
Do we need 3 bases? If one had to close which one would you choose?

Surely one base on it's own could manage to look after our fleet now that it has been reduced so much (although that would be tactically daft).
 

McHammock

Lantern Swinger
Where have we just spent the most money modernising ?
That's normally a sure sign of imminent closure.


Some people call me an old cynic. I like to think I'm a mature realist !?
 
Mercury, Vernon, Daedalus, Dryad - gone. Dolphin - resurrected as an accommodation centre, but cannot survive. Haslar gone, all bar the shouting. Sultan - rumoured to be going in the not too distant future.

Collingrad - developed to the nines, so an attractive purchase for somebody, no doubt.

Faslane won't be closed, but because of what is based there, not the current Scots hue of the government. Rosyth could cope with the carriers and T45s, so a possibility because of the current Scots hue etc. Guzz would sink into the abyss without the RN, so that's unlikely.

Sorry, Portsmouth - you have most of the history and will survive as a tourist centre, so you are the weakest link - goodbye!
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
soleil Herald:Major defence review casts new shadow over Naval Base Bases / Shore Est 3
W Naval Base Review? Current Affairs 26
Permissionopenmuzzledoor Naval Base Review,Naval Estate Review Current Affairs 65
B Naval Base review again!!! Current Affairs 0
janner Singapore Naval Base circa 1960. History 2
MoD_RSS News story: MOD continues to support regeneration of Porstmouth Naval Base MoD News 0
soleil Herald: "Diver Calls On Devonport Naval Base To Stop Dumping 'Toxic Sludge'" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil Western Morning News: "Have Your Say On New Jetty At City Naval Base" Bases / Shore Est 5
soleil "Beyond The Walls Of Portsmouth Naval Base" - Vintage Bus Tours Bases / Shore Est 6
Seaweed Portsmouth Naval Base revamp plan: Bases / Shore Est 0
trelawney126 USS Freedom based in Changi Naval Base International 4
soleil Shipping Times: "Former Cold War Enemy Visits Clyde Naval Base" Bases / Shore Est 6
soleil Herald: "Flying A Flag For The Naval Base" Bases / Shore Est 0
S Question: Do you have a choice or preference to which Naval Base I would placed on? Bases / Shore Est 25
soleil Pompey News: "Portsmouth Naval Base Commander Steps Down After Just One Year In Role" Bases / Shore Est 2
MoD_RSS Portsmouth Naval Base hosts Olympic Flame Current Affairs 0
soleil Guardian: "Big Job Losses Loom At Devonport Naval Base In Latest MoD Cuts" Bases / Shore Est 0
trelawney126 Devonport Twinned with Kiel Naval Base? Current Affairs 7
soleil Pompey News: "‘Portsmouth Has An Incredible Naval Base’" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil Pompey News: Ex Royal Navy Personnel Can Find Work At Portsmouth Naval Base Job Fair The Afterlife - Resettlement and Jobs 0
MoD_RSS Portsmouth Naval Base staff welcome new road Current Affairs 0
soleil Herald: "Cameron: Devonport To Stay 'Proper' Naval Base" Bases / Shore Est 0
soleil Herald: "Plymouth makes its last stand for its Naval Base" Bases / Shore Est 1
soleil STV: "Glasgow-built Destroyer Sets Sail For Naval Base" The Fleet 0
soleil Herald: "Fly The Flag For City's Naval Base" Bases / Shore Est 5
soleil Daily Echo: Is Portsmouth Naval Base Earmarked For Closure? Bases / Shore Est 18
soleil BBC Hampshire: "Go-ahead for Naval Base Link Road" Bases / Shore Est 1
soleil "Raider heads for HMS Naval base next to Tower of London" The Fleet 3
C Naval Base Visit Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 8
soleil "Naval Base Gears Up To Welcome Giant Carriers" Bases / Shore Est 8
soleil Guzz "Eco-warrior defends naval base nuclear sub scrap plan" Submariners 2
PartTimer "Terror arrest close to naval base" - BBC 29 Jul 09 Current Affairs 10
L Plymouth's Devonport Naval Base loses frigates and submarine Current Affairs 15
P Naval base future revealed Current Affairs 1
Jockroach Naval Base in South Africa History 18
N Visit to Cartegena Naval Base and Spanish MCMV Segura=Pics History 3
Seaweed Chinese naval base Hainan Current Affairs 28
W Jobs moving into Portsmouth Naval Base? Current Affairs 3
A Stumpy's Naval Base savings plan... Sell off Parliament Diamond Lil's 9
soleil RN Website: "Britannia Royal Naval College Lights Up For VE Day" Bases / Shore Est 2
Juliaann99 Naval Nursing Joining Up - Royal Navy Recruiting 4
soleil FB: Naval Service Family & People Support - Downloadable Colouring Sheets Films, Music, TV & All Things Artsy 3
soleil Guardian: "Huge UK Naval Figureheads Rescued From Obscurity To Go On Display" History 14
soleil Afloat: "Large UK Naval Auxiliary Replenishment Ship Completes Special Survey In Merseyside Shipyard" RFA 3
soleil Naval Technology: "HMS Prince of Wales to begin F-35 trials in January 2021" The Fleet 1
BFRS Naval Specialist Training Instructor Opportunities The Afterlife - Resettlement and Jobs 1
soleil Tw: Commander Maritime Reserves - Royal Naval Reserves & Royal Marines Reserve Survey 2020 Royal Naval Reserve (RNR) 0
F Naval nurse selection process Joining the Royal Navy 6
soleil FB: RNAS Culdrose: "820 Naval Air Squadron Training In The Mist" The Fleet Air Arm 1
soleil TwoSix - A Fortnightly 60 Second Update From Across The Naval Service The Fleet 8
Similar threads


















































Top